09 R2 :: Sat :: Panthers 26 Bulldogs 28 @ CUA

[pantherz9103]

dogs might lose points but penrith won't get them so its little consolation.

We don't know how to win home games and we don't know how to close games out.

Dump Sammutt, Sack Elliot!

 

[AILD]

they had about 8 trainers on the field at the time too.

 

[Angry_eel]

the points will obviously not be taken off.

 

[Raider_69]

the points will go but they won't, nor should they be given to penrith. This has happened before and the points don't get transfered

 

[Y2Eel]

the points will go but they won't, nor should they be given to penrith. This has happened before and the points don't get transfered

But usually the other team doesn't score points while the 14th man is on the field...

 

[dogz08]

Game of the season so far. Bad luck Penrith got some bad calls i'll admit

 

[Ziggy the God]

Dogs will most likely lose the points, but I can't remember where the other side gets the points.

The Panfers have been rorted.

 

[ibeme]

I didn't see the game (don't have Austar anymore), but how does a team end up with 14 players on the field these days? Don't the substitute officials control it all? If so, have the officials stuffed up?

 

[McLovin]

Why shouldn't the Pamfers get the points?? They had the lead before the 14 player incident...

 

[The General]

There was no 14 player incident. Brandy Alexander went off a bit early. Andrew Ryan was off on the other side of the field. Dogs won't lose their points.

And those Panthers fans blaming the ref obviously choose to ignore some of the blatant calls that went against the Dogs.

 

[dogz08]

People on another forum are saying that Ryan was coming off on the other side of the field to where Roberts was coming on...

 

[Russell Crowe's Band]

odd game
thought lewis and sammut very ordinary in the halves, yet penrith were the slightly better team.

if there's 14 on the field could be interesting.

 

[aussies1st]

Although the ref was dodgy the Panthers should have wrapped the game up with the amount of ball they had in the Dogs 20. Very poor last play options.

 

[Big Mick]

And those Panthers fans blaming the ref obviously choose to ignore some of the blatant calls that went against the Dogs.

Even your own supporters said the ref was dodgy....

How about Sammut being called offside from a bomb that he kicked and the try disallowed?

How about the dumb held calls?

 

[griffo346]

and the 14 men on the feild

 

[Pigskin]

Worst game of the season so far. Bad luck Penrith got some bad calls i'll admit

I'll edit your post for you ... surely thats a typo

Oink !

 

[spartan]

penrith had the ball over the try line at least 3 times with none given,that's 18 points and the last try should never have been given,dogs rode their luck all the way today

 

[The General]

Even your own supporters said the ref was dodgy....

How about Sammut being called offside from a bomb that he kicked and the try disallowed?

How about the dumb held calls?

How about the penalty for taking out a Penrith player when he went to intercept the ball when there was nothing in it?

How about the penalty when Ennis dived on the ball after it had cleared the ruck and there was no dummy half?

How about the non call for taking out Kimmorley when he kicked the ball?

See I can come up with a few dodgy calls too when I put my Blue and White goggles on.

and the 14 men on the feild

That's already been cleared. Ryan was walking off on the other side of the field.

 

[Y2Eel]

How about the penalty for taking out a Penrith player when he went to intercept the ball when there was nothing in it?

How about the penalty when Ennis dived on the ball after it had cleared the ruck and there was no dummy half?

How about the non call for taking out Kimmorley when he kicked the ball?

See I can come up with a few dodgy calls too when I put my Blue and White goggles on.



That's already been cleared. Ryan was walking off on the other side of the field.

all were ok by the rules.. The Kimmorley one should have been a penalty going by the last few games..


It has been cleared has it by you?

 

[The General]

all were ok by the rules.. The Kimmorley one should have been a penalty going by the last few games.

And the calls against the Panthers were ok by the rules. Interpretation or not, if the ref calls held you can't play on and score.

It has been cleared has it by you?

No by the Fox commentators and Fox Sports News.