What's new
By:
Advanced search…
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Former Panthers in the NRL

soc123_au

soc123_au

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
19,865
Red&BlackBear said:
I forgot to add Mansour and Tyrone May!
That’s a lot of $$$ lost for only a few players being upgraded so far. Hence I laugh at Fox Sports saying it’s between Edwards and Luai - both will stay and the proof is literally in these lists put forward as to why and how they’ll stay.
Click to expand...
Shit, I cant believe I forgot Sauce as well. He would have been on a decent contract at that time too.

1. Laurie
2. Mansour GF x 1
3. Critchon GF x 3 Prem x 2
4. Burton GF x 1 Prem x 1
5. Staines GF x 1 Prem x 1
6. T May GF x 2 Prem 1
7. O'Sullivan
8. Tamou GF x 1
9. Korisau GF x 3 Prem x 2
10. Tetavano GF x 1
11. Capewell GF x 2 Prem x 1
12. Kikau GF x 3 Prem x 2
13. Hopgood
14. Egan
15. Leniu GF x 2 Prem x 2
16. Hethrington
17. Naden GF x 1

18. Momorovski GF x 1 Prem x 1

Coach. Andrew Webster
Assistant. Cameron Ciraldo
Water Boy. T Baz


Only 4 players of 18 to not play in a GF. If you want to get cheeky you could add Pangai Jnr into the mix, but to keep it real that would be a stretch.
 
C

ColdWetPanther

Bench
Messages
4,314
Red&BlackBear said:
I forgot to add Mansour and Tyrone May!
That’s a lot of $$$ lost for only a few players being upgraded so far. Hence I laugh at Fox Sports saying it’s between Edwards and Luai - both will stay and the proof is literally in these lists put forward as to why and how they’ll stay.
Click to expand...
I hope I’m wrong, but we have consistently been told by the club that we will lose a few (two) stars a year because of the cap. Everyone is making the right noises but the Panthers are saying is we can afford to keep them both if they want to (ie stay for unders) and Luai has said openly he wants to stay but that his manager looks after his contract (ie he won’t be staying for unders).

Again, hope I’m wrong but we have re-signed Yeo, To’o, Martin and Leota all until 2027; my gut says we are more likely to lose both than keep both.
 
K

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,877
soc123_au said:
Shit, I cant believe I forgot Sauce as well. He would have been on a decent contract at that time too.

1. Laurie
2. Mansour GF x 1
3. Critchon GF x 3 Prem x 2
4. Burton GF x 1 Prem x 1
5. Staines GF x 1 Prem x 1
6. T May GF x 2 Prem 1
7. O'Sullivan
8. Tamou GF x 1
9. Korisau GF x 3 Prem x 2
10. Tetavano GF x 1
11. Capewell GF x 2 Prem x 1
12. Kikau GF x 3 Prem x 2
13. Hopgood
14. Egan
15. Leniu GF x 2 Prem x 2
16. Hethrington
17. Naden GF x 1

18. Momorovski GF x 1 Prem x 1

Coach. Andrew Webster
Assistant. Cameron Ciraldo
Water Boy. T Baz


Only 4 players of 18 to not play in a GF. If you want to get cheeky you could add Pangai Jnr into the mix, but to keep it real that would be a stretch.
Click to expand...
That’s a huge turnover in quality players. No other NRL has endured anywhere near such turnover and still seem to find ways to bring in marquee players.
 
soc123_au

soc123_au

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
19,865
Kilkenny said:
That’s a huge turnover in quality players. No other NRL has endured anywhere near such turnover and still seem to find ways to bring in marquee players.
Click to expand...
Yeah, that is a top 8 team without too much trouble. Still has depth has from players unlisted that we have lost in that time as well.
 
C

ColdWetPanther

Bench
Messages
4,314
soc123_au said:
Shit, I cant believe I forgot Sauce as well. He would have been on a decent contract at that time too.

1. Laurie
2. Mansour GF x 1
3. Critchon GF x 3 Prem x 2
4. Burton GF x 1 Prem x 1
5. Staines GF x 1 Prem x 1
6. T May GF x 2 Prem 1
7. O'Sullivan
8. Tamou GF x 1
9. Korisau GF x 3 Prem x 2
10. Tetavano GF x 1
11. Capewell GF x 2 Prem x 1
12. Kikau GF x 3 Prem x 2
13. Hopgood
14. Egan
15. Leniu GF x 2 Prem x 2
16. Hethrington
17. Naden GF x 1

18. Momorovski GF x 1 Prem x 1

Coach. Andrew Webster
Assistant. Cameron Ciraldo
Water Boy. T Baz


Only 4 players of 18 to not play in a GF. If you want to get cheeky you could add Pangai Jnr into the mix, but to keep it real that would be a stretch.
Click to expand...
Interesting you have Laurie at 1 @soc123_au ; are you a fan?
 
K

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,877
The best utility player we have had in recent seasons, someone who you could basically play anywhere and he could do a job was Tyrone May.
 
C

ColdWetPanther

Bench
Messages
4,314
soc123_au said:
More just a case of who has left in the last 3 years. I toyed with Burto at 1 and bringing Naden in at center.
Click to expand...
Personally I would have Critta at 1 and Momo/Naden in the centres, or even Staines at 1 and bring Naden onto the wing.

Interesting exercise and good debate…
 
K

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,877
ColdWetPanther said:
Personally I would have Critta at 1 and Momo/Naden in the centres, or even Staines at 1 and bring Naden onto the wing.

Interesting exercise and good debate…
Click to expand...
It was interesting to see Momo get a start last night for the Roosters, they have been sparse. Probably would have struggled to make our 17 with the emergence of Tago, Naden likewise I guess. Naden was never explosive over the first 20 but had good high end speed over the longer distance. I noticed a try saving tackle for the tigers earlier this season where he came from the opposite side and stopped a try, pretty impressive. I liked Brent, not perfect, but just a good solid player even if had his issues.
 
Chins get the wins

Chins get the wins

First Grade
Messages
8,493
Burto and TPJ just dragged the Doggies to a win.
I'm not sure Cam Ciraldo is the supercoach some think Burton is a running 6 not a 7 but Cam is clueless on that. All Matt needs is a Chad Townsend level 7 next to him directing and he'd be insanely effective.
 
B

Black Panther

Juniors
Messages
1,888
Manly are deadset down hill skiers. Only look good against shit opponents. The comments around Manly announcing themselves in the coverage really cracks me up. I thought you were there to win the comp from the get go, not just to look good against poor teams.
 
Chins get the wins

Chins get the wins

First Grade
Messages
8,493
Black Panther said:
Manly are deadset down hill skiers. Only look good against shit opponents. The comments around Manly announcing themselves in the coverage really cracks me up. I thought you were there to win the comp from the get go, not just to look good against poor teams.
Click to expand...
Yeah they are nothing to worry about
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Bob
Roger Cowan
Replies
16
Views
1K
Nealo 12
Nealo 12

Latest posts

Top