What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

18th club, whose next?

MugaB

Coach
Messages
13,738
Better clubs than Penrith were killed off bc Penrith went to super league (some were fellow sl clubs)

had the dragons or south’s gone to super league they would spared the merge

utimately Penrith came good as a club justifying the decision to keep them but it was wrong in 98
Justify all you like, we are all 17 tribes... survival of the fittest... apocalypse now!... there is no loyalty, never has been.. ask your fellow neighbours Balmain newtown, glebe and easts, how the scabs of south sydney go to grab their victories... by any means nessesary, took the easts junoir territory, conspired to kick out glebe, took over newtown and kicked off to no one in a GF, the day they agreed to protest against RU with balmain
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
67,532
It's history, but also the creation being organic & coming from the community. Afl setting up in gws coz they want in on western Sydney market & will hope to develop fans later is plastic.
Biggest NRl clubs: Broncos, Storm, Cowboys, Warriors would all be in top 10. Go the plastic fantastics!
For every Titans there is a Manly lol
 

Wb1234

Referee
Messages
28,860
Justify all you like, we are all 17 tribes... survival of the fittest... apocalypse now!... there is no loyalty, never has been.. ask your fellow neighbours Balmain newtown, glebe and easts, how the scabs of south sydney go to grab their victories... by any means nessesary, took the easts junoir territory, conspired to kick out glebe, took over newtown and kicked off to no one in a GF, the day they agreed to protest against RU with balmain
Balmain was my team growing up lol

but after south’s took on the evil empire and won I adopted them too

if Penrith keep winning comps they will one day have the same history as souths the dragons or Balmain
 

MugaB

Coach
Messages
13,738
Trope that superleague killed everything is bs
It stopped growth, a growth where the game was popular, but not rich... it was inevitable that the game would out grow just sydney and that we carried 12 teams whilst introducing the rest of the country and NZ, still they say we should shrink sydney further... when its our best asset being so entrenched in this city as the fumblers have Melbourne in theirs, I'll be happy to concede a team move on from sydney, when AFL do the same, but not before, even then it would be pointless, as locations are just labels, and all teams could be cairns or darwin as long they are still the same rosters being bought... yes locations have different advantages, some are better at recruiting than canberra, or Newcastle, but in the end the roster is the team, based wherever... representing whoever, and there is 17 of them
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
67,532
Yeah but comp doesn't exist without Sydney & Brisbane viewers
Nor does it make as much money without those other clubs. You see outside of your simple head the NRL is multi faceted and different clubs bring different value to the NRL.
 

MugaB

Coach
Messages
13,738
Balmain was my team growing up lol

but after south’s took on the evil empire and won I adopted them too

if Penrith keep winning comps they will one day have the same history as souths the dragons or Balmain
Again history dependent on whos around to tell it,
Its rustys souths.... Illawarra Stmerge dragons, and WESTS...

1909 scabs... surely being a Balmain fan you know of this?
 

MugaB

Coach
Messages
13,738
That makes no sense unless your suggesting another Auckland team? If having two teams in the same country/state made a difference then Cowboys and/or Titans would have had the same impact much earlier.
Personally if there was to be a 2nd nz team, its where id put it, Hamilton maybe, South Auckland,
It is the largest population in that country, surely can take on 2 clubs... im not advocating that over perth or png etc, just saying fish where the fish are, create a local derby, and use the chiefs home ground.. or better yet eden park
 
Last edited:

Wb1234

Referee
Messages
28,860
Nrl without south’s was such a plastic competition

it’s why news ltd allowed them to stay in after they won the appeal
 
Top