Well it's interesting you had to go back 13 years to find such an exception. It certainly proves the rule.
It also proves anything is possible, which is why our club shouldn't give up on this year. Neither should the fans, but we need to realise the odds are stacked against us and have been all year. To win finals matches (at least three of them) against better teams (at least three of those plus another couple at least as good) we will need some luck. Losing Reed Mahoney for the year is the opposite of that. Either way, we shouldn't be looking for scapegoats if we don't win this year. If we somehow face two of Melbourne, Penrith or Souths at full strength and lose both games we won't have failed. We need to hope we hit any of these three teams understrength in an elimination game. Or get every bounce of the ball.