What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

A Draft?

Cranky

Juniors
Messages
182
Although the draft works really well in the AFL I really can't see how it would work in the NRL. The ESL and yawnion would end up the major benefactors of a draft system.
 

ibeme

First Grade
Messages
6,904
I'd prefer the current NRL system over a draft system for the simple fact that players and clubs at least have a say in where they go.

Where it needs improvement is that clubs need to be rewarded through salary cap concessions for developing players. The downside of that is that new clubs, and clubs in developing states will be severely disadvantaged. I don't know what the answer is to counter that problem.
 

Cranky

Juniors
Messages
182
I think a loyalty scheme should be introduced. If a player has spent maybe seven or eight years at the one club, a portion of their salary is then not included in the cap.
 

Johnny Bravo

Juniors
Messages
489
Cranky said:
I think a loyalty scheme should be introduced. If a player has spent maybe seven or eight years at the one club, a portion of their salary is then not included in the cap.
They have that, except its 10 years.
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,878
Bomber said:
...............

As already demonstrated, the draft is a restraint of trade in rugby league and for that reason will not be reintroduced.

The draft would certain restrain the trade of those few clubs who for reasons other than just football have more to offer in terms of attracting the high end marquee players.
 

Mr Saab

Referee
Messages
27,762
Wheelsy said:
And she is a bandwagoner hypocrite as well — she left Carlton to go for Sydney. Where is her loyalty towards her club?

Beccy wrote a story last yr that her and her 2 precious little boys left the Roosters as supporters in 2006 because of the way Ricky Stuart was let go.
 

Raiding Dazz

Juniors
Messages
779
Soward was not wanted and so wasn't J Lewis, so there is nothing wrong with these players swapping sides through the season to have a regular start in first grade.
Newton had to make that decision as he wasn't wanted at NK which is so wrong as they should make an exemption on long serving players under the salary cap.
 

greenhat

Juniors
Messages
552
If only the NRL would completely follow the AFLs great example of a competition with heart.

I know as a fan I'm hanging out to follow a team that has f**kall to do with the place it allegedly represents, and is a completely meaningless corporate entity.
While we are stopping kids from playing for the local team they've supported all their lives, we should also move all the teams to central stadiums so we can -really- kill the soul out of the comp.
Then we can claim that even though the teams have nothing to do with anything any more, because they wear the same jersey as they did 100 years ago, theyre a proud club.
---
Unlike the AFL, Rugby League in Australia still has a culture of local pride. We have home grounds, teams with locals, teams outside of capital cities, state of origin.

Bring in a draft in the NRL and watch the fans leave. One team towns like the Warriors, Cowboys, Knights, Raiders trade almost completely on local pride. They will lose half their fans (including me) in an instant if they are forced to watch their locals get drafted away and replaced with some unfortunate from somewhere else who probably wanted to play for their local team.
 

This Year?

Immortal
Messages
36,122
I didn't even read the article......All I had to see was who wrote it and knew it would be garbage. How this woman can make top $$ for writing about something she knows nothing about is totally beyond me.
 
Messages
6,120
Kilkenny said:
The draft would certain restrain the trade of those few clubs who for reasons other than just football have more to offer in terms of attracting the high end marquee players.

you dont need Marquee players too win a comp look at penrith in 03 and wests tigers in 05 they won it with mostly there juniors
 

aqua_duck

Coach
Messages
18,636
What about her and rothfield offering advice to knights management. Sack Brian Smith and install johns as coach before buderus, simpson, mullen, and gidley leave. Seriously as if anyone would take their advice on board, in fact i'd sign smith up for life now.
 
Messages
42,652
That, is the stupidest suggestion ever. Even worse that swapping jerseys.

Unworkable nonsense and pointless to even discuss it.

Drafts only work when there is no competition to the league.
 

nqboy

First Grade
Messages
8,914
LINK
IN the past week, two internationals - Israel Folau and Willie Tonga - announced they would be playing at different clubs from 2009. At the same time, Wayne Bennett, an institution in Brisbane, declares his allegiance to St George Illawarra for next year, while Neil Henry confirms he will head back to North Queensland at the end of the season. All of the above is big news - even in Melbourne.


Every person I talk to wants to know one thing: how can this happen? How can you sign for a rival club for the following year but play out your existing contract with your current club?


I'll tell you how. It is happening because everyone in the league community has become too comfortable with the present situation. We accept it because it has happened in the past, and will probably happen in the future.


The point I am trying to make is that we shouldn't be happy with it. It is madness. A think-tank is needed to develop and implement a system to deal with it.


I do not have the answers with regards to the movement of coaches. It is a phenomenon that seems to have surfaced in recent years.


There is an obvious solution to player movement though. I have long been a supporter of a draft. I think it, along with the salary cap, is a fair way to even the competition. It would also reward loyalty. We should give it a chance. The previous June 30 deadline didn't work. But neither is the free-for-all situation we have in place now. Players should not be able to sign with rival clubs before the end of the season. It has an affect on the club. It has an affect on the fans.


Is it a restraint of trade? I can't answer that. All I am saying is that we should not be feeling comfortable with the present situation. We should be looking at ways to improve. There are plenty of examples in other sports that we can look at to stop the distractions of coaches and players pledging their futures elsewhere mid-season. A player draft is one of those.


Losing Israel - a talent that has the potential to become anything - to Brisbane for next year was, needless to say, disappointing. His circumstances, though, are different to most players. We understand that. Family is important to everyone. Deep down, I think he wanted to stay but family was the overriding factor. As a Mormon he felt like it was his responsibility to return to them after two years away.

I was confident he would stay. That probably adds to the disappointment. But, given his family situation, it was probably a lot more complicated than we realised. I have a lot of admiration for Israel. He has stuck to his beliefs in a rugby league environment.


He told his teammates of his decision after our game on Saturday against the Sydney Roosters. Yes, Israel is heading north at the end of the year, but he gave them his word that he would be 100 per cent committed to playing his best each and every week.
 

Latest posts

Top