2016 Match Review Committee / Judiciary

[BWNB]

Nice win to end Parkers career.

 

[I Bleed Maroon]

I love how the same merkins who gave Parker shit after getting kicked in the head by Kasiano are now blowing up deluxe about Roberts kick. Absolute immaterial wankers.

 

[Tenacious Titans]

Sorry Broncos fans but Parker HAS to go for this ---

 

[Pete Cash]

I love how the same merkins who gave Parker shit after getting kicked in the head by Kasiano are now blowing up deluxe about Roberts kick. Absolute immaterial wankers.

I thought kasiano should have got a tougher charge. Next conspiracy theory ibm

 

[Timmah]

Wonder if Corey Parker tried to apologise to Ryan James for that headbutt?

Or if James accepted said apology...

 

[myrrh ken]

I love how the same merkins who gave Parker shit after getting kicked in the head by Kasiano are now blowing up deluxe about Roberts kick. Absolute immaterial wankers.

Almost as funny as that one bloke blowing up about kasiano thinking the roberts kick is fine.

 

[myrrh ken]

If parker and roberts arent given at least a week each, the game is well and truly f**ked

 

[Pete Cash]

It should have been dealt with on the field with a send off. Its not like he kicked him hard but he did kick him.

Its a grade 1 kick imo. I wouldnt be shocked if there was no charge though

 

[Red Bear]

The kasiano kick rightly got a suspension, should've had more. The Roberts one was even more blatent. Should have been sent off. Should go straight to judiciary. No place in the game for that.

 

[Maximus]

I love how the same merkins who gave Parker shit after getting kicked in the head by Kasiano are now blowing up deluxe about Roberts kick. Absolute immaterial wankers.

Except everyone but some Bulldogs fans thought Kasiano should have gotten a long suspension. Lol at you trying to claim everyone else is a hypocrite when it is only you.

 

[Shorty]

If parker and roberts arent given at least a week each, the game is well and truly f**ked

They'll both play next week bank on it.

 

[myrrh ken]

They'll both play next week bank on it.

Ive searched my feelings and i know it to be true

 

[Pete Cash]

Id have a hard time charging parker for anything. What would he even be charged with? Striking? Contrary conduct . Either way its a nothing burger. A grade 1 striking at worst.

Roberts though did kick and it would be rough if he didnt get a charge. Players are starting to push their luck in this area imo

 

[TheFrog]

I just don't know how Roberts can avoid the charge, to be honest. It was 100% cut and dried. Parker will be right. He gets away with this sort of thing most weeks.

 

[Shorty]

If both Ennis and Wighton can get off with quite clear shoulder charges, I don't see Roberts getting charged.

 

[Pete Cash]

If both Ennis and Wighton can get off with quite clear shoulder charges, I don't see Roberts getting charged.

They both got off on a technicality because the nrl rules are poorly written. A kick is a kick.

 

[no name]

They both got off on a technicality because the nrl rules are poorly written. A kick is a kick.

Cue the Buettner 3 step Kicking criteria.
1) use of foot (guilty)
2) make forceful contact (guilty)
3) back lift past 90 degree angle (not guilty)

No charge.

 

[gcboyz]

Roberts should have been sent off. The refs chose to "not see" . Both refs need to be dropped as they are either incompetent or cheats. The bunker must have been asleep as well.

 

[Surely]

Well if he doesn't cop a suspension then the players will know punching is a no no but a boot is ok.

 

[jc155776]

Greg Bird copped a massive suspension for a knee to Shane Martinee that about the same force haha.

What an idiot young Bird was.

Still, obviously it was Martinees fault for not clear if the ruck.