Who has the best 1,6,7,9?

[Fiji~Bati]

Id have say the Panthers and Rabbitohs have the best 1,6,7,9
Panthers
1. Lachlan Coote
6. Wade Graham
7. Jarrod Sammut
9. Paul Aiton

Rabbitohs
1. Rhys Wesser
6. Craig Wing
7. Chris Sandow
9. Isaac Luke

 

[Non Terminator]

The Panthers one is too inexperienced and unproven as of yet.

 

[Marshall_magic]

How so? Lawrence untested at #6. Marshall unproven at #7. Simply wanting to believe isn't enough. Besides, the Cronkster says he's in the Halves as per for 09. He said the same thing prior to the 08 season, and he was vindicated by events. Such as they were.

Personally I'm hoping Sheens leaves Lawrence in the centres and Benji at 5/8, and tries Dunley at halfback. Both have shown they can be fantastic players, and skill won't disappear because the number on your jersey changes (they are pretty much irrelevant these days)

 

[Joker's Wild]

Thurston instigated the winning try that won Queensland Origin 08,better?(I should add after losing the halfback of the team and under copious amounts of pressure but whatever).
And Thurston is a halfback,not 17 players and a coach - The fact that the Cows came 15th was due to all of the team and coaching staff.

Lockyer isn't the best in the game,the guy had a huge knee operation he's not even close to his best...Slater is someone that's the best player at the moment.

So when the team he plays in wins its all due to him but if they lose its the combined effort of the 17? Come on Shorts, make your mind up.

 

[Shorty]

Considering I ellaborated in my post that he instigated the winning try...I'd say you're seeing things.
Nice try at creating an argument.

 

[mxlegend99]

The Panthers one is too inexperienced and unproven as of yet.

Yep. That exact same combination with a full season of NRL experience and playing together at that level should be incredible (2010 will be a great year for the Panthers. No Matt Elliott + all of these guys with plenty of experience).

Hopefully they play more good games then bad in 2009 though. If they can scrape us into the top 8 it's a great effort IMO.

 

[The Colonel]

I'm interested to see how

1. McKinno
6. Fien
7. Jones
9. Henderson/Hohaia

goes.

 

[dogz08]

1. Patten
6. Take ya pick
7. Kimmorley
9. Ennis

 

[Liam]

1. Gidley
6. Mullen
7. Dureau
9. De Gois
Will go alright. Best by far is:
1. Slater
6. Taumata
7. Cronk
9. Smith

 

[rupertpupkin]

Personally I'm hoping Sheens leaves Lawrence in the centres and Benji at 5/8, and tries Dunley at halfback.

Agreed. There are a number of possibilities for the Halves in 09. Whether this pans out, or is even seriously tried will remain to be seen.

...Both have shown they can be fantastic players, and skill won't disappear because the number on your jersey changes (they are pretty much irrelevant these days)

But being a "fantastic player" and having "skill" does not automatically translate into "Halfback" or "5/8". The number may not make someone a Halfback, or 5/8. But they have to actually have the ability. Separate from mere general skill.

 

[Nemesis]

LOL

oh dear

you're the kind of guy who has won the "effort award" in every sports presentation night he's ever been involved in

the only one you'd ever get is the "Best Contamination of the Human Gene Pool Award".

 

[Tigers_are_Pro]

I don't rate Thurston at all, useless halfback and fairly good 5/8. Lockyer is a better fullback than 5/8. Best players Imo are Prince, Slater, Smith and Farah.

 

[Loudstrat]

Nope, best by far is Broncos. cutie, Heather,Wallace - there's your best 1 6 7, closely followed by Manly. Inglis ruins the Storms spine - yes, clive churchil blah blah blah - he's a centre or fullkback, not a pivot. Taumata - who the f**k?. Brisbane and Manly aside - none so far listed really grab me.

Without bothering to research club lists - i'm lazy - I think a few clubs outstanding potential spines. Club fans can fill in the blanks.

Titans:
1 Campbell
6 Rogers
7 Prince.
Plenty of speed and skill.

Cowpats
1 Bowen
7 Thurston
2 seasons ago that combo almost won a premiership.

Dragons
1 Hornby
6 Soward
7 Head
9 Hughes
Dunno if that will be their spine, but it's got skill and mongrel all over it.

And I'm a fan of this one:
1 Hayne
6 Mateo
7 Finch
9 Keating
With Burt and Keting Mk 2 to fill in.

 

[EvolutionUber]

I don't rate Thurston at all, useless halfback and fairly good 5/8. Lockyer is a better fullback than 5/8. Best players Imo are Prince, Slater, Smith and Farah.

You don't rate a 2 time dally m medalist, grand final winner, a guy who has 3/4 origin series wins and a guy who has an extremely good winning ratio with Australia? Wow. What does it take then?

 

[Loudstrat]

Tigers contract. He'd be up there with Keith Barnes and Junior Pearce before the ink dried.

 

[Scott Gourley's Lovechild]

Nope, best by far is Broncos. cutie, Heather,Wallace - there's your best 1 6 7, closely followed by Manly. Inglis ruins the Storms spine - yes, clive churchil blah blah blah - he's a centre or fullkback, not a pivot. Taumata - who the f**k?. Brisbane and Manly aside - none so far listed really grab me.

Without bothering to research club lists - i'm lazy - I think a few clubs outstanding potential spines. Club fans can fill in the blanks.

Titans:
1 Campbell
6 Rogers
7 Prince.
Plenty of speed and skill.

Cowpats
1 Bowen
7 Thurston
2 seasons ago that combo almost won a premiership.

Dragons
1 Hornby
6 Soward
7 Head
9 Hughes
Dunno if that will be their spine, but it's got skill and mongrel all over it.

And I'm a fan of this one:
1 Hayne
6 Mateo
7 Finch
9 Keating
With Burt and Keting Mk 2 to fill in.

Corey Hughes signed with Cronulla not St George. Our hookers will be Luke Priddis and Dean Young

 

[Moffo]

Nope, best by far is Broncos. cutie, Heather,Wallace - there's your best 1 6 7, closely followed by Manly. Inglis ruins the Storms spine - yes, clive churchil blah blah blah - he's a centre or fullkback, not a pivot. Taumata - who the f**k?. Brisbane and Manly aside - none so far listed really grab me.

Without bothering to research club lists - i'm lazy - I think a few clubs outstanding potential spines. Club fans can fill in the blanks.

Titans:
1 Campbell
6 Rogers
7 Prince.
Plenty of speed and skill.

Cowpats
1 Bowen
7 Thurston
2 seasons ago that combo almost won a premiership.

Dragons
1 Hornby
6 Soward
7 Head
9 Hughes
Dunno if that will be their spine, but it's got skill and mongrel all over it.

And I'm a fan of this one:
1 Hayne
6 Mateo
7 Finch
9 Keating
With Burt and Keting Mk 2 to fill in.

rogers is a washed up injury prone hack

 

[Shorty]

I adjusted your post for accuracy.

Not trying to create an arguement, just highlighting a clash in points.

Oh you adjusted my post?:? Um...you realise that..is kinda' against the rules....lol idiot.
Grasping at straws.

 

[Noa]

Nope, best by far is Broncos. cutie, Heather,Wallace - there's your best 1 6 7, closely followed by Manly. Inglis ruins the Storms spine - yes, clive churchil blah blah blah - he's a centre or fullkback, not a pivot. Taumata - who the f**k?. Brisbane and Manly aside - none so far listed really grab me.

.

Lol, hands up who wants a ruined spine.

Inglis wasnt outside the best 3-4 5/8's in the game during his time there and when you combine that with the other 3 there's no way the Storms outside the top 2.

But then again you did say the Eels look pretty good :lol:.

 

[roughyedspud]

have you seen leeds rhino's 1,6,7,9 for this season

1. brent webb
6. danny mcguire
7. rob burrow
9. danny buderus


that ain't bad :lol: