Why is perth bid so secretive?!

[Perth Red]

Perth isn’t as open to rugby league as it was in 95

the turn off due to super league is part of it as is afl being entrenched now more than. 95

a Perth nrl team would be dwarfed by both afl teams

and yet 43k turned out last year, yep seems perth doesnt care for RL at all lol

Most NRL teams are dwarfed by AFL teams. That's just the reality of where the two codes are at.

 

[Wb1234]

lol coming from a self confessed Swans fan........

Western reds going to super league effectively killed off all the good work the arl did to make rugby league a big sport in Perth

and yet 43k turned out last year, yep seems perth doesnt care for RL at all lol

Most NRL teams are dwarfed by AFL teams. That's just the reality of where the two codes are at.

n
When we can add Brisbane 3 they wouldn’t be dwarfed by anyone

nz2 would also be a big club

 

[Dragonwest]

Perth isn’t as open to rugby league as it was in 95

the turn off due to super league is part of it as is afl being entrenched now more than. 95

a Perth nrl team would be dwarfed by both afl teams

hahaha your hilarious, you are literally telling a Perth local who's been in and around Perth Rugby League since birth in 82, grew up playing juniors through the expansion in the 90s and still currently coaching what is what in the Perth Rugby League.

Shhhhhhhh

 

[Wb1234]

hahaha your hilarious, you are literally telling a Perth local who's been in and around Perth Rugby League since birth in 82, grew up playing juniors through the expansion in the 90s and still currently coaching what is what in the Perth Rugby League.

Shhhhhhhh

You’re biggest fanboy has been telling rugby league fans in Sydney and Brisbane what’s best for their game and he’s hardly visited

can Perth ever produce enough juniors to sustain an nrl side ? Cmon you should know as a coach

 

[Maximus]

Wow didn’t know he posts on fumbler sites

that explains a lot

I suspect a lot of the anti pvl posters in here are fumblers and jealous of what he’s done for rugby league

Why do you believe that worshipping him is a requirement to be an NRL fan?

 

[Dragonwest]

You’re biggest fanboy has been telling rugby league fans in Sydney and Brisbane what’s best for their game and he’s hardly visited

can Perth ever produce enough juniors to sustain an nrl side ? Cmon you should know as a coach

I have no relationship to Perth Red nor his comments. How does that make you commenting on something you know nothing about correct?

I've gone into great detail in other threads on what is needed for Perth. Yes Perth can begin to produce NRL talent consistently within 5-10 years with the right infrastructure. Will Perth fill a whole squad, no way .... but it shouldn't have to.

A 5% increase in Australian wide participation via Perth would be an achievable goal within 5 years, who knows past then.

 

[Perth Red]

You’re biggest fanboy has been telling rugby league fans in Sydney and Brisbane what’s best for their game and he’s hardly visited

can Perth ever produce enough juniors to sustain an nrl side ? Cmon you should know as a coach

false argument, no club in the NRL produces first graders from its own local area jnrs that fully sustain it.

 

[Wb1234]

false argument, no club in the NRL produces first graders from its own local area jnrs that fully sustain it.

Panthers are the benchmark

Perth will be the opposite of them

one is a club one is a team

 

[Wb1234]

I have no relationship to Perth Red nor his comments. How does that make you commenting on something you know nothing about correct?

I've gone into great detail in other threads on what is needed for Perth. Yes Perth can begin to produce NRL talent consistently within 5-10 years with the right infrastructure. Will Perth fill a whole squad, no way .... but it shouldn't have to.

A 5% increase in Australian wide participation via Perth would be an achievable goal within 5 years, who knows past then.

Fwiw Perth will be team 19 in the nrl

whatever we post on here has on actual impact on the decision it’s just funny seeing Perth red getting wound up

 

[Perth Red]

Panthers are the benchmark

Perth will be the opposite of them

one is a club one is a team

and it took penrith 50 years!

 

[Wb1234]

and it took penrith 50 years!

So Perth should be producing juniors by around 2080

if an asteroid hasn’t taken us out first

 

[Perth Red]

So Perth should be producing juniors by around 2080

if an asteroid hasn’t taken us out first

well it took penrith that long so maybe. or maybe perth will do better than penrith, only time can tell

 

[Wb1234]

well it took penrith that long so maybe. or maybe perth will do better than penrith, only time can tell

Better than Penrith no chance

Perth will never match Penrith for juniors ever

 

[mongoose]

I'll never understand the warped logic of PR and mongoose. They're saying we should ignore more qualified bids from Brisbane because they want us to have teams in cities that don't care for the game. It's a dumb business strategy.

Perth Red is only going along with this insanity because he lives in Perth. He couldn't give a f**k about the game and expects Brisbane and Sydney to prop up his fantasy.

mongoose goes along with it because he's insecure about RL's position in the Australian sports landscape. He's worried about being teased by AwFuL fans about our lack of presence in Adelaide and Perth. He posts on fumbleball sites. It's such a big deal to him that he thinks anyone who advocates for a third Brisbane team is an "AFL troll!"

When people were fighting over toilet paper during the lock down mongoose was in the kitchen aisle stocking up on alfoil.

worried about being teased lol, are you 12?

 

[Pippen94]

well it took penrith that long so maybe. or maybe perth will do better than penrith, only time can tell

Wait! What?! Penrith have been producing great juniors since before they came into the league..

 

[Perth Red]

Better than Penrith no chance

Perth will never match Penrith for juniors ever

quicker than penrith? You're cooked, you want a perth team to be doing something in a coupe of years it has taken penrith 50 years to achieve

 

[Wb1234]

quicker than penrith? You're cooked, you want a perth team to be doing something in a coupe of years it has taken penrith 50 years to achieve

No I don’t think it’s ever possible for Perth to produce self sustaining juniors or indeed produce juniors in numbers who will play nrl

 

[Perth Red]

No I don’t think it’s ever possible for Perth to produce self sustaining juniors or indeed produce juniors in numbers who will play nrl

becasue you're cooked

 

[Wb1234]

becasue you're cooked

Unless qld nz or png become part of wa no chance

Perth will be another storm bumming juniors from established areas

 

[Perth Red]

Unless qld nz or png become part of wa no chance

Perth will be another storm bumming juniors from established areas

Nostradamus has spoken lol