That was out, bat clearly on the line, not over it, sh*t happens.
You cant blame umpire decisions, umpires dont bowl like merkins for two tests (johnson) or incredibly inconsistently (Siddle). Umpires dont bat woefully (Hussey). Umpires dont drop someone who just took apart the best attack in the world. Umpires dont not bring a reserve batsmen on tour. Umpires dont make poor captaincy decisions. Umpires dont not select Stuart Clark at Lords. Umpires dont go about with the arrogance of someone who can suck their own dick (hilditch, neilsen).
We lose this ashes series cos we have played like f**king sh*t for the most part, apart from Clarke, North Haddin and Hilfy (katich and ponting first test).