Brycey
Juniors
- Messages
- 2,110
He didn't say that.The Tank said:That Prelim loss must have really stung.
I bet you can't find that anywhere in the thread...:crazy:
He didn't say that.The Tank said:That Prelim loss must have really stung.
Brycey said:He didn't say that.
I bet you can't find that anywhere in the thread...:crazy:
Brycey said:Which salary cap were they in breach of?
El Diablo said:so you said i said they were cheating yet can't back it up
funny that
El Diablo said:if every club operated like Melbourne then league would die. you keep believing they're somehow helping the game buy poaching players for big bucks instead of developing them and all will be sweet
what a funny little world you live in
dallymessenger said:so we have melbourne storm. a club which plays in a dump of a ground, yet still averages around 11,500 with hardly any away fans making the trip.
parramatta on the other hand are in RL heartland in a modern all seater ground and with the benefit of away fans only average around 3000 more.
the storm have won 2 comps. in 8 years, whilst parra havent won one in 21 years.
the storm have a great history of discovering new talent whilst parra sign timan tahu, a player the newcastle knights spend lots of money developing.
lets be honest, without Parramatta Leagues covering the losses of a poor footy team, the eels wouldnt be around at all. as a footy club, its the eels that would die.
at least the storm are helping the game grow by developing the game in a new market. parra can hardly do well in getting fans in their own area interested.
dallymessenger said:so we have melbourne storm. a club which plays in a dump of a ground, yet still averages around 11,500 with hardly any away fans making the trip.
parramatta on the other hand are in RL heartland in a modern all seater ground and with the benefit of away fans only average around 3000 more.
the storm have won 2 comps. in 8 years, whilst parra havent won one in 21 years.
the storm have a great history of discovering new talent whilst parra sign timan tahu, a player the newcastle knights spend lots of money developing.
lets be honest, without Parramatta Leagues covering the losses of a poor footy team, the eels wouldnt be around at all. as a footy club, its the eels that would die.
at least the storm are helping the game grow by developing the game in a new market. parra can hardly do well in getting fans in their own area interested.
Brycey said:E.D I'm not out to try and destroy your 'credibility' or anything by saying you said something to its exact, once again use your common sense, the general jist of this thread is Melbourne's conduct. I haven't even checked to see if you said it or not, I'd rather argue the issue not the man...if you want to throw some spanners in the works to avoid the subject then go ahhead, your childish games dont work on me.
Ryan - thanks for at least trying to tackle the issue head on. But somehow I don't think this issue of the Woolford Jr relates to the 1st grade salary cap; its the 2nd tier one. I'm not denying Storm hasn't done something wrong in the past, but that issue is first grade, the thing being asked at the moment is how have Melbourne done anything wrong when abiding by (until proven guilty) the 2nd tier salary cap and having the same amount to spend on young players as does Canberra.
Ryan said:to suggest they don't produce juniors is a tad harsh mate.
ED has not even stepped forward to argue the validity of the 2nd tier salary cap with regards to how Melbourne are doing something wrong by signing Woolford Jr when Raiders have spent their fair share of equal money on promising juniors they must want more.eelavation said:Dallymesenger appears to have lost this agruement completely on the basis of continually changing the subject, it doesn't matter how right or wrong ED is, the fact remains that ED is sticking with the topic in a thread that he didn't even create and yet messenger continually changes the subject by bagging off another club and attacking ED!!
pissweak form messenger..
do people accuse your club of poaching top players year after year? yesBrycey said:ED has not even stepped forward to argue the validity of the 2nd tier salary cap with regards to how Melbourne are doing something wrong by signing Woolford Jr when Raiders have spent their fair share of equal money on promising juniors they must want more.
dallymessenger said:the storm have a great history of discovering new talent whilst parra sign timan tahu, a player the newcastle knights spend lots of money developing.
lets be honest, without Parramatta Leagues covering the losses of a poor footy team, the eels wouldnt be around at all. as a footy club, its the eels that would die.
at least the storm are helping the game grow by developing the game in a new market. parra can hardly do well in getting fans in their own area interested.
Brycey said:ED has not even stepped forward to argue the validity of the 2nd tier salary cap with regards to how Melbourne are doing something wrong by signing Woolford Jr when Raiders have spent their fair share of equal money on promising juniors they must want more.
So where are your precious sources to prove your argument.El Diablo said:do people accuse your club of poaching topl players year after year? yes
do they do this? yes
have they been busted rorting the cap? no
Brycey said:So where are your precious sources to prove your argument.
Or is this one of those things called an opinion that you keep going on about. :lol: