Who was better ?

[WaznTheGreat]

Mundine was way better then Campell but people here will say Campell because they hate Mundine and they will use the excuse 'Preston has done it for 45 years" while Mundine didn't play that long even though the question was "Who was better" not "Who played longer"

 

[kbw]

Langer was consistently great for like 14 years, Stuart i thought tailed off a bit towards the end. So it has to be Langer

Preston Campbell or Anthony Mundine

Preston Campbell.
Mainly because he didn't pout, runaway or chuck a wobbly.
He just keeps perservering (sp?) and rises above all the challenges set before him.

Ian Roberts and Paul Harragon

edited to say
so close Muzby
and although I thought Mundine could play, he was never as good as he thought and probably never achieved his potential

 

[to_ddeath]

Campbell. Never dogged the game of RL nor shirk his task in whatever position he played.
When the going got tough for Mundine, boy could he go missing...
Harragon narrowly over Roberts...

Craig Smith or Jason Smith?


T.

 

[WaznTheGreat]

This thread is stupid,people just go against the person they don't like instead of giving there true opinion.


Someone delete this thread.

 

[anjado]

Ian Roberts had aggression and great offloading ability so i will take him.

Greg Florimo or Trent Barrett

 

[muzby]

This thread is stupid,people just go against the person they don't like instead of giving there true opinion.


Someone delete this thread.

easy solution..


click the button below...

 

[muzby]

barrett - had the brilliance whereas flo was just consistent



brad izzard vs craig izzard

 

[Slackboy72]

Brad Izzard but i really couldn't care as to why.

Haynetrain or Simostorm?

 

[84 Baby]

Yeah Peachey was way better. A very decent human being too.

And Hayne isn't? I liked Peachey for the excitement he could bring to a game (kicking the ball back) but Hayne as a footballer on a bad day is lightyears ahead of Peachey at his peak. Gotta pay Muzby's dig at Haynetrain though

 

[timka4]

Matt Bowen or Rhys Wesser

 

[muzby]

rhys wesser - better at turning nothing into something and had better defence


jeremy smith vs brad mackay

 

[Noa]

Matt Bowen or Rhys Wesser

Bowen by a fair margin, can play the role of the modern fb but is also brilliant in the traditional role of being a support man. Wesser could only perform one of those functions and that is what seperates them

 

[Johns Magic]

rhys wesser - better at turning nothing into something and had better defence

wtf?

 

[muzby]

im sorry, here it is in binary:

011100100110100001111001011100110010000001110111
011001010111001101110011011001010111001000100000
001011010010000001100010011001010111010001110100
011001010111001000100000011000010111010000100000
011101000111010101110010011011100110100101101110
011001110010000001101110011011110111010001101000
011010010110111001100111001000000110100101101110
011101000110111100100000011100110110111101101101
011001010111010001101000011010010110111001100111
001000000110000101101110011001000010000001101000
011000010110010000100000011000100110010101110100
011101000110010101110010001000000110010001100101
011001100110010101101110011000110110010100001101
000010100000110100001010

 

[Johns Magic]

Even in binary it's completely f**king stupid.

 

[Russell Crowe's Band]

0100110101000

ah...Wesser vs Bowen. wesser

Matt Rogers vs Hazem Elmasri

 

[muzby]

0100110101000

what? makes no sense..

Matt Rogers vs Hazem Elmasri

el masri. we missed the best of rogers in the nrl



daryl halligan vs luke covell

the challenge of the two blokes who would not have made the grade on their football skills alone..

 

[Russell Crowe's Band]

daryl halligan vs luke covell

the challenge of the two blokes who would not have made the grade on their football skills alone..

disagree

Covell had fluke playes in him.

he also had deceptive afterburner speed.

also, covell was much less of a goal kicker, and therefor more expendable.

Luke Covell FTW

 

[Slackboy72]

I'd plump for Halligan though. Redefined expectations of goalkicking in the modern (i.e. post-Keith Barnes) era.

South Sydney or Parramatta?

 

[Russell Crowe's Band]

parramatta

we beat em all the time.

97 broncos vs 97 knights?