Most over-rated player in the NRL??

[skeepe]

Nathan Hindmarsh. Not as good in defence or attack as he's made out to be.

A dirty little bastard to boot (seriously, count the number of high tackle and dangerous throw penalties against him... you'd be surprised).

 

[lockyno1]

Skeepe, you have got blasted for this one before. Hindmarsh is a superstar in the game and calling him ovverrated is just stupid. He is not rated the best 2nd rower half the time- mason is FFS!

 

[Ron Jeremy]

Nathan Hindmarsh. Not as good in defence or attack as he's made out to be.

A dirty little bastard to boot (seriously, count the number of high tackle and dangerous throw penalties against him... you'd be surprised).

:lol:

40 tackles a game plus 100+ metres in attack, plus SOO and International lol.

When was the last time he was suspended for his dirty antics?

 

[skeepe]

:lol:

40 tackles a game plus 100+ metres in attack, plus SOO and International lol.

Alan Tongue has him covered in defence and attack, and should have equalled him in representation were it not for the ridiculous bias of selectors

When was the last time he was suspended for his dirty antics?

Earlier this year for a dangerous throw I believe. But he's generally a protected species.

 

[Ron Jeremy]

Alan Tongue has him covered in defence and attack, and should have equalled him in representation were it not for the ridiculous bias of selectors

:lol: Really do i even need to answer this. Sorry Tongue is a pimple on the arse compared to Hindmarsh.

Hindmarsh will be considered a great when he retires, Tongue by then will be playing for Goulburn Stockman.

Earlier this year for a dangerous throw I believe. But he's generally a protected species.

Offcourse:lol::lol:

 

[skeepe]

:lol: Really do i even need to answer this. Sorry Tongue is a pimple on the arse compared to Hindmarsh.

Hindmarsh will be considered a great when he retires, Tongue by then will be playing for Goulburn Stockman.

It's really not my fault that it seems Raiders fans are the only good judges of talent.

 

[Ron Jeremy]

It's really not my fault that it seems Raiders fans are the only good judges of talent.

:lol:

Royston Lightning, Jason Bugerelli.....:lol:

 

[skeepe]

Royston Lightning, if he had stayed focussed, would be talked about in the same breath as people like Graeme Langlands, John Raper and Reg Gasnier. Supreme talent, all wasted.

We all knew Bulgarelli was trash. Don't see your point mate.

 

[legend]

Ron Jeremys top 5 is

1. Alan Tongue:Yes he can tackle, show me the stats or whatever, but f**k, it's the only thing he can do. He offers nothing in attack whatsoever...and even if he made 80 tackles a game the Raiders have plenty of young forward depth coming along that will turf this guy into first division then Souths.

For the leading tackler and leading try scorer for all forwards in the NRL, he offers a lot more than nothing in attack IMO.

 

[skeepe]

Can't believe I missed the moustachioed one's post!

Clearly Ron Jeremy did not watch a single Raiders game all last season. Now I may be a little over the top with my praise for Tongue, but that's because he was close to being the best "little" forward in the game this season. He was the top attacking forward, and the amount of times he saved the Raiders' bacon I cannot count.

 

[simon says]

:lol: :lol: At Raider fans.

I knew they would bite.

 

[skeepe]

Just as I knew this thread would be full of people jealous they don't have the great Tongue on their team.

 

[DownUnder]

TC > Tongue.

 

[aids]

Ryles.
Tait.
N. Myles
and i think Kite is very very lucky to be playing rep football, however does nothing wrong at that level.

 

[skeepe]

Bit harsh on Kite there mate, he was a standout for Manly this year.

 

[aids]

i don't think he does anything wrong.
but not in the same league as Bailey, Webke, and at the moment Omeley.

 

[aqua_duck]

Nate Myles-Can't see what's so great about him
Karmichael Hunt-He's a good tough gutsy player but he has many deficiencies in his game

Willie Mason-best front runner in the NRL, the blokje would be the best forward in the world if he had even a double digit IQ

Brian Carney-Great attacking winger, scores heaps of tries but lets in twice as many with his poor reads in defence

Ruben Wiki-I'm a big fan, but he's jut not the player he use to be

 

[Johns Magic]

Alan Tongue has him covered in defence and attack, and should have equalled him in representation were it not for the ridiculous bias of selectors.

Deadset, you're a completely biased f**kwit. No other way to put it.

 

[tbone10]

Menzies owns Tongue

Tongue is sh*thouse compared to the headgeared one. And as for leading try scoring forward...you missed menzies record. Greatest try scoring forward of all time!

 

[skeepe]

Menzies owns Tongue

Tongue is sh*thouse compared to the headgeared one. And as for leading try scoring forward...you missed menzies record. Greatest try scoring forward of all time!

Do the words "season 2006" mean anything to you?

Menzies is nothing like he used to be. Still good, sure, but no longer great.