'15 | R5 | Fri 4pm | CBY 17-18 SOU | ANZ

[typicalfan]

My exact point, taking out a players legs isn't by definition a reportable offence. Each incident needs to be judged on its own merits.

Says who?

 

[gronkathon]

Reynolds generally looks like he is going to be out for 3 years every time he clutched at anything. Without any scans such a estimate is nothing more than Maguire trying to justify the penalty in the press conference

That may very well be the case

 

[BranVan3000]

You know that blood flows right? Blood being on his face does not actually mean he was cut there.

The blood flowed around his ear and onto his right cheek. Morris's foot was at best within a couple inches of the left side of Luke's face

It was on the left side of his forehead

 

[Game_Breaker]

The on-field ref asked the video ref to look at it, as is their right in a potential point-scoring play.

The field goal missed, the ref missed the incident

The incident wasn't even worthy of a report so it's play on

 

[BranVan3000]

Reynolds generally looks like he is going to be out for 3 years every time he clutched at anything. Without any scans such a estimate is nothing more than Maguire trying to justify the penalty in the press conference

Lmao you truly are a mediocre person :lol:

 

[ram raid]

You know that blood flows right? Blood being on his face does not actually mean he was cut there.

The blood flowed around his ear and onto his right cheek. Morris's foot was at best within a couple inches of the left side of Luke's face

Andrew Webster said in his half time injury report thingy that Luke was wounded both sides of his head. Common sense would suggest to me that both would would have bled.

 

[The Colonel]

Reynolds looking at being out for up to 4 months

:lol:

How have they the scans back within an hour of the game? He's obviously injured but please....

 

[skeepe]

The field goal missed, the ref missed the incident

The incident wasn't even worthy of a report so it's play on

That's what you think, fair enough, the rules of the game say otherwise though.

 

[ram raid]

Reynolds generally looks like he is going to be out for 3 years every time he clutched at anything. Without any scans such a estimate is nothing more than Maguire trying to justify the penalty in the press conference

Madge didn't say anything like that in the press conference.

 

[gronkathon]

:lol:

How have they the scans back within an hour of the game? He's obviously injured but please....

I can only say what the reports are

 

[BranVan3000]

:lol:

How have they the scans back within an hour of the game? He's obviously injured but please....

I hope you're right, but I imagine trained medical staff can tell the nature of an injury pretty easily.

 

[Game_Breaker]

That's what you think, fair enough, the rules of the game say otherwise though.

The rules don't say the video ref can award penalties whenever they feel like

They have to be a reportable offense

 

[The Colonel]

I can only say what the reports are

I don't doubt that. I do doubt that a diagnosis can be made within an hour of the game finishing....

 

[Mr Spock!]

Of course if the Dogs took the 2 points in front at 16-14, they probably would have won or at least gone into extra time.

 

[Game_Breaker]

I hope you're right, but I imagine trained medical staff can tell the nature of an injury pretty easily.

Trained medical staff wait for scans

 

[Usain Bolt]

Penalty decision was correct.

Can't really blame the Dogs fans for the way they behave, they're just tryna be like their captain.

Grubby club with a grubby culture.

 

[typicalfan]

The rules don't say the video ref can award penalties whenever they feel like

They have to be a reportable offense

And where is the evidence that it is not a reportable offense?

 

[Mr Spock!]

I don't doubt that. I do doubt that a diagnosis can be made within an hour of the game finishing....

Be real. You hear it all the time. Sports physios can diagnose and tell how long a player will be out before scans (eg if he's done is cruciate ligament)

 

[Card Shark]

Reynolds generally looks like he is going to be out for 3 years every time he clutched at anything. Without any scans such a estimate is nothing more than Maguire trying to justify the penalty in the press conference

Very cynical but very true.

 

[RWB]

Says who?

Says precedence.

Unless you have that link I originally asked for where all taking out of the legs are reportable offences?