Moi Moi Gone.

[eelsta]

He's innocent i tell you INNOCENT:lol:

 

[renouf]

Renouf's logic:

Grothe was targeting Minto
Burt was Targeting Bott
B.Smith was targeting Tate

Wat a drop-kick, tackling someone is not taking them out, its a part of the game.
If barnes couldnt handle the heat he should have never gone into the kitchen.
Hes soft, and perfect for rugby union

yeah and you're a halfwit.

How surprising that Parramatta supporters are only seeing in their way.. infact, did Moi Moi even hit Barnes?!? Nah it was just a slap on the face he'll be right for next week. what a load of crap..

Yeah Carroll targeted Smith a couple of times, but he didn't knock him out

 

[eelsta]

Poor Fui

 

[shiftysmith]

lets settle down people ,but can someone correct me if im wrong but i am sure brad thorn spear tackled grothe in the second half and nothing has been said,talk about the judiciary being a joke

 

[eelsta]

lets settle down people ,but can someone correct me if im wrong but i am sure brad thorn spear tackled grothe in the second half and nothing has been said,talk about the judiciary being a joke

i can't settle down i'm too depressed

 

[shiftysmith]

i just hope we fight it

 

[Mr Saab]

lets settle down people ,but can someone correct me if im wrong but i am sure brad thorn spear tackled grothe in the second half and nothing has been said,talk about the judiciary being a joke

was not a spear tackle at all.
Spear tackle...see Mcdougall on Minichiello.

 

[mickdo]

was not a spear tackle at all.
Spear tackle...see Mcdougall on Minichiello.

The way the judiciary has been policing it he should have been charged.

 

[shiftysmith]

get real mate you do not have to drive them into the ground for it to be deemed a spear tackle,at least if you want to pick the sh*t out of moi moi you have to be able to except the fact that thorns tackle deserved a charge

 

[Mr Saab]

yes you do...
there are many facets to the grading of a dangerous throw.

 

[The Colonel]

Actually the tackle was pulled up because it was regarded as becoming dangerous. Was worthy of a penalty.... nothing more.

 

[Mr Saab]

Actually the tackle was pulled up because it was regarded as becoming dangerous. Was worthy of a penalty.... nothing more.

exactly..

 

[shiftysmith]

you have to b joking so in your eyes unless there head has been drove into the ground its an ok tackle,if they are beyond the horizontial its a dangerous throw its as simple as that.according to you then moi moi can argue barnes was falling

 

[mickdo]

yes you do...

No you don't. There are many facets as you said, but you don't have to commit all of them to be charged.

 

[Mr Saab]

shifty...read post 91

 

[mickdo]

Actually the tackle was pulled up because it was regarded as becoming dangerous. Was worthy of a penalty.... nothing more.

Hey, look I agree. But not according to the judiciary this year!

 

[PJ Marshal]

i lol at all who said he was gonna get off

 

[Hurriflatch]

PJ: Morris has just be charged with a grade 40 bad hair day and will miss the Grand Final

 

[strider]

yeah and you're a halfwit.

How surprising that Parramatta supporters are only seeing in their way.. infact, did Moi Moi even hit Barnes?!? Nah it was just a slap on the face he'll be right for next week. what a load of crap..

Yeah Carroll targeted Smith a couple of times, but he didn't knock him out

Maybe if Tim Smith had of been falling to the ground when he hit him (as Barnes was on BOTH occassions) it would have knocked him out???

 

[shiftysmith]

well said

Maybe if Tim Smith had of been falling to the ground when he hit him (as Barnes was on BOTH occassions) it would have knocked him out???