What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Judiciary rd 4

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
101,214
Colonel, El D, the vid is Frank Puletua flying into Jason Smith from the side with his legs. Didn;t notice it during the game but it looks pretty bad...
 

Iafeta

Referee
Messages
24,357
Staggering that Simon Woolford can cop a massive suspension over an innocuous tackle on Billy Slater, but Beau Scott is free to play with no repurcussion for his head driving tackle on Todd Polglase. Also, staggering Hopoate gets near life for his hit on Galloway, and while the force was different, the technique was much the same but instead of near life, 1 week? Gimme a break - Lolesi was lucky to stay on the paddock.
 

*Paul*

Juniors
Messages
2,151
Really, it's just a bog standard Xvid
Canberra v Penrith
bscap0001.jpg
 

Iafeta

Referee
Messages
24,357
nqboy said:
http://foxsports.news.com.au/story/0,8659,18689543-23214,00.html
THE NRL last night demanded a full inquiry into Melbourne's Scott Hill allegedly manhandling referee Jason Robinson during a wild afternoon at Leichhardt Oval yesterday where Storm fullback Billy Slater admitted kicking West Tigers prop John Skandalis.

Once the drama settled, the Wests Tigers held off a fast-finishing Storm to secure a 30-28 win before 17,803 fans.

In further controversy, two players were placed on report during the game.
But the match will have ramifications today after NRL chief operating officer Graham Annesley called for a full report into Hill handling Robinson. Robinson conceded after the game that Hill had touched him during a 29th-minute incident after Wests Tigers winger Shane Elford scored a try.

"There was contact between he and myself after the try," Robinson told The Daily Telegraph. "I'm not sure whether it was deliberate or accidental. I have been asked to put in a report. I spoke to Scott on the field and that's as far as I have got."

Hill was playing down the incident.

"There was nothing in it. I was just in the defensive line and he got in the way and obstructed me," Hill said. "We made a bit of contact. I just tapped him on the shoulder afterwards and made sure we were OK. I was just trying to get his attention. He said to [Storm captain] Matt Geyer there was no problem, so I don't expect anything to come of it."

On the field, Robinson told Geyer: "If I thought he meant it, you'd be a man short."

But the controversy did not end there. In the 47th minute, Slater lashed out in a tackle and kicked Skandalis in the head, who reacted angrily. The crowd started chanting, "Slater's a wanker" and jeered each time he touched the ball. Slater, who scored two runaway tries, apologised to Skandalis on the field after the game.

"He had my leg after I passed the ball and I tried to break free and unfortunately I kicked him in the head," Slater said. "He didn't take too kindly to that but I found him after the game and he was sweet. He's a good fellow and I wanted him to know it was an accident. It was one of those things that happen in a game. I don't think there will be any drama."

Skandalis said he had accepted Slater's apology.

"It's all over and finished," Skandalis said. "He apologised after the game on the field and I accepted it. I hope nothing more comes of it. I don't want him suspended. It happened in the heat of the moment. I don't mind leaving things like that on the field. It just stunned me."

Asked about the crowd reaction, Skandalis said: "They must have seen it. They stuck with me which was good. We got away with the win. That's enough for me."

Hill was placed on report for a seperate incident in the 19th minute for a high tackle on Wests Tigers halfback Scott Prince. Wests Tigers lock Jamaal Lolesi was also on report for a high tackle on Storm forward Dallas Johnson. Lolesi's tackle came as the Tigers received a penalty. But the match officials did not look at the Lolesi tackle for a few more seconds, meaning Melbourne did not receive the penalty they probably deserved.

"We should have got the penalty," said Melbourne coach Craig Bellamy.

Wests Tigers coach Tim Sheens was pleased with the win but upset his side led 30-4 before allowing Melbourne to score four late tries.

The Scott Hill charge is absolute tripe. Scott Hill was denied an opportunity at sliding with the defence, they ended up being one short, because Jason Robinson positioned himself very, very poorly.

Robinson's the one who should be suspended, not Hill.
 

Iafeta

Referee
Messages
24,357
Mr Saab said:
chad was intentional, very intentional.
No one tackles like that with a man on the ground.
this match review committee is hopeless.
I expect the storm to challenege both.

He was lucky not to be ordered off, 10 minutes was a bit light.
 

Glenn

First Grade
Messages
7,314
Bazal said:
Eh?

*Bazal looks around as something flies over his head*:?

Meant you had to be joking that Delaney got charged with a grapple tackle :shock:
 

Iafeta

Referee
Messages
24,357
shadow grinder said:
well i disagree. you see players all the time kicking about and pushing up trying to get a penalty or a fast play the ball....and with a player hanging on to your feet...then an accident is bound to happen. i dont think its a dog of an act if it is accidental. if he meant to do it...which i doubt, then ofcourse its a dog act and he should be suspended big time....but i dont know i havent seen the incident...

In the Manly/Chooks game, Ben Kennedy got booted in the head and had to defend on the wing while he got things together again.

I didn't see Slater's incident, I'd be interested in seeing the comparison and seeing if there's obvious difference in intent.
 

HoLLuS

Juniors
Messages
215
That's three high tackles in three weeks for Lolesi isn't it?

Much the same for Billy Slater with his recent spout of late hits, maybe this charge makes up for all of that.

Judiciary is a joke!
 

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
101,214
Glenn said:
Meant you had to be joking that Delaney got charged with a grapple tackle :shock:

Ahhhhh.....lol. Damn 6am starts. :D It's a friggin joke that he;s been charged, I agree
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
germ suspended again, i didnt think there was that much in his shot to be honest
but at least it gives us a chance to shift withers to hooker, carney to half and maintain zillman on the bench :D
 

Prodigiousman

Juniors
Messages
933
Anyone with a copy of the Roosters-Manly game check out Steve Matai's hit on Adrian Morley in the leadup to the Minichiello try in the 34th minute...

If Warren Smith was commentating and Morley had put the hit on I wonder if he'd have noticed it.

Intent, high and well intentional!

Proves that unless the commentators pick it up no action is taken. I thought the NRL Judiciary had an obligation to find foul play and punish it - not just go with commentator's recommendations...
 

Iafeta

Referee
Messages
24,357
Raider_69 said:
germ suspended again, i didnt think there was that much in his shot to be honest
but at least it gives us a chance to shift withers to hooker, carney to half and maintain zillman on the bench :D

It won't, you know it won't. Thats just hopeful proposterious thinking.

Matt Gafa will be recalled from London to play halfback, Terry Campese will move to right wing, Peter "the chocolate eater" Penana (or whatever his name is - the big bloke in the arm wrestling contest) will go to five eighth and Troy Thompson will go to hooker.

You know it's true.
 
Messages
10,949
Prodigiousman said:
Anyone with a copy of the Roosters-Manly game check out Steve Matai's hit on Adrian Morley in the leadup to the Minichiello try in the 34th minute...

If Warren Smith was commentating and Morley had put the hit on I wonder if he'd have noticed it.

Intent, high and well intentional!

Proves that unless the commentators pick it up no action is taken. I thought the NRL Judiciary had an obligation to find foul play and punish it - not just go with commentator's recommendations...
Obviously not. :x
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
Iafeta said:
It won't, you know it won't. Thats just hopeful proposterious thinking.

Matt Gafa will be recalled from London to play halfback, Terry Campese will move to right wing, Peter "the chocolate eater" Penana (or whatever his name is - the big bloke in the arm wrestling contest) will go to five eighth and Troy Thompson will go to hooker.

You know it's true.

:lol: with elliott its not entirely out of the question
 

Billy Gunn

Juniors
Messages
322
Did anyone hear Warren Smith in the Tigers - Storm game (can't remember exactly the takle) declare that "that takle will not have a case to answer" after it was placed on report.

I was wondering when he was apointed to the review committee.

His calls on high shots are pathetic one minute he condems a player then next he passes sentence
 

Latest posts

Top