Who was better ?

[Loudstrat]

Carty. Great ball player.

MG or SBW?

 

[Bullseye]

Wishart or Carne?

 

[joshie]

Carty. Great ball player.

MG or SBW?

MG, he was more of an all rounder, not mainly a shoulder.

Lewis or Lockyer

 

[gypsy]

MG, he was more of an all rounder, not mainly a shoulder.

Lol. Some opinions on here are funny. SBW was more than a shoulder, he had the best offload going, a great step and was the fastest bulldog over 40 metres. Bit more than a shoulder.
Anyway, each to their own ;-)

 

[seaeagle sam]

The traitor SBW was apretty f**king good


Bunniesman or Doggiesbro?

 

[Moffo]

Bunniesman

Willow or dilmah?

 

[Loudstrat]

MG, he was more of an all rounder, not mainly a shoulder.

Lewis or Lockyer

Lewis. Not many ex Kangaroo wingers turn into great 5/8s and end up one of the first backrowers picked for the blues in Origin!

Bull Bailey or Ryles?

 

[Desert Qlder]

Luke Bailey has been a terrific Front-rower in his career, and he's better than Ryles. When he first came on the scene I thought Bailey could be one of the best, but injury and other factors laid waste to that. Still, GC did the right thing building a forward pack around him. He's been a natural leader and a tireless worker, even though he never quite reached the heights he should have.

Travis Norton or Ashley Harrison?

 

[PARRA_FAN]

Norton was underrated to me, and was glad he was finally recognised being picked for QLD in 2002 having played so well for Bulldogs and also did a great job for the Cowboys.

I think he played in the first Crushers game in 1995.

Speaking of Crushers players:

Craig Teevan or Troy Pezet?

 

[Loudstrat]

Norton was underrated.

Pezet. Any player with a Z in their name is all class in my books.

Les Boyd or Crusher Cleal?

 

[Moffo]

cleal more talented

mcgaw or mcindoe

 

[BM1979]

cleal more talented

mcgaw or mcindoe

McGaw

2010 Saints or 2011 Manly

 

[gypsy]

McGaw

2010 Saints or 2011 Manly

2010 Saints, easily. They were the better team in 2011 as well, Manly were lucky to avoid them in the finals.

Dean Widders or Neville Costigan?

 

[campbo]

Costigan. He has been a big part of QLD's dominance.

Hasler or Toovey (as players obviously - I have never seen Dessie play)

 

[Haffa]

Well Toovey did force Hasler out of Half-back and into a utility role. Hated him except when he wore blue.

Damien Chapman or Jamie Olejenik

 

[Loudstrat]

Olejenik. Sightly better seating position when on the bench..........

Morley or Ellis?

 

[BM1979]

Olejenik. Sightly better seating position when on the bench..........

Morley or Ellis?

I would still favour Morley , Just

Leichhardt or Kogarah

 

[firechild]

I would still favour Morley , Just

Leichhardt or Kogarah

Leichhardt. No merkin Dragons supporters (unless it's Tigers v Dragons which I would not attend).

Stuart or Fitler?

 

[Vic Mackey]

Definetaly Fittler.

Doggiesbro, politis or bunniesman?

 

[Joker's Wild]

3 way tie for deadshit of the century

ET or The Pearl?