Who was better ?

[Vic Mackey]

brasher, he was unbelievable in a terrible, terrible team. if brasher had of played in a successful team in the 90s he would be thought of as one of the greatest ever fullbacks. you only had to look at what he did for nsw to realise how good he really was.

also the only people who rate hindmarsh are parra fans, everyone else knows he is complete garbage.

lazarus or webcke?

 

[typicalfan]

brasher, he was unbelievable in a terrible, terrible team. if brasher had of played in a successful team in the 90s he would be thought of as one of the greatest ever fullbacks. you only had to look at what he did for nsw to realise how good he really was.

also the only people who rate hindmarsh are parra fans, everyone else knows he is complete garbage.

lazarus or webcke?

I am not a Parramatta fan, I just don't base my opinions on garbage like the media and certainly wouldn't rate Thaiday or Watmough ahead of Hindmarsh those two are pretty poor defenders and not natural leaders on the field.

Lazarus comfortably.

Mark O'Neill or Daniel Gartner.

 

[dangerousdave]

brasher, he was unbelievable in a terrible, terrible team. if brasher had of played in a successful team in the 90s he would be thought of as one of the greatest ever fullbacks. you only had to look at what he did for nsw to realise how good he really was.

also the only people who rate hindmarsh are parra fans, everyone else knows he is complete garbage.

lazarus or webcke?

Hard to split em.

Wishart or Brett Dallas

 

[Loudstrat]

Hindmarsh 1999-2005 was a machine, quantity AND quality. Hindmarsh 2006-current? A lot of quantity but not much quality. Watmough, Gallen and Thaiday have been far superior to Hindmarsh the last 5 years, Kennedy and Tallis played Origin until retirement.

Hindy played 100 more first grade games and 3 times more tests than Talls.

I agree about Watmough, Gallen and Thaiday, but I'd say 3 years - and if that makes Hindy after 300 games, 10000 tackles and 30kms gained still the FOUTH best backrower in the NRL - i'd say it's a case of Gordon Who? Oh yeah, Dragons contract cheat!

BTW - Wishy, could kick goals.

And Gartner had real promise.

Folau or Yow Yeh?

 

[Billythekid]

Definitely Folau. There have been few backs in the history of the game who could influence a match as much as he could. When he was on he was simply unstoppable.

This one is probably pretty stupid but Langmack or Mateo.

 

[typicalfan]

Definitely Folau. There have been few backs in the history of the game who could influence a match as much as he could. When he was on he was simply unstoppable.

This one is probably pretty stupid but Langmack or Mateo.

Mateo has better skill but Langmack had as much if not more success in the game. If I wanted one of them in my side I would pick Mateo

Nathan Brown or Jamie Goddard.

 

[RABK]

Goddard, i never rated brown but Goddard was one of the best hookers in the comp in the mid 90's.

Funnier moment? Lance Thompson falling headbutt off tap restart or Laurie Daley stealing Goulds chair on Origin sideline

 

[Noa]

Lazarus pretty easily over.webcke for mine. For a supposedly great prop webcke was dominated in the tackle to often for my liking. You could never say that about Lazarus.

 

[Loudstrat]

Never saw the Thompson incident, but Terry lamb's drop goal to lose by one beats the other.

Chook Herron or Ross Conlon?

 

[typicalfan]

Goddard, i never rated brown but Goddard was one of the best hookers in the comp in the mid 90's.

Funnier moment? Lance Thompson falling headbutt off tap restart or Laurie Daley stealing Goulds chair on Origin sideline

It was Gould stealing Daleys chair.

 

[dangerousdave]

Nathan Brown slap must figure in funny moments

 

[God-King Dean]

*edit*

 

[BM1979]

Nathan Brown slap must figure in funny moments

The ref (Cant Remember which one ) tripping himself up in goal is still worth giggles

 

[Desert Qlder]

Ross Conlon was one of the first round-the-corner goal kickers if memory serves me right. His contribution to the art was substantial so I'm going with him.

Think this one may have been done so apologies if it has - Craig Wing or Shaun Berrigan?

 

[Moffo]

Wing by a fair distance

Rod Silva or Ivan Cleary

 

[Easts R #1]

Ross Conlon was one of the first round-the-corner goal kickers if memory serves me right. His contribution to the art was substantial so I'm going with him.

Think this one may have been done so apologies if it has - Craig Wing or Shaun Berrigan?

Yeh Ross was just that, taught Hazim.
On topic, Wing was better he could win a game. Berrigan is tough but hasn't the class of Wing.

 

[Easts R #1]

Wing by a fair distance

Rod Silva or Ivan Cleary

Tough one, but I'd say Ivan better alrounder.

Sterlo or Johns. sorry if its bin done.

 

[Loudstrat]

Johns. Best player ever.

Phil Blake or Slippery Morris?

 

[Moffo]

phil blake, deadly try scorer on his day

greg florimo or trent barrett

 

[anjado]

Trent Barrett was far more talented than Florimo, Barrett really could of been up there with Daley and Fittler as the best five eighth of the past 20 years but he is nowhere near that level. He is in essence at a similar level to what Florimo was despite having more talent so for me it has to be Florimo.

John Cartwright or Glenn Stewart