No.11 said:Renouf's logic:
Grothe was targeting Minto
Burt was Targeting Bott
B.Smith was targeting Tate
Wat a drop-kick, tackling someone is not taking them out, its a part of the game.
If barnes couldnt handle the heat he should have never gone into the kitchen.
Hes soft, and perfect for rugby union
shiftysmith said:lets settle down people ,but can someone correct me if im wrong but i am sure brad thorn spear tackled grothe in the second half and nothing has been said,talk about the judiciary being a joke
shiftysmith said:lets settle down people ,but can someone correct me if im wrong but i am sure brad thorn spear tackled grothe in the second half and nothing has been said,talk about the judiciary being a joke
The way the judiciary has been policing it he should have been charged.Charlie Saab said:was not a spear tackle at all.
Spear tackle...see Mcdougall on Minichiello.
The Colonel said:Actually the tackle was pulled up because it was regarded as becoming dangerous. Was worthy of a penalty.... nothing more.
No you don't. There are many facets as you said, but you don't have to commit all of them to be charged.Charlie Saab said:yes you do...
Hey, look I agree. But not according to the judiciary this year!The Colonel said:Actually the tackle was pulled up because it was regarded as becoming dangerous. Was worthy of a penalty.... nothing more.
renouf said:yeah and you're a halfwit.
How surprising that Parramatta supporters are only seeing in their way.. infact, did Moi Moi even hit Barnes?!? Nah it was just a slap on the face he'll be right for next week. what a load of crap..
Yeah Carroll targeted Smith a couple of times, but he didn't knock him out
strider said:Maybe if Tim Smith had of been falling to the ground when he hit him (as Barnes was on BOTH occassions) it would have knocked him out???