I think it is hard comparing Tim Smith to our other younger players.......I cannot recall a player with bigger raps on him than Tim Smith (ie already being mentioned as a State of Origin player this season!).
Mateo is loved by some people on this forum, and it is great to see this loyalty (I loved Jaime Lyon and Danny Sullivan when they broke into the junior grades.)
It takes time for most kids to come into first grade - I think Smith has done a good job of it over his time. Just take a look at Souths when they came back in - they signed a bunch of our good kids and all of them faded, except for Wade who promptly returned home!!!
I guess we are lucky we have so many good players in the junior ranks.