What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2017 NRL Club Membership

Raiderdave

First Grade
Messages
7,990
LOL "we should only compare the restructured comp because going any further back completely destroys my flimsy argument"

lol
my argument is flimsy is it ?
id of thought comparing the NSL ....nothing but a collection of historical ethnic disputes usually ending in violence at most games
to a group of generic franchises in a completely different set up to disprove an argument

was a flimsy effort bozo : )
 

Tiger5150

Bench
Messages
3,761
well youve essentially said it again lol ...
ill call stupidity out where ever i see it
& im seeing plenty from you

again for our dim witted friend
why should RL crowds have increased that much , when no codes crowds have increased all that much in the last 20 years , mainly due to the set ups of the comps , teams involved , & broadcasting being widely available to most people so they don't have to attend games to actually see matches like they did 20 years ago & of course where RL is concerned , Monday & or Thursday night games.
All have had an effect.

but no ... please by all means plead your innocence
then repeat your flawed ridiculous views again lol

Why should RL crowds have increased that much? Maybe if you actually read my original post, or bother to go back and re-read my post instead of hijacking this thread for your own stupid childish agenda, you would realise that that was MY WHOLE POINT. 20 YEARS AGO, my club and others (remember the Sydney Bulldogs, Sydney City Roosters) put themselves through a lot of upheaval and pain in order to make a massive difference to crowds. It didnt work. In fact the opposite happened forthe Tigers. THATS THE POINT. Subsequent to this a lot has been done and tried in order to change things and crowds havent really risen proportionally. You can post all kinds of "stats" but the fact of the matter is EVERYTHING ELSE has risen exponentially. Sydney's population, the grants to the clubs have more than tripled in that time, club turnover at leat doubled, salary caps doubled, TV ratings probably doubled.......crowds have crept up marginally relative.

I stand by what I said about other codes in the context of what I have said above and point out that AFL crowds are double NRL. If you told me 20 years ago that the Swans would average 33K and double the average NRL game in Sydney (at least) I would laugh. If you told me that soccer's average crowds would be neck & neck (within 3K) of NRL average crowd I would have pissed myself. If you told me that a Sydney soccer team (WSW) would have average crowds app 4-5K MORE than any Sydney NRL team I would have taken you to a doctor. All of these are now facts.

Raiderdave your hijacking of this post highlights for me one of my pets hates about RL. I am a RL fan. In winter I only follow RL. I have never been to a AFL game or an A League game, Ive seen a super rugby game becuase I got free tickets. RL is my game. But I cannot understand or cop this stupid, childish, insecurity that comes with so many RL fans that its a competition between RL and every other winter code. If you say something good about another code RL must be defended, a criticism of RL must be countered with a corresponding slam down of (GAY)FL. Its small minded bullshit. RL is my game, I cant tolerate any of the others, but I can cleary see that they are all run more professionally than RL, Infact I think RL is at risk of becoming a bogan backwater in Aus professional sport, but thats another thread. Its still my favourite winter sport.
 

Raiderdave

First Grade
Messages
7,990
Why should RL crowds have increased that much? Maybe if you actually read my original post, or bother to go back and re-read my post instead of hijacking this thread for your own stupid childish agenda, you would realise that that was MY WHOLE POINT. 20 YEARS AGO, my club and others (remember the Sydney Bulldogs, Sydney City Roosters) put themselves through a lot of upheaval and pain in order to make a massive difference to crowds. It didnt work. In fact the opposite happened forthe Tigers. THATS THE POINT. Subsequent to this a lot has been done and tried in order to change things and crowds havent really risen proportionally. You can post all kinds of "stats" but the fact of the matter is EVERYTHING ELSE has risen exponentially. Sydney's population, the grants to the clubs have more than tripled in that time, club turnover at leat doubled, salary caps doubled, TV ratings probably doubled.......crowds have crept up marginally relative.

I stand by what I said about other codes in the context of what I have said above and point out that AFL crowds are double NRL. If you told me 20 years ago that the Swans would average 33K and double the average NRL game in Sydney (at least) I would laugh. If you told me that soccer's average crowds would be neck & neck (within 3K) of NRL average crowd I would have pissed myself. If you told me that a Sydney soccer team (WSW) would have average crowds app 4-5K MORE than any Sydney NRL team I would have taken you to a doctor. All of these are now facts.

Raiderdave your hijacking of this post highlights for me one of my pets hates about RL. I am a RL fan. In winter I only follow RL. I have never been to a AFL game or an A League game, Ive seen a super rugby game becuase I got free tickets. RL is my game. But I cannot understand or cop this stupid, childish, insecurity that comes with so many RL fans that its a competition between RL and every other winter code. If you say something good about another code RL must be defended, a criticism of RL must be countered with a corresponding slam down of (GAY)FL. Its small minded bullshit. RL is my game, I cant tolerate any of the others, but I can cleary see that they are all run more professionally than RL, Infact I think RL is at risk of becoming a bogan backwater in Aus professional sport, but thats another thread. Its still my favourite winter sport.

afl crowds have always been double rl crowds , nothing has changed much there
also...
why would you have laughed 20 odd years ago if you were told the swans would have averaged 33K in 2016
when they also did that 30 years ago ??...
It was true back then & still is , that snoody up themselves eastern suburbs types who would never attend an RL game because it is beneath them & they believe all RL fans are bogans , coupled with the large ex pat sthn australian population in sydney who need to get their live fix of men in singlets & tight shorts
that the support for a succesful sydney afl side was there , all the afl needed to do was keep them succesful
so manipulation of their salary cap has done that. the fact no one watches them on TV shows how much depth of support there is
Same for the WSW & waratahs at a point about 12 years ago , thin on top support
nothing underneath

but again
you're using individual examples of teams to prove your point about codes
fact is
RL , the NSWRL, ARL , NRL is doing no better or worse then anyone else crowd wise compared to where they were in 1993
Youre typical of the type of RL fan i hate too
i love RL
i love RL
but youre ignorant , negative & happy to talk it down at any opportunity even in this day & age when given its history & the way its treated by the media
plus dopes like you supposedly supporting it , Its thriving in reality with more people watching it then ever before
is it perfect , no of course not , no sport is.but we're the only code that has fans like you
will join a circle jerk to put your fav code down , & won't defend it
but sure .... you love it right lol
 
Last edited:

Raiderdave

First Grade
Messages
7,990
RL is at risk of becoming a bogan back water sport in Australia

lol

but its my fav sport ... truly it is

hahahahaha

youre a clown
fullstop .
 

hutch

First Grade
Messages
6,810
Why should RL crowds have increased that much? Maybe if you actually read my original post, or bother to go back and re-read my post instead of hijacking this thread for your own stupid childish agenda, you would realise that that was MY WHOLE POINT. 20 YEARS AGO, my club and others (remember the Sydney Bulldogs, Sydney City Roosters) put themselves through a lot of upheaval and pain in order to make a massive difference to crowds. It didnt work. In fact the opposite happened forthe Tigers. THATS THE POINT. Subsequent to this a lot has been done and tried in order to change things and crowds havent really risen proportionally. You can post all kinds of "stats" but the fact of the matter is EVERYTHING ELSE has risen exponentially. Sydney's population, the grants to the clubs have more than tripled in that time, club turnover at leat doubled, salary caps doubled, TV ratings probably doubled.......crowds have crept up marginally relative.

I stand by what I said about other codes in the context of what I have said above and point out that AFL crowds are double NRL. If you told me 20 years ago that the Swans would average 33K and double the average NRL game in Sydney (at least) I would laugh. If you told me that soccer's average crowds would be neck & neck (within 3K) of NRL average crowd I would have pissed myself. If you told me that a Sydney soccer team (WSW) would have average crowds app 4-5K MORE than any Sydney NRL team I would have taken you to a doctor. All of these are now facts.

Raiderdave your hijacking of this post highlights for me one of my pets hates about RL. I am a RL fan. In winter I only follow RL. I have never been to a AFL game or an A League game, Ive seen a super rugby game becuase I got free tickets. RL is my game. But I cannot understand or cop this stupid, childish, insecurity that comes with so many RL fans that its a competition between RL and every other winter code. If you say something good about another code RL must be defended, a criticism of RL must be countered with a corresponding slam down of (GAY)FL. Its small minded bullshit. RL is my game, I cant tolerate any of the others, but I can cleary see that they are all run more professionally than RL, Infact I think RL is at risk of becoming a bogan backwater in Aus professional sport, but thats another thread. Its still my favourite winter sport.


20 years ago the swans averaged almost 33k, 20 years ago afl crowds were bigger than they are now.

The Aleague crowds are all over the shop but decreased last year and have fallen around 3k per game since 2007.

Super 15 crowds have pretty much halved since unions peak in 2003.

The nrl is the only competition to stay relatively consistent with crowds over the last 10 or so years. Yes, they should be better and havnt grown as much as they should have, but there is no need for such panic.
 

Lambretta

First Grade
Messages
8,689
lol
my argument is flimsy is it ?
id of thought comparing the NSL ....nothing but a collection of historical ethnic disputes usually ending in violence at most games
to a group of generic franchises in a completely different set up to disprove an argument

was a flimsy effort bozo : )

I went to loads of NSL games when I first came to the Country
I saw Sydney Olympic, Marconi, Northern Spirit etc and never once did I see any violence. Not a single instance. Not one punch thown.

so I'd call that part of your argument flimsy
 

Raiderdave

First Grade
Messages
7,990
I went to loads of NSL games when I first came to the Country
I saw Sydney Olympic, Marconi, Northern Spirit etc and never once did I see any violence. Not a single instance. Not one punch thown.

so I'd call that part of your argument flimsy

hahahahah

you're lucky then , or delusional
or both

thered be 1000 examples of violence at soccer matches or near by them in the last 50 years
& even up to todays modern a league
but its improved at least without the ethnic based comp of old.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,585
20 years ago the swans averaged almost 33k, 20 years ago afl crowds were bigger than they are now.

The Aleague crowds are all over the shop but decreased last year and have fallen around 3k per game since 2007.

Super 15 crowds have pretty much halved since unions peak in 2003.

The nrl is the only competition to stay relatively consistent with crowds over the last 10 or so years. Yes, they should be better and havnt grown as much as they should have, but there is no need for such panic.

Not really true.
20 years ago Afl avg around 28-29k
Now 31-32k

As I said before both sports crowds have followed a similiar path, increases unto 2012 then drop off.
Afl likely due to expansion to places with no start up fanbase
NRL likely due to crap tv time slots

Cricket has arguably grown its crowd avg significantly by introducing a more fan friendly format in the big bash.
 

Pommy

Coach
Messages
14,657
Not really true.
20 years ago Afl avg around 28-29k
Now 31-32k

As I said before both sports crowds have followed a similiar path, increases unto 2012 then drop off.
Afl likely due to expansion to places with no start up fanbase
NRL likely due to crap tv time slots

Cricket has arguably grown its crowd avg significantly by introducing a more fan friendly format in the big bash.

Why is the big bash so successful? The timings are hardly family friendly.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,986
I stand by what I said about other codes in the context of what I have said above and point out that AFL crowds are double NRL. If you told me 20 years ago that the Swans would average 33K and double the average NRL game in Sydney (at least) I would laugh. If you told me that soccer's average crowds would be neck & neck (within 3K) of NRL average crowd I would have pissed myself. If you told me that a Sydney soccer team (WSW) would have average crowds app 4-5K MORE than any Sydney NRL team I would have taken you to a doctor. All of these are now facts.
Facts aren't what you *think* something is, they're actually what is happening and can be verified.

Fact: the Swans' average home crowd in 1997 (twenty seasons ago) was 35,818.
Fact: the Swans were for the bulk of that 20 years, the only AFL team. Ever heard of supply and demand?

Fact: within 3k is not "neck and neck". (It's also ludicrous to compare a 10 team competition to a 16 team competition.)

Fact: WSW averaged 14,711 last season, one in which they finished 2nd and made the GF. Canterbury & Wests Tigers both averaged more than that in 2016, while Cronulla, Manly and South Sydney were just behind them.

It helps if you verify facts before bringing them to the table. Perhaps you need to consult the doctor?
 

unforgiven

Bench
Messages
3,138
Time of year ??

Almost exclusively during the school holidays
So late night.finishes aren't a huge problem

A lot of people also off work during the Christmas- NY period, so I would guess that gives a bit of a boost in crowds and ratings. CA really timed this competition perfectly.

Will be interesting to see how the Christmas Day game goes if they end up playing it
 

chahrour123

Juniors
Messages
172
Why should RL crowds have increased that much? Maybe if you actually read my original post, or bother to go back and re-read my post instead of hijacking this thread for your own stupid childish agenda, you would realise that that was MY WHOLE POINT. 20 YEARS AGO, my club and others (remember the Sydney Bulldogs, Sydney City Roosters) put themselves through a lot of upheaval and pain in order to make a massive difference to crowds. It didnt work. In fact the opposite happened forthe Tigers. THATS THE POINT. Subsequent to this a lot has been done and tried in order to change things and crowds havent really risen proportionally. You can post all kinds of "stats" but the fact of the matter is EVERYTHING ELSE has risen exponentially. Sydney's population, the grants to the clubs have more than tripled in that time, club turnover at leat doubled, salary caps doubled, TV ratings probably doubled.......crowds have crept up marginally relative.

I stand by what I said about other codes in the context of what I have said above and point out that AFL crowds are double NRL. If you told me 20 years ago that the Swans would average 33K and double the average NRL game in Sydney (at least) I would laugh. If you told me that soccer's average crowds would be neck & neck (within 3K) of NRL average crowd I would have pissed myself. If you told me that a Sydney soccer team (WSW) would have average crowds app 4-5K MORE than any Sydney NRL team I would have taken you to a doctor. All of these are now facts.

Raiderdave your hijacking of this post highlights for me one of my pets hates about RL. I am a RL fan. In winter I only follow RL. I have never been to a AFL game or an A League game, Ive seen a super rugby game becuase I got free tickets. RL is my game. But I cannot understand or cop this stupid, childish, insecurity that comes with so many RL fans that its a competition between RL and every other winter code. If you say something good about another code RL must be defended, a criticism of RL must be countered with a corresponding slam down of (GAY)FL. Its small minded bullshit. RL is my game, I cant tolerate any of the others, but I can cleary see that they are all run more professionally than RL, Infact I think RL is at risk of becoming a bogan backwater in Aus professional sport, but thats another thread. Its still my favourite winter sport.

LOL you just got f***** on. Timmah 1 Tiger5150 0. It's called facts what you just said in your post is what you think so your thoughts. Timmah brought out the stats and facts and taught you a lesson. If you are anti RL this forum isn't for you or if you want to talk the game down can do so but only if you have facts if not don't assume things because your post is completely wrong.
 

Canard

Immortal
Messages
35,609
AFL trolls like Tiger Eddie Van Halen always state "I'm a RL fan but"

It's the equivalent of "some of my best friends are black"
 

hutch

First Grade
Messages
6,810
Not really true.
20 years ago Afl avg around 28-29k
Now 31-32k

As I said before both sports crowds have followed a similiar path, increases unto 2012 then drop off.
Afl likely due to expansion to places with no start up fanbase
NRL likely due to crap tv time slots

Cricket has arguably grown its crowd avg significantly by introducing a more fan friendly format in the big bash.

In 1997 the afl averaged 33197, in 2016 they averaged 31877. They also dropped 200k spectators the year after adding an extra game every week.
I can't bag afl crowds, they are phenomenal for such an ordinary sport, but they havnt grown in 20 years.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,986
They grew over 15 years but have slid in the last five, owing to the addition of two teams which aren't performing just yet
 
Top