Your top 5 overrated players of all time?

[Homo man69]

1, Michael De Vere
2, Liam Fulton ( Tim Sheens love child)
3, Mitchel Pierce
4, Scott Mahon
5, Martin Bella

 

[9701]

Milfdud
Dugan
Hayne
N.Hindmarsh
Fatty

 

[I Bleed Maroon]

1. Josh Jackson

 

[Homo man69]

Milfdud
Dugan
Hayne
N.Hindmarsh
Fatty

I agree with them all except for Hindmarsh. At his best the guy was more underrated. He defence was awesome but what people forget is that in his early days. It was his attack that was phenomenal. The guy was a busting tackles left right and centre. I’m interested to hear your reasons as to why you think he’s overrated? I’m genuinely interested.

 

[Homo man69]

1. Josh Jackson

What I don’t get about Josh Jackson. Is that EVERYONE thinks he’s crap. Yet he keeps getting picked in rep teams?

 

[Fire]

Queensland fullback
Queensland five-eighth
Queensland half back
Queensland hooker
Queensland coach

 

[mxlegend99]

Jack Wighton.
Boyd Fraudner.
Josh Jackson.
Kurt Gidley
Ben Hunt

And ofcourse I'll be first to mention Matt Moylan and Nathan Cleary.

 

[Homo man69]

Jack Wighton.
Boyd Fraudner.
Josh Jackson.
Kurt Gidley
Ben Hunt

And ofcourse I'll be first to mention Matt Moylan and Nathan Cleary.

What happened to Jack Wighton? The guy showed so much promise. Then nothing. I agree bout Moylan and Cleary.

 

[King hit]

Darius Boyd
Kurt Gidley
Daly Cherry Evans
Greg Inglis
Chris Sandow

 

[King hit]

Jack Wighton.
Boyd Fraudner.
Josh Jackson.
Kurt Gidley
Ben Hunt

And ofcourse I'll be first to mention Matt Moylan and Nathan Cleary.

All of this pre hype about players is what leads to people constantly calling Moylan overrated as an example. I remember all of this Lockyer talk about him and that he had the potential to be in the same class but lets be honest. Have you ever heard Moylan ever compare himself to Lockyer before? because of this people are always going to say he is overrated.

 

[mxlegend99]

All of this pre hype about players is what leads to people constantly calling Moylan overrated as an example. I remember all of this Lockyer talk about him and that he had the potential to be in the same class but lets be honest. Have you ever heard Moylan ever compare himself to Lockyer before? because of this people are always going to say he is overrated.

He's probably more comparable to Lockyer off the field then on it. Unlike Lockyer he was kind of shit at most of the fullback duties.

Lockyer was great in both positions. Moylan was always a half out of position.

 

[Captain Apollo]

Jack Wighton.
Boyd Fraudner.
Josh Jackson.
Kurt Gidley
Ben Hunt

And ofcourse I'll be first to mention Matt Moylan and Nathan Cleary.

LOL@ selection of Cordner. Only bloke in your list who has won two NRL Premierships.

 

[TheDalek079]

Greg Inglis

 

[King hit]

I got some abuse back in February on facebook for calling Inglis overrated

 

[Roosters rule]

Matt Moylan

 

[Roosters rule]

Trent supercoach Barrett

 

[WaznTheGreat]

Milfdud
Dugan
Hayne
N.Hindmarsh
Fatty

• 2006: Dally M Rookie of the Year
• 2006: Parramatta Eels Rookie of the Year
• 2007: Dally M Winger of the Year
• 2007: New South Wales Player of the Year
• 2009: RLIF International Player of the Year
• 2009: Dally M Player of the Year
• 2009: Dally M Fullback of the Year
• 2009: New South Wales Player of the Year
• 2009: Parramatta Eels Player of the Year
• 2010: Parramatta Eels Player of the Year
• 2013: Rugby League World Cup Player's Player
• 2013: Rugby League World Cup Top Tryscorer
• 2014: Dally M Player of the Year
• 2014: Dally M Fullback of the Year
• 2014: Dally M Representative Player of the Year
• 2014: Dally M Top Tryscorer (20)
• 2014: New South Wales Player of the Year
• Made NFL roster

How the heck is that overrated? a decade worth of achievements is overrated? You chose to remember his short crap stint at the Titans as opposed to 10 years worth of greatness? LOL

 

[Life's Good]

• 2006: Dally M Rookie of the Year
• 2006: Parramatta Eels Rookie of the Year
• 2007: Dally M Winger of the Year
• 2007: New South Wales Player of the Year
• 2009: RLIF International Player of the Year
• 2009: Dally M Player of the Year
• 2009: Dally M Fullback of the Year
• 2009: New South Wales Player of the Year
• 2009: Parramatta Eels Player of the Year
• 2010: Parramatta Eels Player of the Year
• 2013: Rugby League World Cup Player's Player
• 2013: Rugby League World Cup Top Tryscorer
• 2014: Dally M Player of the Year
• 2014: Dally M Fullback of the Year
• 2014: Dally M Representative Player of the Year
• 2014: Dally M Top Tryscorer (20)
• 2014: New South Wales Player of the Year
• Made NFL roster

How the heck is that overrated? a decade worth of achievements is overrated? You chose to remember his short crap stint at the Titans as opposed to 10 years worth of greatness? LOL

 

[simmo05]

Off the top of my head
Anasta
C. Smiff
M. Moses
Moylan
J. Jackson

 

[typicalfan]

Paul Sironen
Dean Pay
Eric Grothe Jr
Nathan Merritt
Dane Gagai