What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

'11 | Rivalry R19 | Sun | Raiders 0-26 Storm | Canberra

R19: CAN v MEL


  • Total voters
    24
  • Poll closed .
Messages
17,822
There was nothing at all wrong with that hit. Not Thompson's fault Kostjasyn is a pussy.

It looked okay when it happened but on the replays it did look like he led with the elbow ??...

I don't have any issues with the tackle...it is league after all.

A good tough game though...Storm looked on their game from the start and IMO Norrie, Duffie and Cronk had strong games.
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
He'll have a case to answer, no doubt
looked a lot worse than it was imo

i dont think it was a cocked elbow, i think he was braced for impact and accidently collected him high. Thats a case to answer but it will be a week or two i think, not a long term suspension
 

bileduct

Coach
Messages
17,832
I'm guessing he'll be cited with a grade 3 reckless high tackle and take an early plea. 300 points = 3 week suspension.

Not sure if he has any carry over points.
 

Ronnie Dobbs

Coach
Messages
17,560
That's giving the Chisholm Tavern a bad rap that it doesn't deserve.

The weird thing is when Melbourne scored, I honestly didn't feel anything. Maybe a little frustration, but the worst thing is that while the Raiders were trying their hardest - and they were trying - Melbourne didn't have to break a sweat. We have the talent, they're putting in the effort so what the f**k is happening? I've defended Furner until now, because God knows we've had plenty of bad luck, but you've got to come up with a better gameplan than that. We've been help to 0 twice this year, and both times we had the exact same gameplan.

Furner has done some brilliant work with bringing our juniors through, but whether he's up to coaching first grade, well I'm just not sure anymore. Im even starting to question how much of last year's good run was Furner and how much was Campese. Regardless, it looks like we're stuck with him. The board see him as a mate rather than an employee and while that's not Dave's fault, its pretty depressing for fans.

This is the worst year I can remember as a Raiders fan. We've equalled our worst ever losing streak, suffered our first ever golden point loss, lost to the Knights and Titans at home - teams who never win in Canberra, lost Campese to a season-ending injury after he had played about 7 minutes of his return game, and to put the icing on the cake we'll probably lose to the Dragons. We've had a board member come out publically and say Furner would have to lose 30 games straight to be sacked... and we're playing like a park football team who have a real big chance of taking out the spoon.

Someone wake me up when this season ends.

Are you a Roos or a Blues man Skeepe?
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
The Dugan will have nightmares about the Canberra score looking like a boil :lol:

Maybe Toddles will stay off the piss and "the worlds best halfback" will stop playing like a gumby, and then who knows, maybe you could end up ahead of us on the ladder

seriously, roosters fans trying to give it to us? You just surrendered a game to lol@souths

id be worrying about your own club before worrying about dugan and us.
 
Messages
886
Maybe Toddles will stay off the piss and "the worlds best halfback" will stop playing like a gumby, and then who knows, maybe you could end up ahead of us on the ladder

seriously, roosters fans trying to give it to us? You just surrendered a game to lol@souths

id be worrying about your own club before worrying about dugan and us.

Ouch... I didn't even know he was a Roosters fan before his comedic comments. :lol:
 

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,358
Bronson Harrison was statistically was one of the best back rowers in the game last year and the year prior, which is why he's usually a walk up start for NZ. Unfortunately his season has been diabolical. Im not sure how to remedy this, aside from the emergency of Josh Papalii, to replace him
Harrison likes to play wider of the ruck in attack and run hard lines.

That's what he did last year off Campese and he was devastating every time.

This year it seems he's being pushed further in field, thus taking his attacking trump card away from him. In attack he should be used like a centre when within 20 metres of the tryline. Instead he's lining up to take hit ups near the props.

He needs to get good service from the 6, 7 and 9.

That's his problem.

Canberra's go forward is woeful and that is whats killing them. It's woeful because Tongue plays in slow motion. Should have had Orford at Hooker.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,720
Whats with all the anti-raiders fans in here?

Everyone on LU hates the Dragons and the Eels just because we have so many fans on this board but the Raiders fans on here bring it on themselves.

There's only about three of them and 100% of those are f**kwits.
 

bottle

Coach
Messages
14,126
Everyone on LU hates the Dragons and the Eels just because we have so many fans on this board but the Raiders fans on here bring it on themselves.

There's only about three of them and 100% of those are f**kwits.

Vossy would say -

9 out of 10 times that would be 100% right
 
Top