What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Worst season in history

Noname36

First Grade
Messages
7,067
Plus, most crucially, that team tried its f**king guts out every week.

In 05 yes. In the second half of 07 (minus the last game) certainly not. Actually the second half of 2009 was the most disappointing for me. We were headed for the top 4, Smith hands in his resignation and the players decide to start playing like complete cats to get rid of him and we were lucky to limp into the semis before getting flogged the first week.

This season is like a mix of 05 and 07 for mine. Pre-season f**k ups by players, main playmaker getting injured early on, followed by other key players, severe off field issues with the club. However it's also like more like 07 in the sense that we've packed it in and we have a generally shit squad unlike 05 when we knew Joey was coming back.
 

macavity

Referee
Messages
20,680
The same "didn't give a f**k" effort like he gave last week in chasing down the Warriors winger to stop the try?

We would have been belted yesterday without him. I understand he's an easy target, and he is frustrating to watch, but he cops more than his fair share of the blame for the most of it...

Have to agree.

It was a major, game changing blunder yesterday, but he has been our best this year. Effort is not an issue with him.

Our club culture is the worst in the comp. That comes down to the coach and senior players.
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,202
Have to agree.

It was a major, game changing blunder yesterday, but he has been our best this year. Effort is not an issue with him.

Our club culture is the worst in the comp. That comes down to the coach and senior players.

Maca, I didn't realize you smoked crack!?
 

macavity

Referee
Messages
20,680
I think it may have been an issue in a few games but certainly not now. The whole team is morbid but he is still trying. Regardless he has been our best this year on whole.
 

Misanthrope

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
47,627
Have to agree.

It was a major, game changing blunder yesterday, but he has been our best this year. Effort is not an issue with him.

Our club culture is the worst in the comp. That comes down to the coach and senior players.

Boyd has been our best this year?

That's a pretty bold claim. I'd have Cuthbertson and Scott ahead of him by a fair stretch.
 

Frederick

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
27,658
Have to agree.

It was a major, game changing blunder yesterday, but he has been our best this year. Effort is not an issue with him.

Our club culture is the worst in the comp. That comes down to the coach and senior players.

Did you just say Boyd has been our best all year?

You're wrong
 

Zoidberg

First Grade
Messages
6,521
Just doing some calculations and thinking about Gids' binning.

9 points against us in the 10mins
By doing what he did he may have saved us 6 points right there.
If we took the 6 points instead of the 9, final score is 20-20, but we take that conversion opportunity.

End result=Gids needs to go
 

Joker's Wild

Coach
Messages
17,894
The same "didn't give a f**k" effort that conceded the first Simon Mannering try last week because he couldn't have been arsed diving on the ball ahead of a second rower.

He did put his body on he line in a similar scenario yesterday though. Lose ball, 3-4 Tigers going for it and he got in there and covered

The 40/20 non-cover was the only blemish yesterday
 

Misanthrope

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
47,627
He did put his body on he line in a similar scenario yesterday though. Lose ball, 3-4 Tigers going for it and he got in there and covered

The 40/20 non-cover was the only blemish yesterday

Must have missed that. What's his excuse for the piss poor chase on the game-changing 40/20?

I've read some people saying "didn't know". but isn't knowing kind of his f**king job?
 
Messages
11,725
Must have missed that. What's his excuse for the piss poor chase on the game-changing 40/20?

I've read some people saying "didn't know". but isn't knowing kind of his f**king job?

He mustn't have heard the ref call inside but still he had no Tigers players attacking the ball and had plenty of time to pick it up and run with it. F***ing cat he is.
 

Joker's Wild

Coach
Messages
17,894
Must have missed that. What's his excuse for the piss poor chase on the game-changing 40/20?

I've read some people saying "didn't know". but isn't knowing kind of his f**king job?

Unless you hear the refs call, it is near impossible to see from 40+ metres away whether the kick was taken in or out of the 40m zone

He should have gotten to it regardless but its tough to be too critical of him for it
 

Mr_Knightside

Juniors
Messages
2,408
This year has more of a '07 feel to it, at least in '05 when we got that first win on the board we played pretty well for the rest of the year and even beat a few of the top teams if my memory serves me correctly, and I think we even won 6 in a row at one stage too. Actually this is a stat that I heard at some point from channel 9 and I haven't looked it up to verify but apparently in '05 we won the most games for any team that came last in the history of the comp until that point. So when you look at it that way we may have been unlucky to end up with the spoon considering we won 7 or 8 games I think.

'07 got worse and worse as it went on and we just got more and more embarrassing, the last 10 weeks or so was diabolical. This year to me is definitely feeling like that at the moment, doesn't look like we'll be winning any time soon, we could be on track for 9 or 10 straight losses unless another team had a really off day against us, but even then we proved in that manly game that we still can find a way to lose.
 
Messages
17,035
I wonder if anyone here could stand on their own 10m line and be able to tell if a player is 1 foot behind their own 40m line. The blame first and foremost lies with the players not calling the 40/20 out to Darius because he clearly was not aware.

Darius was outstanding yesterday. Probably one of his best games for us. What he did yesterday in attack not one of our current squad would ever be able to pull off except maybe Mullen.
 

Jobdog

Live Update Team
Messages
25,696
It's already our worst ever season as far as watching us is concerned. At least when we lost 13 in a row we had a Cronulla level injury toll (maybe worse) and were without the best player ever.

Now, we have most players on deck, have far better facilities, are not a one man team and have the best coach of the modern era yet our highest paid players are not performing and our terribly basic game plan makes us painful to even watch. What makes it even worse is the fact that we should be building on an awesome finish to last year but are instead competing for the spoon with a side that has almost their entire first choice team out with injury and the ASADA crap constantly hanging over their heads.

Off field dramas don't help but come on, there comes a time when you have to grow a set of plums and man up. If the hard decisions need to be made, make 'em and if blokes need to be told the truth, put it straight on the plodders.

Fingers need to be pointed at each other, not at off field problems. How you handle hardship and tough times is a true test of your character, it defines the person you are. This to me, shows mental weakness in our players which translates to the on field performances were seeing now. These guys get paid huge $$$ $$$ to do what they love don't they? I wish I did.

Leadership and big calls are the only way forward for us now. If the players don't believe in Bennett and the game plan or they want Boyd/Gidley gone but are too afraid to speak up, we'll go nowhere. It's clear something is wrong within the playing group because there's just no way this side should be performing like this and blaming off field problems is getting old fast.
Hammer. Nail.. Head.

The same "didn't give a f**k" effort like he gave last week in chasing down the Warriors winger to stop the try?

We would have been belted yesterday without him. I understand he's an easy target, and he is frustrating to watch, but he cops more than his fair share of the blame for the most of it...
Agree 100%.

Also on that 40/20, the wingers should have been back. Conceding a 40/20 on the 5th tackle is close to a cardinal sin. McManus is as equally to blame as Boyd there.
What made it even worse was there was a delay in the play-the-ball which would have given the wingers time to get back you'd normally think.

I wonder if anyone here could stand on their own 10m line and be able to tell if a player is 1 foot behind their own 40m line. The blame first and foremost lies with the players not calling the 40/20 out to Darius because he clearly was not aware.

Darius was outstanding yesterday. Probably one of his best games for us. What he did yesterday in attack not one of our current squad would ever be able to pull off except maybe Mullen.
CH knows.
 

swarmski

Juniors
Messages
7
I wonder if anyone here could stand on their own 10m line and be able to tell if a player is 1 foot behind their own 40m line. The blame first and foremost lies with the players not calling the 40/20 out to Darius because he clearly was not aware.

Darius was outstanding yesterday. Probably one of his best games for us. What he did yesterday in attack not one of our current squad would ever be able to pull off except maybe Mullen.

I agree. I dont post much on here, more read through the posts, but i feel i needed to add my 2c

Boyd this year for me has been disappointing to say the least. But yesterdays game against the tigers Boyd was by far our best. The passes he made in our 1st 2 tries were phenomenal and he put his body on the line a few times (unlike last week). The 40/20 was from the short side and right on the line. I dont blame Boyd for assuming this one wasnt a 40/20

Gidley on the other hand...
Gidley seems to find a way to destroy our hard work every match. Not only did he lose it for us with that ridiculous sin bin effort... but there were plenty of other moments in the match that showed how much he is dragging us down.

There was once he kicked on tackle 4 where none of our players were expecting it, there was also the 'last play' fiasco. I dunno if it's just me, but we look more aggressive with Clydesdale at the 9.

Dont even get me started on the missed 2 point conversion the other week

ARGH

Serious question...does anyone know how long Gidley has on his contract?
 

Noname36

First Grade
Messages
7,067
Darius was good yesterday. He f**ked up with that 40/20 but I certainly don't blame the loss on him. We wouldn't have been in the game to begin with without him. He's been bog average and lazy most games though. In fact him performing well yesterday actually ticked me off a lot because it shows that he can get involved and be great, but he chooses not to. I don't want to wait for another 100 games before he gets involved again.
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,202
How's this for a fun fact to add to the worst season ever facts;

Our only 2 wins this year are over 14th placed Canberra and the last placed Sharks.
 

Latest posts

Top