What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

News Coronavirus and NRL

AnonymousLurker

Juniors
Messages
1,900
I got the flu shot as MY CHOICE but I really don’t think they should be forced. The only unique situation for them is that their employer is trying to start up business again before everyonand this was apart of their measures to get government approval .
The players have individual rights not to have the jab , do you want your rights taken away for the “greater good “ ie
~ mandatory to have app to go anywhere including supermarket
~ have to carry around a “immunity” passport for this virus or the next big virus to come around otherwise denied the right to work or even purchase essential goods

at what stage does it become enough is enough. Does the flu shot stop the spread of covid or protect you from it. Does the flu shot protect you from the flu ..NO.. only against 4 strains and even then you can still get it .
Is the flu even widespread this year considering we’ve been in lockdowns and overseas tourists have now been blocked

Whilst they are tools for not having it , as it’s not law they should have choice not to get it
 

nick87

Coach
Messages
12,256
I got the flu shot as MY CHOICE but I really don’t think they should be forced. The only unique situation for them is that their employer is trying to start up business again before everyonand this was apart of their measures to get government approval .
The players have individual rights not to have the jab , do you want your rights taken away for the “greater good “ ie
~ mandatory to have app to go anywhere including supermarket
~ have to carry around a “immunity” passport for this virus or the next big virus to come around otherwise denied the right to work or even purchase essential goods

at what stage does it become enough is enough. Does the flu shot stop the spread of covid or protect you from it. Does the flu shot protect you from the flu ..NO.. only against 4 strains and even then you can still get it .
Is the flu even widespread this year considering we’ve been in lockdowns and overseas tourists have now been blocked

Whilst they are tools for not having it , as it’s not law they should have choice not to get it

They're not being forced to have it. Any player who doesnt want it doesnt have to go get it.
What they do have to do is sign a document agreeing that they've been made aware of the risks of not having the shot by their employer and thus they are assuming that risk and ultimately protecting the league from litigation if one of these players contracted COVID19 during the course of play/training and got very ill/died from it.

That's all this is for the NRL. They want everyone to have to shot so if something goes wrong they can say they took all reasonable steps to ensure safety and for those who choose not to have it, they were made aware of the risks and willingly assumed them.
 

The Marshall

Juniors
Messages
625
Peter Dutton, Chief medical officer in QLD and the NSW premier all said that the health plan put forward by the NRL said that all players would have the flu vaccination. Sounds like the waivers wont be enough.
 

Valheru

Coach
Messages
17,633
They're not being forced to have it. Any player who doesnt want it doesnt have to go get it.
What they do have to do is sign a document agreeing that they've been made aware of the risks of not having the shot by their employer and thus they are assuming that risk and ultimately protecting the league from litigation if one of these players contracted COVID19 during the course of play/training and got very ill/died from it.

That's all this is for the NRL. They want everyone to have to shot so if something goes wrong they can say they took all reasonable steps to ensure safety and for those who choose not to have it, they were made aware of the risks and willingly assumed them.

Yep when you put it like that, it is completely ridiculous that they didn't sign the waivers
 

Valheru

Coach
Messages
17,633
Peter Dutton, Chief medical officer in QLD and the NSW premier all said that the health plan put forward by the NRL said that all players would have the flu vaccination. Sounds like the waivers wont be enough.

Well that is on the NRL for promising something that they couldn't possibly guarantee to deliver.

They should have just said "we will strongly encourage them to get the shot and ask them to sign a waiver if they don't.

They will still probably get 90% uptake,
 

unforgiven

Bench
Messages
3,138
Well that is on the NRL for promising something that they couldn't possibly guarantee to deliver.

They should have just said "we will strongly encourage them to get the shot and ask them to sign a waiver if they don't.

They will still probably get 90% uptake,

It may be on the NRL, but if the government stay firm in this stance then those players will not be playing.
 

AnonymousLurker

Juniors
Messages
1,900
What it does is it prevents the flu from compromising your immune system which makes you more susceptible to covid 19, so it helps you fight covid 19.

Against 4 New flu strains only and considering borders shut and lockdowns, any flu going around which would be unlikely given lockdowns and social distancing would have a good chance of being the other strains it doesn’t protect against

They're not being forced to have it. Any player who doesnt want it doesnt have to go get it.
What they do have to do is sign a document agreeing that they've been made aware of the risks of not having the shot by their employer and thus they are assuming that risk and ultimately protecting the league from litigation if one of these players contracted COVID19 during the course of play/training and got very ill/died from it.

That's all this is for the NRL. They want everyone to have to shot so if something goes wrong they can say they took all reasonable steps to ensure safety and for those who choose not to have it, they were made aware of the risks and willingly assumed them.

Everyone has been mainly hammering them for not getting the shots , and government response has been about them not having the shots , not amendments to waiver
 

nick87

Coach
Messages
12,256
Everyone has been mainly hammering them for not getting the shots , and government response has been about them not having the shots , not amendments to waiver

They should be hammered for not getting the shots. Its selfish and irresponsible. And the science doesnt give a single f**k about what fairy god father up in the sky has to say. Immunisations are a proven benefit to individual and community health. It's not up for debate.

If you're a public figure and out yourself as a f**king moron, you're going to get hammered for it and rightly so.

But that's their fault. They did that to themselves. I've got no sympathy for them.

No one is forcing them to have the shot, they get to decide if they want the flu shot and those of us who arent f**king morons get to decide how we feel about their stupidity.
 

unforgiven

Bench
Messages
3,138
They will be playing

APS workers don't require the flu shot to be in the office.

Not unless the governments accepts the changes to the NRL biosecurity measures, these were approved as part of the NRL's submission to restart. Those agreements end if they are not adhered to.
 

unforgiven

Bench
Messages
3,138
Against 4 New flu strains only and considering borders shut and lockdowns, any flu going around which would be unlikely given lockdowns and social distancing would have a good chance of being the other strains it doesn’t protect against



Everyone has been mainly hammering them for not getting the shots , and government response has been about them not having the shots , not amendments to waiver
The flu shots contain the vaccines that experts predict will most likely have an impact on Australia each year, sometimes they get it wrong but most of the time that are fairly accurate.
 

Mr Angry

Not a Referee
Messages
51,783
I love the you cannot have this.

But you must have this, totally unfair.

Buy some logic, you have none.
 

Canard

Immortal
Messages
34,415
Putting aside the f**king dumb as dogshit vaccination debate, that wankers like @AnonymousLurker are trying to turn into some crazed internet bullshit.

Certain sections of the players, really seem to be going out of there way to f**k this up for everyone.

I wont take any solace when reading the "Where are they Now?" article in 2023 about Bryce Cartwright working on a shovel for the local Council bemoaning the fact he listened to his now divorced wife.
 

TheFrog

Coach
Messages
14,300
Putting aside the f**king dumb as dogshit vaccination debate, that wankers like @AnonymousLurker are trying to turn into some crazed internet bullshit.

Certain sections of the players, really seem to be going out of there way to f**k this up for everyone.

I wont take any solace when reading the "Where are they Now?" article in 2023 about Bryce Cartwright working on a shovel for the local Council bemoaning the fact he listened to his now divorced wife.
Careful what you wish on others, lest the begging bowl be bequeathed to you.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
65,849
I dont really see the issue here, having the flu shot doesnt reduce chances of spreading Covid and as said there is much scientific debate about just how effective flu immunizations are in reducing flu incidents. Some years they get lucky, other years they miss the boat totally, even in good years theya re only around 40-60% effective. If its just abut covid effects potentially being more harmful if you also have a strain of other flu then a simple acceptance of risk form should cover it, though I doubt players would sign it as they wouldnt want to waiver their litigation rights if the NRL or clubs do something wrong and spread Covid negligently.

Either the NRL or RLPA have dropped the ball again on this, this should have been factored into the RLPA negotiations and all its members notified early last week surely?
 
Top