Who was better ?

[ANTiLAG]

Too tough - even NSW origin team I flip flop between those 2 and Jack.

Ill go with Brasher tonight - because he was so good even when he waas drinking lemonade post game as he was too young to drink the sponsor's product. Hah!

Okay -

As a utility player...

K Hunt or S Berrigan?

 

[Big Pete]

Berrigan easily.

Hunt was only a good fullack, the only decent thing he did as a utility was cream Greg Bird in Origin 2 2008.

Berrigan was a serviceable half/centre and a dynamic dummy half runner.

Jarryd Hayne or Josh Dugan at fullback?

EDIT

Wesser had an astounding 2003 still holds the record for tries in a season for a fullback doesnt he?

That was a great season, but I'd have Bowen's 2007 over it easily. Ahh..2007...what a year for fullbacks.

 

[Didgi]

From what we've seen Dugan. Both have potential to be much more.

Watmough or G. Stewart.

 

[ANTiLAG]

Didgi - we need a question....

 

[Didgi]

Don't know what you're talking about Antilag. :sarcasm:

 

[perverse]

at their respective bests, Watmough is the better player of the 2... and is one of the best forwards in the game when his penalty count is low. Stewart has some handy ball skills and is a good second rower in his own right, and probably more consistent than Watmough... but nowhere near as damaging and explosive.

tbh i think i could safely say Watmough with a full stop.

Anthony Mundine or Terry Campese?

 

[RHCP]

It would be racist not to choose Mundine.

Joel Monaghan or Adam MacDougall?

 

[typicalfan]

The Man had a lot of talent but so does Campese. I would probably prefer Campese if i needed a guy to make the big play otherwise Choc.... So 8/10 Choc.

Paul McGregor or Mark Coyne

 

[typicalfan]

It would be racist not to choose Mundine.

Joel Monaghan or Adam MacDougall?

That comparison is in poor taste lol.

Mad Dog.

 

[anjado]

Paul McGregor over Mark Coyne never really rated him that highly in an attacking sense.

Noel Goldthorpe or Craig Field

 

[muzby]

craig field, more electric..


peter jackson vs steve jackson

 

[Brutus]

craig field, more electric..


peter jackson vs steve jackson

Peter Jackson..did great burnouts when he was one of the boys in blue.

Les Cleal v Don Price

 

[Mr Saab]

Les Cleal
Gavin Robertson vs Michael Slater

 

[Baron Vo Mandor]

Alan Tongue or Nathan Hindmarsh.

 

[typicalfan]

Alan Tongue or Nathan Hindmarsh.

Hindmarsh easily.

Daniel Fitzhenry or Steve Turner

 

[timka4]

Neither, equally bad

 

[anjado]

Steve Turner is miles better everyone says he is sh*t off the back of one bad game. He genuinely plays well in the NRL.

Scott Gourley or Adam Muir

 

[JB]

Muir.
Michael Hancock or Willie Carne

 

[anjado]

Michael Hancock he was around longer.

Robbie O'Davis or Kurt Gidley

 

[ANTiLAG]

Robbie O'Davis. Queenslander

It will be Kidley by the time he retires, though.

Okay -

Mario Fenech or Royce SImmons?