What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

More bad RLWC press coming...

morningstar

Juniors
Messages
826
Surprising that it has taken this long for him to stick the boot in really. The RLWC is not above criticism, but there have been more positives than negatives this year which he has conveniently chosen to ignore in his blog.


A shame this germ has such a platform to voice his opinion, but no one will remember this article in two weeks time. Onwards and upwards.
 

Card Shark

Immortal
Messages
32,237
The only reason this guy gets print space is because people read it and react. I reckon he knows exactly what he is doing.

That is the News Limited method. They should be known as News Unlimited, as they make up as much shit as possible to sell a paper.

I admit I haven't watched a lot of the games due to the timeslots & I forget to watch the replays but what I have seen has been great for the development of the game.

I'd like to see some of the game's new found wealth plowed into the developing nations to continue momentum generated by the World Cup.
 

Danish

Referee
Messages
31,974
The bledisloe competitive?

That must be why its been won in a canter by the same team for over a decade.
 

PARRA_FAN

Coach
Messages
17,356
If he wants to mention floggings, why dont we mention Australia beating Namibia 142-0 at the Rugby "World Cup" or when we smashed the USA in Cricket, of all sports, or how we got smashed by Brazil and France.

Come to think of it, I dont think there were any Americans in the USA cricket team, and he wants to bag Rugby League for too many expats.

Someone should give Rothfield a flogging.
 

morningstar

Juniors
Messages
826
"Response" to Slothfield's article by Andrew Bryan on Nrl.com. Would be great if the NRL could get this circulated in the press quick smart to counter act Slothfield's bile. Even better if they could get some video of the Kangaroos players mentioned talking passionately about the RLWC on the news this week.

http://www.nrl.com/on-tour-why-the-world-cup-matters/tabid/10874/newsid/75430/default.aspx

It's easy to write off the World Cup on one scoreline. Australia 62, USA 0. But to do so is missing the point.
Try telling Cam Smith, Paul Gallen, Greg Inglis and Johnathan Thurston that this World Cup doesn't matter. Or try telling the same to the fans who attend the games or spend hours waiting outside the grounds in the freezing cold after full-time in the hope of getting a photo with one of their heroes.
Maybe they should mention it to the kid Billy Slater sat beside in the stands after leaving the field early in the quarter-final against USA, due to what could in all likelihood be a tournament-ending injury. Billy and the kid watched the rest of the game together side by side. That little boy's name? Billy Slater Leather.
Then there is the young lad in a hoodie who was waiting beside the team bus. He was picked up by big Sam Thaiday and taken onto the team bus because he had somehow missed getting a photo with his favourite player Johnathan Thurston after waiting for over an hour after full-time. Sam carried the boy onto the bus and down the back, grabbed his phone, took a photo of Thurston and the kid smiling together and then safely returned the phone and child to his parent who could not believe what had just happened.
Yes, Australia are expected to make the final and if they do, they will play against one of the other 'big 3' – New Zealand or England. But tell the fans, the players or anyone involved in this World Cup that the games leading up to the semi-finals haven't mattered.
Tell Boyd Cordner and Josh Papalii that their debuts in the famous green and gold jersey do not matter, or brother Brett and Josh Morris that playing together for Australia is meaningless. Tell the young halfback Ryan Brierley from Leigh Centurions that his 30 minutes of one-on-one time with Cooper Cronk talking about how to control a match after Australia had finished training didn't matter.
Maybe mention to the USA Tomahawks that the tournament doesn't matter. Before the game against Australia, the staff talked of the amazing journey and friendships they had forged in the short timeframe of the tournament. They were glowing about their historic win over France in a trial, then their first ever World Cup victory over the Cook Islands, backed up by a 24-16 win over Wales that cemented their place in the knock-out stage of the tournament.
Sure they were predictably beaten by Australia in the quarters, but does that make their achievement any less significant for rugby league? Their motto was 'shock the world', and while they didn't do that against the Kangaroos, their story certainly did get a lot of coverage. The Wiggles released a song about them that has had over 65,000 views on YouTube and gained media attention across all major publications.
The Rugby League World Cup is not perfect – some teams get seven-day turnarounds while other teams play three games in nine days. Sure, there are minnows and there are giants in this World Cup. No-one is denying that. But the same could be said of most sports.
One or two results shouldn't deter from what has been an excellent tournament.
 

Misanthrope

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
47,624
Not a bad response. A little too heavy on the pro-Aussie fapping, but that makes sense given its target audience.
 

Canard

Immortal
Messages
35,189
Why do News keep perpetuating this MYTH that the World Cup will run over 8 weeks!!!

It started on Oct 26 and will finish Nov 30 thats NOT 8 weeks for FFS!!!

All these "records" being broken?? Is anyone even aware of this being an issue or even publicised?? He is essentially insinuating that "sanctity" of old players and records is more important than the development of the game internationally.

"Its shown on 7mate, a channel not many people get???" EVERYONE can get this channel???

And his argument about time difference is baffling, guess what time Wimbeldon, Boxing in Las Vegas, Soccer and Rugby World Cups and the Tour De France are shown?What does he want, the WORLD to change its timezones to suit his TV viewing habits?? Its like an old man shouting at a wall.

There has been no focus on the positive, which for me is Fiji making the semi-Finals with a team laden with Fijian born and/or with Fijian backgrounds.
 
Last edited:

taste2taste

Juniors
Messages
2,007
Excuse my ignorance but could someone explain the Telegraphs agenda?
Every time i open the Tele Rebbecca Wilson or Phil are bagging League.
Maybe its time for the Tele to bring in some fresh new journo's and turf these jaded hacks?
 

taste2taste

Juniors
Messages
2,007
Basketball is the perfect example of how quickly a game can grow.

1992 Olympics USA won gold thrashing teams by an average of 43 points per game.

Only 12 years later in the 2004 Olympics Argentina won gold, Italy silver...and the USA waaaay back in bronze.

Also, it wasn't too long ago the Rugby Union World Cup had 80 point thrashings and every second player had a Kiwi accent.

With a bit of patience and good management Leagues international future is very bright.
 

Evil Homer

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
7,178
Basketball is the perfect example of how quickly a game can grow.

1992 Olympics USA won gold thrashing teams by an average of 43 points per game.

Only 12 years later in the 2004 Olympics Argentina won gold, Italy silver...and the USA waaaay back in bronze.

Also, it wasn't too long ago the Rugby Union World Cup had 80 point thrashings and every second player had a Kiwi accent.

With a bit of patience and good management Leagues international future is very bright.
The Rugby Union World Cup still has 80 point thrashings. 3 scorelines of 80+ at the last RUWC, and another 79-pointer. In total 9 scorelines of 60+ compared to one at the RLWC. To be fair the RUWC played about twice as many matches, but that's still a far higher ratio of blow-out scores.
 

100%green

Juniors
Messages
514
The guy is a moron of the highest order.

It's hilarious that these people don't see what is right in front of them. He would be the type to whinge when League players go to union but then shits on our attempt to grow the game internationally to compete with Union and offer something AFL can't yet.

And really given the history of his beloved Sharks he should watch what he says. If half the negative crap he says was applied to his own team he'd be in a world of hurt!!!
 

taste2taste

Juniors
Messages
2,007
http://www.foxsports.com.au/league/...-joke-tournament/story-fnk3vz4p-1226762494518

"OK, that's it then. GI, can you give JT a hand putting DCE's gear into the bus? Come on the rest of you blokes, hurry up. The plane leaves Heathrow at 8.30; we want to be back home in time for the final episode of The Bachelor. Yeah, yeah Sam I know we've still got two games to go but didn't you hear the news? Buzz Rothfield reckons the World Cup is a farce so they've called it off. Now which of you clowns has hidden Billy's crutches?"

Well why not? According to my esteemed colleague Mr Rothfield this whole Rugby League World Cup thing is a complete waste of time. By racking up big scores against Ireland and the USA the Kangaroos have apparently insulted the great players of the past, such as Immortals Johnny Raper, Reg Gasnier and Graeme Langlands.
As Buzz sees it there is no room in international rugby league for scores such as 50-nil, 62-nil and 50-12 . . . oh hang on, that last one isn't from the current RLWC, it was Australia versus England at Swinton in 1963 featuring Johnny Raper, Reg Gasnier and Graeme Langlands.
Maybe we should have called that game a joke too, instead of lauding it as the Kangaroos' greatest-ever performance.
But let's not confuse the knockers with history. Or facts. The truth of the matter is that the RLWC isn't being held for the sole entertainment of Phil Rothfield or any other dyed in the wool rugby league supporter.
That's what the NRL is for (incidentally Buzz, did you call it a farce when your Sharks beat Manly 68-6 in 2005?). While bragging rights are at stake between Australia, NZ and England the real aim of the tournament is to promote the game, support the "minnows" and, hopefully, garner interest in new markets.


Yes, it is true that the three "home nations" are making up the numbers - a quarter final spot for Ireland, Wales or Scotland is neither here nor there - and many of the Italian players wouldn't know whether Tagliatelle is an opera, a pasta dish or a racehorse, but so what?
The real success stories of this World Cup have been the US, Fiji and Samoa.
We shouldn't be ridiculing the performance of the Americans in the quarter final, we should be praising the fact that they got there - and pushing for a RLWC to be held in the US as soon as possible. And yes Buzz, you could rightly argue that rugby union is the more dominant sport in the Pacific Islands.
All the more reason to get behind the three Islander teams. Take a look at international rugby union Buzz, there are a lot of Sonny Bills, Peteros and FuiFuis running around. The NRL teams might have to prop up the World Cup by releasing their players through the off-season, but that is the cost of expanding their talent pool.
If one Polynesian kid living in Auckland or Sydney is inspired enough by the World Cup to become a Shark, Blue or Roo rather than an All Black or Wallaby doesn't that make it worth the exercise? Let's not forget that the biggest boost rugby union ever had in the Pacific was when Samoa beat Wales and made the quarter-finals of the 1991 Rugby World Cup.
As for the legitimacy of teams like PNG or France going up against the likes of Australia or New Zealand, don't you get it mate? Not all teams competing in England seriously believed they had a chance of winning the World Cup (and that doesn't stop the Sharks chasing the premiership year after painful year does it?).
Some, like the Kumuls, who represent the one nation on earth that calls rugby league its national sport, were just hoping to get on the same paddock as the game's heavyweights.
Like the Socceroos, our minnows of world sport, they want to play against the best and their fans want to see them taking on Thurston, Inglis, Slater, Hayne, Smith and co. Unlike you Buzz, their supporters don't mind getting up early to watch what you call "rubbish".
It is their World Cup as much as yours.
Actually, I take that back. It isn't your World Cup at all. You don't deserve it. Consider yourself BLOCKED

 

jargan83

Coach
Messages
14,916
Rothfield is a moron doing the bidding of his News Ltd masters

A 5 year old could write a better article
 

league13

Juniors
Messages
278
The Rugby Union World Cup still has 80 point thrashings. 3 scorelines of 80+ at the last RUWC, and another 79-pointer. In total 9 scorelines of 60+ compared to one at the RLWC. To be fair the RUWC played about twice as many matches, but that's still a far higher ratio of blow-out scores.



When you take how long the ball is actualy in play at Union these thrashing are a sight worse than in League where the ball is in Play for eighty minutes

The score in the recent All Black v Japs match was 56-0 and there were also a few funny looking Japs on the field.
 
Top