Will Isaac Luke get suspended ?

[muzby]

souths are my second team.

 

[ek999]

So the conclusion is that reverse psychology by the victim works at the judiciary. Tate cries that he feared for his life, we all have a giggle and no charge. SBW says all is cool bro let him off, judiciary is not going to be told what to do and suspends Luke.

Lol dickhead, Reynolds copped the exact same charge as Luke, and missed a week. He got charged with a grade 2 but got it downgraded to a grade 1 because of Beau Scott's involvement in the tackle

 

[_Johnsy]

Did he lift him, check
Did he get him into a dangerous position, check

Fair suspension.

 

[big hit!]

Koroisau started in 9 games (5 wins, 4 losses) to round 17 (shock loss to the Tits). Luke started the other 7 (4 wins, 3 losses). It was only after their second bye in round 18 that they really hit their straps. Bringing in a bloke who hadn't played all year for one game may have disrupted them significantly, but not a bloke who has played 13 games and started 9. Anyone relying on Luke being out for their lol@souffs fix will be sorely disappointed.

still breaks the continuity though, JM.

the difference towards the back end of this season for Souths in comparison to other two is the variety built in around the ruck. much of this would have been worked on with Luke taking the majority of the reps at training. they've got to a stage with him, Reynolds, Keary and the forwards of being able to get it greased very well. losing the guy who handles the ball on 99% of these plays, and is a master at taking advantage of undisciplined defending arounf the ruck is a huge blow for the rabbits. i'm not even sure if Koroisau has played many games with Keary in as the left-side half considering he was out with the pec injury the same time Luke was missing.

not happy Luke won't be there as a souths fan. but as a fan of the game, he had to be rubbed out for that tackle. lifting, crushers and chicken wings need to be eliminated from the game. the significance of the next match should not be a factor. if only the MRP were consistent in their reports.

 

[Lambretta]

When people start saying shit like "Souths are my second team", that's when it's ridiculous.

You don't have a second team.

In NRL I would have to agree

However for me in English football it's not so clear cut

I grew up in Milton Keynes, which was a new town and one without a team. Therefore most people from that area adopted out of town teams. Liverpool, Chelsea, Arsenal, Tottenham and Man United were popular, as were localish lower league teams such as Watford, Northampton and Luton.

I followed West Ham because a lad in my street was from there and we used to go down to London to watch games together.

However Milton Keynes now has a team and the allure of a home town team from where I grew up means I look for their results as much as West Ham's and when I'm back in England I go and watch the Dons play. I also have a MK Dons scarf and beanie etc. So I would definitely consider them my "second" team.

It's a bit easier when they're both in different divisions - the test will come if they ever play each other. Who will I want to win?

 

[MARSHALL ZHUKOV]

Do the crime do the time- maybe he should have used the following as a defence. Would make as much sence as his he has to put food in his kids mouth defence he used previously

• The unusual gravity forces on the night
• The earths rotation and speed at the precise moment of the tackle
• Global warming

 

[Frank_Grimes]

You see Maher thinks its uber cool to go against the grain and be pro souths. A bit like hipsters think those stupid beards make them look cool. I bet maher has a stupid beard too.

"Stupid beard" - like this?

 

[pantherz9103]

Nothing wrong with a bit of bandwagoning around finals time. Makes it more fun if you can pick a side.

When people start saying shit like "Souths are my second team", that's when it's ridiculous.

You don't have a second team.

I used to rank the teams in order of how much I liked them from first to last when I was younger :lol:

I quite like Souffs compared to other high performing clubs of recent years- the Bullduds, Moanly, Rorters etc They were the original premiers and we need to respect history!

I'm really a Penrith NSW Cup side fan for Sunday but am right behind Souffs to beat the Bullduds and break their drought.

 

[bileduct]

I was just watching James Hooper discussing this on Fox Sports' Back Page and I'm now more certain than ever that he is seriously brain damaged.

The guy contradicted himself numerous times while delivering his spray and the argument essentially boils down to "it's a Grand Final, let him off!" and "the judiciary hasn't been consistent all year, why be consistent now?"

 

[BadSport]

James Hooper is as dumb as a box full of hammers.

 

[Nice Beaver]

Eat shit Isaac Luke

Enjoy your hot chips in the stands grub.

 

[Danny-Boy]

Couldn't have happened to a better grub. Well maybe Josh Reynolds but the joy I'm going to get from seeing his cross eyed head lose the Grand Final will more than make up for it.

 

[BunniesMan]

Jason Maher is a great bloke.

The judiciary is a joke.

/thread.

 

[Nice Beaver]

Jason Maher is a great bloke.

The judiciary is a joke.

/thread.

Judiciary got it spot on.

They didn't give Luke his prior record. He did that himself.

Tough shit.

 

[BunniesMan]

You see Maher thinks its uber cool to go against the grain and be pro souths. A bit like hipsters think those stupid beards make them look cool. I bet maher has a stupid beard too.

"Go against the grain"? Are you high? Most neutral fans are with us. The only place a majority is against us is on here because of the freaks obsessed with me. Supporting Souths is not going against the grain, it's going with the grain.

 

[AlwaysGreen]

"Go against the grain"? Are you high? Most neutral fans are with us. The only place a majority is against us is on here because of the freaks obsessed with me. Supporting Souths is not going against the grain, it's going with the grain.

Most neutral fans would be neutral.

That's my understanding of the word neutral.

 

[Different kind of Rabbit]

Most neutral fans would be neutral.

That's my understanding of the word neutral.

Perth Red will be mighty pissed that this neutral team is somehow involved in the competition before a team from WA.

Perhaps we should relocate them to WA and make everyone happy.

The Perth neutrals... Has a nice ring to it.

 

[Bumble]

our justice system is based on the concept of 'mens rea'...

so i guess that explains why judges wear those crazy wigs & loopy outfits...

Any chance of you wearing a crazy wig and a loopy outfit if Souffs win on Sunday?

 

[muzby]

Perth Red will be mighty pissed that this neutral team is somehow involved in the competition before a team from WA.

Perhaps we should relocate them to WA and make everyone happy.

The Perth neutrals... Has a nice ring to it.

thanks kenny

 

[Nice Beaver]

"Go against the grain"? Are you high? Most neutral fans are with us. The only place a majority is against us is on here because of the freaks obsessed with me. Supporting Souths is not going against the grain, it's going with the grain.

:lol:

Don't flatter yourself princess.