Who was better ?

[Politis]

I may get shouted down for this, but I would go with the Fredster.

Kenny had unbelievable skills but Fittler wasn't too shabby himself. He also had a few other strings to his bow such as being a 100kg ball player that could take the line on, break tackles and put anyone on the field that run at him on their backside. Not to mention he could put a cutout ball on a dime and had a varied kicking game. And the left foot step close to line was dy-no-mite!

Menzies or Tallis?

Not compairable, Fittler was better in every area of the game! Including achievements.

Bedeurus or Smith?

 

[timka4]

Smith, nice spelling on Buderus btw.

Anasta or Finch

 

[BM1979]

Smith, nice spelling on Buderus btw.

Anasta or Finch

Anasta

Kevin Campion or Michael Luck

 

[Politis]

Smith, nice spelling on Buderus btw.

Anasta or Finch

Hahaha,Yeyeus!
Crocker or The axe..

 

[anjado]

Anasta

Kevin Campion or Michael Luck

Kevin Campion for me though Luck is underrated.

The axe for me Crocker was a very good player though.

Lance Thompson or John Cross

 

[Loudstrat]

Not compairable, Fittler was better in every area of the game! Including achievements.

4 premierships, the two tries in 3 consecutive finals record, the golden boot, the Lance Todd trophy........................

Granted, Bert never spent a night in the Glebe lockup.

 

[Loudstrat]

Cross. For 2 forgettable players, he was less forgettable.

Terry Lamb or Steve Mortimer?

 

[typicalfan]

Cross. For 2 forgettable players, he was less forgettable.

Terry Lamb or Steve Mortimer?

Turvey, although Baa would make a strong case. Mortimer was an origin legend and was immensely talented.

I liked Cross, one of many underrated Steelers.

Interesting stat that Peter Mortimer has more points to his name than Steve despite scoring less tries and Steve having a couple of goals to his name. The change in the scoring system would be the culprit.

Steve Folkes or Jeff Hardy

 

[Loudstrat]

Folkes. A terror in defence.

Chicka or Tingha?

 

[gUt]

Tough call... Tingha for his trysneak abilities.

Offiah or Uate?

 

[typicalfan]

Folkes. A terror in defence.

Chicka or Tingha?

Tough one Chicka was seemingly ageless and scored a great GF try, but Tingha also has a special GF moment albeit in a losing side. For consistency year after year I choose Blacklock.


Andrew Farrar or Ziggy Niszczot

 

[typicalfan]

Tough call... Tingha for his trysneak abilities.

Offiah or Uate?

Uate.... he can tackle

 

[Vic Mackey]

Brasher or Mullins?

 

[BM1979]

Mullins for me

Matt Orford or Craig Polla-Mounter

 

[Sans Souci Sainter]

Mullins for me

Matt Orford or Craig Polla-Mounter

Orford.

Fat little turd has too many runs on the board to be a fluke.


Mick Potter or Luke Patton?

 

[851]

Tough one Chicka was seemingly ageless and scored a great GF try, but Tingha also has a special GF moment albeit in a losing side. For consistency year after year I choose Blacklock.


Andrew Farrar or Ziggy Niszczot

Farrar easy,while Ziggy was good,Farrar was good for years.
Barnhill or Goulay,both underated imho.

 

[Vic Mackey]

Hmm barhill was your tougher get down and dirty player whilst goulay was more of a wide running back rower. I'll probably go barnhill

Brett hodgson or David peachey?

 

[Loudstrat]

Tough one. Hodgeson by the slimmest of margins, only because in twilight years Peach seemed to get cute with his plays.

Sandow or Soward?

 

[Desert Qlder]

Soward by the length of the straight. His game may not be perfect, but at least he shows attention to detail with his kicking game and passing. He's a dangerous runner also. Sandow has yet to demonstrate any consistency or value to his side.

Paul Bowman or Shaun Timmins

 

[Haffa]

Tough one. I think Timmo had more natural ability but was crueled with injuries. Bowman was reliable in attack and defense and didn't miss many games. Timmins at his peak gets the nod.

Ron Coote at Easts or Souths?