Adolf_Spritzer
Juniors
- Messages
- 638
Anyone who saw the effort Dane Laurie just put in to stop Staines is the reason why Duff isn't worth 600k
Griffin alluded to more than football issues....make of it what you want....sad to see him go, but whispers have been there for a while. Wish Matty Dufty all the best except for when he plays against us....hope he has a great remainder of the year.
As I have said there is obviously a money stalemate. He will not budge on what we are willing to offer. Market value is quite low as you yourself acknowledge. They would probably rather start from scratch than pay overs. We are already paying good coin for Hunt, Lomax and DeBelin plus we have a few players that clubs won’t be paying the final year in their deal so we don’t really have money for paying overs anymore. If our halves actually did their job ie Sullivan starting and reaching his potential we may not need such an attacking fullback. I personally have seen some good signs from Ramsey. But I’m looking for positives not waiting for a drop to say I told you so. He will get over that just like Rava and his light stepping, flick passes and speed will all come to the fore once he gets confidence using them in first grade. Is he the answer? I don’t know but it’s way too early to rule him out. All the coaching staff have seen something most people on here haven’t so I’ll leave it there. Long story short Dufty is gone, Ramsey is here long term, let’s support him.I'd have him higher than that, but not significantly higher. Draw a line under Nicoll-Klokstad everyone above that is an elite fullback, all the skills. Draw another line above Watene-Zelezniak - everyone below that has serious weaknesses as a fullback. Dufty is in the middle group, which includes players still learning the position or like Dufty do some things brilliantly but still have some shortcomings.
I don't disagree that Walsh and Holmes have far more upside than Dufty, but what's the point? They don't play for us. We won't be signing any of the elite fullbacks. Without Dufty, our only option is to try someone new and hope.
still would love to see him given a chance at 6...sets up many tries for his outsides with his deft touches.....
Seriously? We don't need an attacking fullback? Look at the ladder. All the top 8 sides have attacking fullbacks. Even us.As I have said there is obviously a money stalemate. He will not budge on what we are willing to offer. Market value is quite low as you yourself acknowledge. They would probably rather start from scratch than pay overs. We are already paying good coin for Hunt, Lomax and DeBelin plus we have a few players that clubs won’t be paying the final year in their deal so we don’t really have money for paying overs anymore. If our halves actually did their job ie Sullivan starting and reaching his potential we may not need such an attacking fullback. I personally have seen some good signs from Ramsey. But I’m looking for positives not waiting for a drop to say I told you so. He will get over that just like Rava and his light stepping, flick passes and speed will all come to the fore once he gets confidence using them in first grade. Is he the answer? I don’t know but it’s way too early to rule him out. All the coaching staff have seen something most people on here haven’t so I’ll leave it there. Long story short Dufty is gone, Ramsey is here long term, let’s support him.
Yes the same type of article. All having their guess scratching their head. The club knows that is all that matters for now but one other Small aspect of his game for me which I have been critical is the reluctance in avoiding collision in attack or even willingness to try and burst through tackles and putting his body on the line in defence. In fairness Cody has to improve his attack from the backfield
Cheers Redv13 that is what I meant. It the highest points win "For" Hook has coached a club.Well I clarified it on his behalf.
He's definitely our best 5/8.It’s obvious the club have moved on but a certain No.6 named Lockyer was always crap in defence for the Broncos and Queensland and Bennett always protected him with a production line of good big defenders. Still does the same tactic today for Cody Walker. Dufty isn’t Lockyer but he’s the best attacking player in the team currently.
If I were to break it up into 2 parts, on recent performances in attack I would have Papenhuyzen at 3, Dufty 4 and Tuivasa Scheck 5. In defence Dufty somewhere near the bottom.These are a list of Current Fullbacks in the NRL off the top of my head... Where do people think Dufty Ranks amongst these..
Ie - who is he better than....
Mine are in order
Trbojevic
Tedesco
Tuivasa Scheck
Papenhuyzen
Mitchell
Gutherson
Ponga
Nicoll-Klokstad
Brimson
Hynes
Laurie
Kennedy
Edwards
Allan
Walsh
Holmes
Watene Zelezniak
Hoy
Isaako
I may have missed a few, apologies.
For me - and i'm honestly not being vindictive or smart - he'd sit around Walsh/Holmes.. Walsh is only new and has incredible talent, no doubt will rocket up the charts next year. Ie Walsh has far more upside IMO than Dufty.
I can only rank confidently rank him above Hoy, Isaako, and possibly Watene Zelezniak.
We currently have the best collective quality of fullbacks I can recall. Maybe he does need a positional shift....
It's probably the third game he has won for us this year without him tonight we lose to win you need to score tries who will get them next year when he goes.At least with Dufty attack we get a score to defend. Without him we don’t get points and our defence will need to be near perfect to win a game.
Mills I shudder to think of Norman getting another gig...but your probably right.......decisions of which are some of the reasons we have been dormant for 10 yearsThere has to be more to this than just on field performance.
never understood why he hasn’t had a chance in the 6. What was the risk? It’s bloody Norman in there
he will get another gig.
We need an attacking fullback but if our halves pulled their weight we wouldn’t need him to be out chief playmaker. Playmaking ability is great but not at the expense of the fundamentals. Players like Hynes have a better passing game than Dufty imo, he just isn’t required to carry the attack as the other players all do their part. Also we don’t know if it is Ramsey, he could have an overseas guy, Folau or any number of options we don’t know about. All I’m saying is whoever it is maybe not death ride them so much.Seriously? We don't need an attacking fullback? Look at the ladder. All the top 8 sides have attacking fullbacks. Even us.
It's not obvious to me that it is a money stalemate. Dragons haven't made Dufty an offer. It's not about Dufty not budging, we haven't offered anything. I have no doubt Ramsey will improve. Once he does, what then? We release him for costing too much money and replace him with the next promising junior? Can't see us playing finals footy anytime anytime soon based on that strategy.