Manly Salary Cap

[Nice Beaver]

this has nothing to do with what's legal as they aren't the police

it's about what is in the agreement all clubs sign and if handing over your private phone is in that then them's the breaks

Hahahaha

Bullshit.

 

[Nice Beaver]

The audit team gave up when Manly threatened to lock them in a room with Zorba as he explained what was going on. Didn't want to risk their sanity

Christ.

I would not wish that on Al Qeda operatives in Guantanimo Bay!

 

[The Beaver]

this has nothing to do with what's legal as they aren't the police

it's about what is in the agreement all clubs sign and if handing over your private phone is in that then them's the breaks

I've heard it all now. "It has nothing to do with what's legal", haha fmd. I'm retiring from this thread after that beauty.

 

[Nice Beaver]

I've heard it all now. "It has nothing to do with what's legal", haha fmd. I'm retiring from this thread after that beauty.

Hey! Hang on....El Dildo posts lots of articles so he knows the law.

Lol

I could go and start a company and put in the employment contract that all workers are allowed to drive to work at 140kms an hour

When the police arrest them, all they need to do is produce the employment contract as what I put in there supercedes the law.

Too easy!!!!

 

[mave]

Good work El D.
Thanks for that massive lol.

 

[El Diablo]

Hahahaha

Bullshit.

why is it bullshit?

it's the NRL's comp and they make the rules

 

[El Diablo]

When the police arrest them, all they need to do is produce the employment contract as what I put in there supercedes the law.

fair dinkum Manly fans are f**king idiots

a lot of lawyers out there say a salary cap isn't legal as it's a restraint of trade just like the draft was

 

[Miller was a legend]

Hmmm all this back and forward about legal or not legal, isn't the issue here has there been any salary cap cheating?

Not much of a defence to say, ha ha sucked in NRL you can't have access to something that maybe, just might, show we did something wrong?

Seem a double edge sword to me.

We didn't cheat, but no we won't let you find that we might have.

If there is nothing to hide, why hide?

 

[Nice Beaver]

why is it bullshit?

it's the NRL's comp and they make the rules

F*ck me.

Nice and slowly for you. Given its you.

The NRL or any other organisation can put whatever they like in their contract.

But if what's in the contract is a contradiction of common law, it holds no water if contested.

If nobody contests the validity and accepts it, then its OK. But if it does get contested and is found to breach the common law then they cannot compel anybody to abide by it.

 

[Nice Beaver]

fair dinkum Manly fans are f**king idiots

a lot of lawyers out there say a salary cap isn't legal as it's a restraint of trade just like the draft was

Have they contested it?

Nobody stopping them.

 

[El Diablo]

But if what's in the contract is a contradiction of common law, it holds no water if contested.

just like the salary cap most likely would

do you see anyone rushing off to court?

do you see the AFL being forced to scrap the draft because of Terry Hill?

 

[Nice Beaver]

just like the salary cap most likely would

do you see anyone rushing off to court?

do you see the AFL being forced to scrap the draft because of Terry Hill?

Address the issue at hand instead of scrambling off on tangents.

Just because you don't like the answer, doesn't mean its not right.

Law is law, and Todd and Co. can lick my left nut.

Ironic really that a shifty turd who was behind so much dodgy stuff is now being blocked now he's all high and mighty.

 

[El Diablo]

you really are thick

 

[Nice Beaver]

you really are thick

Hahahahahaha

So you have no logical or legal reply. Lets go with an 8 year old's insult.

As you were, dullard.

 

[El Diablo]

So you have no logical or legal reply

i gave it

it's not my fault you can't understand it

moron

 

[Nice Beaver]

i gave it

it's not my fault you can't understand it

moron

Hahaha

The law is very simple concept.....for most.

How anyone can't compehend the basic concept of law is quite amazing. But keep swinging idiot.

 

[El Diablo]

it's like talking to a brick wall

 

[mave]

Generally once a hole is deep enough, you stop digging it.
Not in this case.

 

[Scaven]

it's like talking to a brick wall

Jesus Christ, do we have to get the sock puppets out for you?
It doesn't matter what the NRL puts in their agreements, if it is illegal the club can tell them to go jump, just like Manly is doing.
You understand now?

 

[El Diablo]

yup

all as dumb as each other