Old Timer
Coach
- Messages
- 16,973
By any normal logic it is obvious that if you think we shouldn't pay what the going rate is for the 2 players then you are happy for them to leave. You also keep bringing up the inference that last years form or the year before's form has some relevancy in the negotiation and that somehow they should discount themselves to us.Where did I say that I want them to go? They're both playing great at the moment but they played shithouse last year as did the whole team and now they've strung a few wins together they think they're top shit. Our forward pack is what's winning us games because forward packs always win games. Backs simple decide the margin. If they go anywhere else except Melbourne and maybe the Roosters, they'll go backwards.
Now on the basis of your argument that forwards win games that therefore means the forwards also were responsible for all the losses last year and the backs merely accounted for the margin of the loss.
A loss is a loss so the margin had no real meaning, so anything that Dugan and Widdop did was therefore pretty much irrelevant.
So on the basis of your argument that the forwards lost all the games then what did you really expect from Dugan and Widdop? Maybe make the margin of the loss less?
For the record I would love to know how you worked out that Dugan played shit-house last year because if that's what you think I believe your judgement is completely flawed and your football knowledge extremely limited.