1. This is News Limited bullshit.
2. It is designed to pit rugby league against its own kind to divide its forces in order to destroy the games bargaining power. If you side with News Limited and/or support such actions you are in effect weakening the game. This isnt about partisanship; this is just a cold hard fact.
3. There would be a lawsuit by the ARLC against any rebel club and the governing body would likely win given that the clubs themselves created the ARLC and endorsed them with independent authority. Any such actions would cost the clubs money in exorbitant legal fees.
4. Cutting out the 4 clubs under the NRLs wings Knights, Tigers, Dragons & Titans would gut support. In fact the whole sniff of a Super League Mark 2 organised under News Limited would have an impact on crowds and fan interest. It will cost the break away clubs even more.
5. The ARLC owns the State of Origin, Australian Kangaroos etc properties.
6. But prior to anything like that occurring which I agree is highly unlikely -- theyd have to be able pass a no-confidence vote which would simply change the management. It would be News Limiteds desire that the new officials be people whom they have a degree of control over. This in effect would be a coup détat. I think this would be News Limiteds desire intent but its also unlikely to happen give what they need to pass the motion.
7. Any new rights deal that breaks the 9 agreement will come with a several legal/financial penalty.
8. A breakaway competition under News Limited influence (via control of commissioners etc) would likely receive a lower broadcast rights deal as theyre taking competitive tension out of the negotiations. It would likely returned to a scenario where the Gallop puppet simply asks News what theyre going to pay and gets told a figure. Ultimately when you consider this and all the legal costs, any action that allows News Limited to gain more influence in the game is going to hurt rugby league.
The NRL best strategy is for the commissioners & upper management to remain silent and instead get all 16 clubs to simply say we support the NRL CEO and the commission and all rumours of a breakaway competition are lies.