These people need to go from Origin 3

[m0j0]

lol, are you ratting on Ryan as well?

Not at all. I thought he played well tonight, and the stats back up what you were saying.
I think you're being a bit harsh on Mini, though.
As for Finch, he actually did better than I expected but obviously doesn't belong there ... yet.

 

[KFC]

Hey Moffo have you got any answers for me or are you to weak to respond?

 

[Moffo]

I've come to the conlclusion that Moffo is a TOOL. Replacing Finch is fair enough, I don't think he's ready for origin. But too suggest Mini be punted shows your absolute lack of footballing knowledge.

Have you ever played or coached the game Moffo?

Becasue these ill informed comments that you sprout reeks of Dungeons and Dragons loving, virus programming nerd!

Tell me do you still live at home with Mummy?

Minichello was poor tonight and im not convinced that he did any better than Hornby in game 1. So why shouldn't he be replaced?

I've played the game for several years KFC

A virus programming nerd? lol, good call.

Actually, you'd be surprised what I do, but then again, thats none of your business

Goodnight KFC, take a panadol and some water before you go to bed tonight, you seem quite fired up

Cheers,
Moffo

 

[Johns Magic]

He just has no real argument- nothing to support his case. Whilst Minichiello was not great, that doesn't mean he should be dropped. Webcke wasn't great tonight... should he be dropped?

 

[Moffo]

lol, what argument do you want me to defend?

I answered his questions

 

[Hass]

You can't miss the tackle if you are not close to making it in the first place.

 

[Johns Magic]

Many arguments.
Minichiello made almost 200 metres tonight, and had no mistackles. Whilst his handling was not up to scratch, he had a decent game on the whole. yet he should be dropped?
Tahu and Gidley missed 2 tackles between them, whilst making 28. Tahu was one of only 3 NSW backs to make over 100 metres. Tahu scored 2 tries, Gidley set 2 up. Gidley made a try-saving tackle. Yet they were both hopeless?
Saying"They were crap" is not an argument. It is an opinion. But if statistics are continuously proving you wrong then your arguments are not valid.
So explain to us why all of these players were so bad?

 

[Moffo]

They missed vital tackles at vital times

Sorry johns_magic, but they are the money calls and the things that stick in supporters memories

Cheers,
Moffo

 

[Moffo]

Tahu and Gidley have a great combination, don't get me wrong, but they missed vital tackles and position themselves poorly at times

Go watch the game again

 

[Macca]

I would imagine it will be a Gower/Freddy combo for game III. Finch played far from poorly. Give yourself a triple Moffo.

 

[melon....]

The roosters fans are misunderstanding what im saying

He played ok, but he was too quiet for most of the game and did not have the impact that he was expected to have.

That is my only point. And that comes back to experience. Someone like Shifty has been around long enough to know this.....He has an old head on his shoulders, Finch is still learning the game

LOL, Finch is showing Sherwin how to play the game!!! More try assists, line breaks, tries...you name the stat, Finch kills Sherwin. Moffo, its not 2002 any more...what a great year for both of us!! LOL. But gee Sherwin was good then!! LOLOLOLOL.

 

[aqua_duck]

But they can't tackle mate! Good attackers but shocking defenders

Moffo, your comedic hatred of Matt Gidley is getting beyond the well worn turnstile joke and into the realms of "having no f***ing clue what you're talking about".

M. Gidley

Tackles 23
M/Tackles 1
Errors 0

Don't come to the table unless you've got something to back your opinions up.

lol, he was 1/2 arsed in going for Carlaw and Tonga ran straight over him....2 defensive errors

2 important defensive lapses

Maybe I was watching the wrong game but I can't recall Tonga running over him?

I think this is a case of blaming the usual suspects, Gidley was excellent, he set up 2 tries, saved an absolute certain try as well, and didn't do much wrong in defence, the only defensive ever I can attribute to Tahu/Gidley was the Tonga try when the defence was much too compressed, apart from that they were the only players who looked dangerous, as for replacing them with players who can attack just as well, who might that be, De Vere?

I thought Finch showed he is quite clearly not an origin player yet, his kicking game was poor, most of his kicks were straight to the QLD backs either on the full or on the 1st bounce, his passing was average. I thought Fitzgibbon had a game to forget, he did alot of work but it was a case of quantity rather than quality, and his hands let him down badly. I thought Andrew Ryan did alot of work but alot of his hit ups yielded not much territory. In my honest opinion I thoguth NSW best player was Nathan Hindmarsh, that in and away he put on Willie Tonga was classy, I mean a 2nd rower to do that to a centre, and he gave Flannery a few don't argues as well, and the try he set up for Lewis was also class, Matt Bowen didn't know what hit him.

 

[Moffo]

I would imagine it will be a Gower/Freddy combo for game III. Finch played far from poorly. Give yourself a triple Moffo.

Please read what I say

He went MIA and was not there when we needed him

He was not crap, he just wasn't up to what we needed

 

[Moffo]

The roosters fans are misunderstanding what im saying

He played ok, but he was too quiet for most of the game and did not have the impact that he was expected to have.

That is my only point. And that comes back to experience. Someone like Shifty has been around long enough to know this.....He has an old head on his shoulders, Finch is still learning the game

LOL, Finch is showing Sherwin how to play the game!!! More try assists, line breaks, tries...you name the stat, Finch kills Sherwin. Moffo, its not 2002 any more...what a great year for both of us!! LOL. But gee Sherwin was good then!! LOLOLOLOL.

Do you have short term memory loss?

Ah, it was only 2 weeks ago

 

[aqua_duck]

Tahu scored 2 tries but let 2 very easy ones in. He is a defensive liability as Milchcow said.

Slater stepped around him like he was not there in his first try, then he tapped it onto Carlaw for an easy walk over.

Were you even watching the game mate, Slater's 1st try was an inside ball in the middle of the park, unless Tahu followed him all the way from the wing you quite clearly need to get your eyes checked, and for the record slater beat ryan/fittler and Minicheillo, Slater stepped around like he wasn't there because he was a good 25m away, give yourself an uppercut.

 

[brissyleaguedude]

Hmm a poser for qlders, where the heck is tate gonna go? Tate is mad but tonga n bowman played tops. Slater n sing did great too. HAh bowan was also great when he came on, too many good performances. Id even prolly leave tate out ?

 

[Macca]

Replace Bowman with Tate.

 

[brissyleaguedude]

yeh its wats gonna happen but i reckon bowman played sweet

 

[Pantherjim.]

Luke Rooney - Pass the ball you moron it would have been 12-0 but typical loser you went yourself and got bundled into touch.

p*** off

my god he made a lil mistake f**k no need to tie a bloody noose for him he may not of played his best but who gives ashit he scored a try leave him alone if anyone should go it should be minichello

I wouldn't worry about it P.G. It's only these f*cked-up Roosters supporters that are criticising Rooney. The kid makes one mistake, and it wouldn't matter how many tries or line-breaks he makes... in their opinion he should be booted. They convieniently forget that the supporting player on Rooney's right was well marked... why wouldn't he try and go himself???

If it was up to them... Todd Bryne would be winger in place of Rooney! :lol: :lol: :lol:

Pantherjim.

 

[Leagueguy]

Put Slater at fullback and tate in the centres with bowman and maybe tonga on the wing. Wesser has to go, he had an awful game, he tried hard and was involved but he made 3 awful errors. Slater is a better option at full back.