Do you want Brad Arthur as coach

[Chipmunk]

Do you remember Kearney? That was clueless and a monumental f**k up at all levels!!

Since 2017, we have missed the finals once (including this year), i would hardly call him clueless. This is where you lose people with your comments.

Does he have the ability to get us to the next level? History is suggesting that he does not, but calling him clueless is hilarious.

We haven't won a comp for 36 years because our management (and fan, board election votes to an extent) at all levels let us down for so long until it all came to a head in 2016 and we were given a clean slate.

We didn't have the luxury of brining in Uncle Wayne, Bellamy or Robinson who are clearly top tier coaches but they also have teams who have enormous resources and we simply don't have that and i'll tell you it is the failures of the past as to why we don't have those resources because if we had been more successful we would probably be as loaded as those clubs.

Would you say he's clueless in being able to get us to the next level then?

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Paul McGregor never finished last and didn’t make it to the end of his seventh season.

How many times did he make the finals?

 

[Hindmarshisgod2]

Do you remember Kearney? That was clueless and a monumental f**k up at all levels!!

Since 2017, we have missed the finals once (including this year), i would hardly call him clueless. This is where you lose people with your comments.

Does he have the ability to get us to the next level? History is suggesting that he does not, but calling him clueless is hilarious.

We haven't won a comp for 36 years because our management (and fan, board election votes to an extent) at all levels let us down for so long until it all came to a head in 2016 and we were given a clean slate.

We didn't have the luxury of brining in Uncle Wayne, Bellamy or Robinson who are clearly top tier coaches but they also have teams who have enormous resources and we simply don't have that and i'll tell you it is the failures of the past as to why we don't have those resources because if we had been more successful we would probably be as loaded as those clubs.

Just cause we have made the finals doesn't exactly mean anything. Good recruitment has helped, as well as variables such as easy draws, playing better teams during origin, playing teams with players out due to injury, etc....

The fact that they have been knocked out in the finals without even a whimper, shows that they were not good enough to be there to begin with, and only got there due to the reasons mentioned above...so yeah, the bush coach is clueless as clueless can be.....

Oh wait, we beat the broncos in a finals game...

 

[Poupou Escobar]

There’s another stat that’s alarming.

In the nrl era, only one coach, that’s coached more than 8 years then jagged a premiership. That’s John Lang. But some of the years he coach were outside the nrl years, so it’s debatable if he qualifies

All the other coaches were either rookies, won one within a few years, or old timers that have one comps over the years (wb, Bellamy and robbo).


The stats indicate Nathan brown, Cleary and BA won’t win a Comp.

In data analytics they call this overfitting. True correlations, but useless.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

You aren’t arguing in good faith.

Trying to show the difference between statistical relevance and irrelevance. It's difficult with merkins who don't even understand the fundamentals. It's like we're having two different conversations.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

No wonder why we haven't won a premiership for 36 years

Arthur's fault?

 

[lucablight]

How many times did he make the finals?

I’m not going to argue that McGregor was a better coach. I’m saying that it’s incredibly rare for a coach to be at the same club for such a long period of time without at least a grand final showing.

Trying to show the difference between statistical relevance and irrelevance. It's difficult with merkins who don't even understand the fundamentals. It's like we're having two different conversations.

Is the irony of what you’re saying lost on you?

 

[Hindmarshisgod2]

Arthur's fault?

Nah, now I'm starting on the club.

Majority now realise that Bushy is a fraud.


Now I'm blaming the club for 1: extending him when he hasn't proven nothing 2: not sacking him as of yesterday.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Do you remember Kearney? That was clueless and a monumental f**k up at all levels!!

Since 2017, we have missed the finals once (including this year), i would hardly call him clueless. This is where you lose people with your comments.

Does he have the ability to get us to the next level? History is suggesting that he does not, but calling him clueless is hilarious.

We haven't won a comp for 36 years because our management (and fan, board election votes to an extent) at all levels let us down for so long until it all came to a head in 2016 and we were given a clean slate.

We didn't have the luxury of brining in Uncle Wayne, Bellamy or Robinson who are clearly top tier coaches but they also have teams who have enormous resources and we simply don't have that and i'll tell you it is the failures of the past as to why we don't have those resources because if we had been more successful we would probably be as loaded as those clubs.

Great post.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Oh wait, we beat the broncos in a finals game...

*destroyed

That finals win set a bunch of records. You might say it was lucky we faced the Broncos who were on a downward trajectory, but then how lucky were we to face the Storm every single time we made the finals? They were premiers in two of those years.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

I’m not going to argue that McGregor was a better coach. I’m saying that it’s incredibly rare for a coach to be at the same club for such a long period of time without at least a grand final showing.

Agreed, but I don't think it's relevant.

Is the irony of what you’re saying lost on you?

Well we can't both be right. If only one of us is wrong I'm tipping it isn't me. Ultimately an assessment is just an opinion, but it's backed up with experience and evidence. You wouldn't compare Arthur with Ricky Stuart but you'll compare him with McGregor based on one tenuous correlation. And then you accuse me of making bad faith arguments.

 

[Gazzamatta]

Yep he was shit too.

And their fans had been saying it for years before he was removed.

 

[Gazzamatta]

*destroyed

That finals win set a bunch of records. You might say it was lucky we faced the Broncos who were on a downward trajectory, but then how lucky were we to face the Storm every single time we made the finals? They were premiers in two of those years.

I was there Poo. A day Ill never forget. Such pride and massive expectations (well not really)of what was to come . Nek minit!

 

[Gazzamatta]

 

[hineyrulz]

Lol Pou.


The stamina of a Kenyan marathon runner.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

I was there Poo. A day Ill never forget. Such pride and massive expectations (well not really)of what was to come . Nek minit!

Turns out it was our grand final that year. Which we won! Go Parra.

 

[IFR33K]

Arthur's fault?

No, the fans

 

[IFR33K]

Lol Pou.


The stamina of a Kenyan marathon runner.

with the thrust of a midget

 

[Poupou Escobar]

No, the fans

Well they've been at the club much longer.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

with the thrust of a midget

Check our IFR33K with the ad hominem attacks again. What a f**ken lightweight!