JJ
Immortal
- Messages
- 32,339
Twizzle said:he's better than those three put together
we'll see how good a judge you are in a year or so
he might be in a year or so, but he's not now - and that's all I'm talking about
Twizzle said:he's better than those three put together
we'll see how good a judge you are in a year or so
lockyno1 said:No I actaully have nothing against Clarke to be honest and unlike Katich, becuase he is young, I am prepared to give him time. But to be honest he has been awful for the last 12 months and is struggling against this WI side. His dropping is fair, but unlike Katich I wish him well to get back in the side. But when he comes back he should be at no6 not no4. Currently Clarke is a waste in this team considering there are better batsmen around the country. He is still young and should improve.
Balmain_Boy said:It's got nothing to do with Symmonds being a queenslander. I didn't like Watson but I was willing to give him a chance, because there is definately potential there. But Symmonds, ffs. He'll never be better than a part time bowler and a bloke than bat ok. It's like playing Ian Harvey in the test team.
Balmain_Boy said:It's like playing Ian Harvey in the test team.
ryanallen said:Symonds might not be all that good with his medium pacers but why not give him a go at his off spiners. He bowls effective offies in the one day game so why can't he do it in tests.
Also saying clarke should of been kept and symonds should of got axed is ridiciulous.
Since clarkes debut he has had 15 tests averaging just 24.7. He has had time to convince the selectors, so why shouldn't symonds have the chance to proove himself and convince the selectors? Fair enough he failed in sri lanka,and missed out on the runs in hobart but he has had 3 matches to proove himself to clarkes 15.
So just because you fail in 1 test match doesnt mean you should be compared to a guy that has failed in 15 previous matches.
Balmain_Boy said:Bevan would have easily been a 40-50 run average test player if he was given an extended run. I've got no doubts about that whatsoever.