Do you want Brad Arthur as coach

[hindy111]

Our biggest problem with Dylbags next year may be hanging onto him, although he has said recently he loves it here and doesn't want to leave.

Not a huge deal. He will only leave for overs. What is he worth? 2 x TAs last year. Less then Jake Arthurs. Moses is our main half and the one we cant afford to lose.

 

[hindy111]

I’m not convinced he is a natural attacker. A bit like Gutho, but slightly faster. Coaching is a factor but it also comes down to the individual and their skill set.

If we can unlock something with him and get him to play like a Cody Walker then we will be a formidable side.

At the moment if you shut down Moses you go a long way to shutting down our team. Even our forward pack can be on top and we struggle.

Gutherson has a great passing game. Issue is Dylan's not showed any type of passing game at all.

 

[hindy111]

Jake is slow and not ready but he is always looking for ways to score. Quite often he would roll a kick in if noticed the fullback was out of position. Wrong or right it showed he is looked for opportunities.

 

[King-Gutho94]

Anyone want to change their vote.

I still haven't changed mine but i did vote NO at the backend of last year.

 

[Eelementary]

Anyone want to change their vote.

I still haven't changed mine but i did vote NO at the backend of last year.

Once his deal is done, let him go.

He's all out of ideas.

 

[Noise]

Once his deal is done, let him go.

He's all out of ideas.

He should have been out on his arse last contract…and the one before that.

 

[Eelementary]

He should have been out on his arse last contract…and the one before that.

I'm officially out of patience with him.

 

[Noise]

I'm officially out of patience with him.

It’s even worse now because we are getting a 2 for 1 with his incompetent son.

 

[King-Gutho94]

Once his deal is done, let him go.

He's all out of ideas.

Well they gave him a 12 month extension last year. After we lost to penrith.

I ran out of patience last year after he parachuted his son into the team to give experience only to cost us a top 4 spot.

Nothing has changed this year.

 

[IFR33K]

Once his deal is done, let him go.

He's all out of ideas.

all out? Not sure he had much to offer at all. Very one dimensional coach. His game plans will work in junior footy, but that’s about it.

 

[IFR33K]

Anyone want to change their vote.

I still haven't changed mine but i did vote NO at the backend of last year.

I voted no when the post was started. Standing firm.

 

[IFR33K]

It’s even worse now because we are getting a 2 for 1 with his incompetent son.

Don’t be harsh mate. He’s only 19, not much experience and the best half in NSW cup.

also the benefit of having him in the team, allows Drown to oppose Holmes….

 

[King-Gutho94]

Well when i bumped this thread i think it was 54.5% for yes.

It has dropped 1% already in 30 mins.

 

[IFR33K]

After this thrashing we probably reward BA with a 2 year extension and ja 3 years and guarantee him captain.

 

[Happy MEel]

Is there a way I can double down on my “no” vote?

 

[Eelspride]

Anyone want to change their vote.

I still haven't changed mine but i did vote NO at the backend of last year.

My fear is BA would let D Brown leave before we get rid of him and his little possum son and cause a lot of damage to the team.
But for us to get rid of both of them we must get the wanker that have given him a two year contract extension first.

 

[hineyrulz]

It’s been a no since round 6 2018, he should of went then. But no the club rewards him with an extension after getting Poned by 60 in 2019.


He was told last year he needed to do better but instead we finished 6th and went out yet again in week 2. 2 finals wins in 9 years and somehow this idiot is still here for two more years??? Does this club know what KPI’s are?? How are his useless assistants still here?? They should be f**king homeless, the long suffering fans deserve better but instead we are stuck with an absolute plodder. It’s bad enough he’s an average coach wirh limitations but when he starts being the nepotism Gnome it’s time for him to f**k off. f**k his bald eyes.

 

[Happy MEel]

It’s been a no since round 6 2018, he should of went then. But no the club rewards him with an extension after getting Poned by 60 in 2019.


He was told last year he needed to do better but instead we finished 6th and went out yet again in week 2. 2 finals wins in 9 years and somehow this idiot is still here for two more years??? Does this club know what KPI’s are?? How are his useless assistants still here?? They should be f**king homeless, the long suffering fans deserve better but instead we are stuck with an absolute plodder. It’s bad enough he’s an average coach wirh limitations but when he starts being the nepotism Gnome it’s time for him to f**k off. f**k his bald eyes.

There is zero accountability in this organisation. It’s as simple as that.

 

[Chipmunk]

My fear is BA would let D Brown leave before we get rid of him and his little possum son and cause a lot of damage to the team.
But for us to get rid of both of them we must get the wanker that have given him a two year contract extension first.

If we let Drown go for JArthur to replace him, my more than 40 years support will end...immediately.

 

[Gazzamatta]

It appears it matters little who we bring in as "consultants", our playing style, inconsistency and God awful defence remains. Why is this? Are we wasting our money? Are they just poor choices? At least give us a couple of Sterlo Run Arounds each season. We have no idea how to work an extra man. Long cut out balls, kick to the posts or running our wingers over the sideline seems our only go to plays. Sometimes this works but switched on teams work this out. Post match interviews by Cows last night said they knew exactly how to oppose us.
Our ptb is painfully slow and we were smashed in that area last night. Eels left floundering on the ground at every ptb yet even with our forward dominance we cant respond in kind. Gutho quoted we will back our fitness. BA said we can score points whenever we need too. Gee that was disappointing. Penrith, Chooks and Manly (finally at home) to follow. This could get real ugly real fast.
We cannot rely on effort alone. Its not sustainable and injurys will mount up but Ive little doubt effort will be the only area targeted. Try harder boys!