Who is the most over-rated player in the NRL?

[10$ Ferret]

Katoni Staggs by a mile. Bloke can't tackle at all and can't defend positionally if he tried.
Would be lucky to play NSW cup for any other team.
I had to laugh at the Broncos thinking of playing him in the halves.

 

[Fangs]

Some accurate calls in this thread. Back in 2014 no less.

On contract value Luciano Leilua and Chad Townsend. Not even worth half the green they are getting paid.

 

[dogz08]

This is where Kalyn Ponga fits

 

[Cheese sandwich]

David Fifita

 

[ohitsyou]

Luke Brooks

 

[hineyrulz]

Anyone Parra have lost this off season.

junior Paulo could be next on this list.

 

[nöyd]

Clunt Githerson

 

[GreenMachine121]

Mitchell Moses

 

[mongoose]

correct answer is Dylan Brown

Gutho and Moses at least do stuff sometimes

 

[Marshall_magic]

Anyone Parra have lost this off season.

junior Paulo could be next on this list.

this. There was a moment I thought RCG would also be on the list of overrated players though I don’t quite know why I felt that way anymore

 

[mxlegend99]

this. There was a moment I thought RCG would also be on the list of overrated players though I don’t quite know why I felt that way anymore

He had a patch of form where his confidence was shattered following two broken jaws. After signing a massive contract which looked bad for him.

But he slowly gained his confidence back and looks a beast for the Eels. Personally I am happy for him. Only time I hope he plays shit is when he faces us.

 

[mozza91]

correct answer is Dylan Brown

Gutho and Moses at least do stuff sometimes

This. Brown does absolutely nothing each week and still gets talked up.

 

[Apey]

Kurt Mann by Adam O'Brien.

 

[Lemon Squash]

He had a patch of form where his confidence was shattered following two broken jaws. After signing a massive contract which looked bad for him.

But he slowly gained his confidence back and looks a beast for the Eels. Personally I am happy for him. Only time I hope he plays shit is when he faces us.

He’s been outstanding and his last month of footy this years was other worldly… he made Tyson Frizell his bitch in that Knights game

 

[Chimp]

Has to be Ponga if he signs for the reported $1.5m. He’s a good player, a player I’d be happy for my club to pay around $800k for, but $1.5m is ridiculous money

 

[blaza88z]

Has to be Ponga if he signs for the reported $1.5m. He’s a good player, a player I’d be happy for my club to pay around $800k for, but $1.5m is ridiculous money

Is that the Dolphins offer?

They'd be getting desperate to get a big name player, time is running out

 

[Lemon Squash]

Off what he dished up this year, Cameron Munster

 

[soc123_au]

Has to be Ponga if he signs for the reported $1.5m. He’s a good player, a player I’d be happy for my club to pay around $800k for, but $1.5m is ridiculous money

That is a shit tonne of strawberry milkshakes.

 

[SBD82]

The correct answer is still Braith Anasta.

 

[mxlegend99]

Has to be Ponga if he signs for the reported $1.5m. He’s a good player, a player I’d be happy for my club to pay around $800k for, but $1.5m is ridiculous money

Wait is the $1.5m per year? I assumed it was a 2 year contract at $750k per season.

No player is worth $1.5m per season. I dont think Ponga is even worth $1m a season TBH. But I could understand that at least.