Who was better ?

[RABK]

Fairleigh

Ian Roberts or David Gillespie

 

[gypsy]

Fairleigh

Ian Roberts or David Gillespie

Cement.

Chris Leikvoll or Luke Felsch?

 

[typicalfan]

Cement.

Chris Leikvoll or Luke Felsch?

Leikvoll, just for his massive hit on Webcke.

Paul McGregor or Matt Gidley

 

[attamarrap]

Leikvoll, just for his massive hit on Webcke.

Paul McGregor or Matt Gidley

Mary was the better player imo big strong powerful

Feleti mateo or jim dymock?

 

[Phil_22]

Dymock...

Ok since I'm from Group 19 how about these ones.

Tingha. Blacklock vs Campbell vs Craigie

Armidale. Dean Widders vs Denis Moran vs Craig Smith (Melbourne Storm 99 Gf)

Uralla. Stuart Webb vs Phil Bailey (Inverell)

Moree. Ewan McGrady vs Brad Tighe

 

[anjado]

Campbell
Widders
Bailey
McGrady you could of probably fit at least another dozen McGrady's for Moree.

Mick Neil or Travis Burns

 

[Haffa]

Mick Neil.

Tricky Trindall or Tugger Coleman

 

[sensesmaybenumbed]

Mick Neil all the way.

Edit: Coleman seemed the more balanced player from memory, so Coleman it is.

Mark McGaw or Ryan Girdler?

 

[Walt Flanigan]

Pringle

Dave furner or fairleigh?

Well one was a 2nd rower and the other a front rower.

David Furner was a fanastic player (not so much a coach). Played a lot of footy for NSW and Australia.

Brett Mullins or Anthony Minichiello?

 

[typicalfan]

Mini

Brett Rodwell or Kevin McGuiness

 

[gUt]

Mark McGaw or Ryan Girdler?

You'd have to say points machine Girds.

ET or GI?

 

[sensesmaybenumbed]

Depends on which era GI you name...

At peak, GI.
In terms of longevity, he has a way to go to match ET
Billy Moore or Gary Larson?

 

[typicalfan]

Depends on which era GI you name...

At peak, GI.
In terms of longevity, he has a way to go to match ET
Billy Moore or Gary Larson?

GI at this point is a must. As good as ET was GI is a game breaker of the highest standard. Might have to reconsider if GI fades out or gets struck down.

Gary Larson.

back to

Brett Rodwell or Kevin McGuinness

 

[Loudstrat]

Rodwell. McGuines had talent to burn, but geez he was erratic.

Adrian Morley or Mark Broadhurst?

 

[Doga]

Adrian Morley

SBW or Bradley Clyde

 

[Von]

Mark Broadhurst...simply for that HUUUUGE brawl in the 1981 semi final at the SCG, Manly v Newtown.

The Illawarra spaghetti twins...
Schiffiletti or Piccinelli.
Who was better?

 

[PARRA_FAN]

Clyde. Always a fan when he played for the Raiders. Very good wide running forward.

Bill Peden or Paul Marquet.

 

[typicalfan]

Mark Broadhurst...simply for that HUUUUGE brawl in the 1981 semi final at the SCG, Manly v Newtown.

The Illawarra spaghetti twins...
Schiffiletti or Piccinelli.
Who was better?

Was a fan of Schifilitti sp?

So I go with him

Darrell Trindall or Leo Dynevor

 

[Von]

Tricky Trindall.


Kerry Boustead or Eric Grothe.

COntrasting styles, but both brilliant.

 

[typicalfan]

Tricky Trindall.


Kerry Boustead or Eric Grothe.

COntrasting styles, but both brilliant.

Grothe, pure game breaker

Ben Kennedy or Willie Mason