Our run to the finals

[ACTPanthers]

Hang on... So because he made the assumption that you are female, something pretty obvious from your name, he's a misogynist..? Well that'll f**king do me...

 

[Copperhead]

and what gives you the right the make such gender biased comments eh ? For all you know Jane the pain might be a bloke.

What makes your opinion better than others. Last time i looked we are all punters.

Well the fact "she" acts like a 15 year old girl with a crush on Nathan whenever his name comes up might have something to do with it.

What makes his opinion better? I think we've seen enough of Janes' posts that that question doesn't even deserve an answer.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Well the fact "she" acts like a 15 year old girl with a crush on Nathan whenever his name comes up might have something to do with it.

What makes his opinion better? I think we've seen enough of Janes' posts that that question doesn't even deserve an answer.

Wow.

 

[OldPanther]

Im glad I make you happy.

I wouldn't worry. Everyone is entitled to have their opinion whether we agree or not. People give out the exact attitude your being accused of.

 

[jane the pain]

Jane, Good on you for not allowing that comment to upset you. As you've probably realised I get frustrated when such comments are made. Sadly that opinion (at times) is not uncommon. Like you I'm a female who has been watching the game since the mid 1960's.

Thanks for your support.

 

[mxlegend99]

Hayne and GI are a lot of other things besides confident and calm. And GI is a very, very confident footballer, moreso than Jarryd Hayne IMO.

Sorry mate but forgive me thinking the kid that has been playing FG since 18 and origin at 20 probably doesn't lack confidence on the footy field.

If he had the type of vision we are talking about he'd have shown us more by now. It took Luai two games to show how great his vision is.

Yeah... because Cleary has never shown vision in his career.

Cleary came in and made the #7 Jersey his own after 1 game as an 18 year old. 2 years after that he has earned the NSW#7 jersey.

Cleary is obviously doing what the coach wants him to do. Or else he would have been dropped or moved from the halves like one of his 7 or 8 halves partners in the 2 years he has been playing.

I guarantee if Luai was a permanent squad member his vision would appear to be gone also when he was forced go play within the limits we clearly set on Cleary and Maloney. Or else he would just be the next of many halves axed by Hook.

In 2 and a half seasons we have had:
Jamie Soward
Peter Wallace
Te Maire Martin
Bryce Cartwright
Tyrone May
Tyronr Peachey
Nathan Cleary
Matt Moylan
Jarome Luai

Cleary since his debut is the only player other than James Maloney not to be dropped or moved from the halves. He does the job his coach wants. When he returned from injury his job in the team had changed. Its not his team anymore.

 

[OldPanther]

Thanks for your support.

It's good to see each other stand together in these tough times.

 

[jane the pain]

Well the fact "she" acts like a 15 year old girl with a crush on Nathan whenever his name comes up might have something to do with it.

What makes his opinion better? I think we've seen enough of Janes' posts that that question doesn't even deserve an answer.

Do you want to play now? Bring it on.

 

[Fangs]

Penrith can't win the 2018 competition without James Maloney.

On the other hand, we can certainly win the 2018 comp without Nathan Cleary.

 

[Fangs]

Do you want to play now? Bring it on.

You go girl!

 

[franklin2323]

Yeah... because Cleary has never shown vision in his career.

Cleary came in and made the #7 Jersey his own after 1 game as an 18 year old. 2 years after that he has earned the NSW#7 jersey.

Cleary is obviously doing what the coach wants him to do. Or else he would have been dropped or moved from the halves like one of his 7 or 8 halves partners in the 2 years he has been playing.

I guarantee if Luai was a permanent squad member his vision would appear to be gone also when he was forced go play within the limits we clearly set on Cleary and Maloney. Or else he would just be the next of many halves axed by Hook.

In 2 and a half seasons we have had:
Jamie Soward
Peter Wallace
Te Maire Martin
Bryce Cartwright
Tyrone May
Tyronr Peachey
Nathan Cleary
Matt Moylan
Jarome Luai

Cleary since his debut is the only player other than James Maloney not to be dropped or moved from the halves. He does the job his coach wants. When he returned from injury his job in the team had changed. Its not his team anymore.

Throw in all the hookers and FB's we have had. No wonder he is playing different

 

[jane the pain]

It's good to see each other stand together in these tough times.

I do not care what other people think of me. I never have, and I never will. Some people on here, do not understand the simple concept that this is a public forum to air our views. No one is right or wrong.

 

[ACTPanthers]

I do not care what other people think of me. I never have, and I never will. Some people on here, do not understand the simple concept that this is a public forum to air our views. No one is right or wrong.

Except anyone who disagrees with you it seems...

 

[OldPanther]

I do not care what other people think of me. I never have, and I never will. Some people on here, do not understand the simple concept that this is a public forum to air our views. No one is right or wrong.

I completely agree. I must have missed something. Betcats is just arguing his opinion. Personally I disagree with him but it was you who first attacked him.

 

[mxlegend99]

Throw in all the hookers and FB's we have had. No wonder he is playing different

His career he has partnered from memory:

Fullbacks:
Moylan
Hardaker
Edwards
Whare
DWZ

Halves:
Soward
Cartwright
Te Maire Martin
Moylan
May
Maloney

Hookers:
Wallace
Rein
Katoa

In 49 games of NRL. Bit different from the combinations most halves get to build and thrive in.

 

[franklin2323]

His career he has partnered from memory:

Fullbacks:
Moylan
Hardaker
Edwards
Whare
DWZ

Halves:
Soward
Cartwright
Te Maire Martin
Moylan
May
Maloney

Hookers:
Wallace
Rein
Katoa

In 49 games of NRL. Bit fifferent from the combinations most halves get to build and thrive in.

No to mention other teams targeting him to shut us down. It is many of the reasons players drop off a bit after season 1

 

[jane the pain]

I completely agree. I must have missed something. Betcats is just arguing his opinion. Personally I disagree with him but it was you who first attacked him.

Except anyone who disagrees with you it seems...

I suggest that you two look up the meaning of the word attack. There was no attack on my part. Lol.

 

[ACTPanthers]

I suggest that you two look up the meaning of the word attack. There was no attack on my part. Lol.

I never used the word attack... But sure, continue to make shit up to suit your argument...

 

[jane the pain]

I never used the word attack... But sure, continue to make shit up to suit your argument...

That was directed at the other person, not you. Go on keep it up. I will will be the adult and move on.

 

[mxlegend99]

Penrith can't win the 2018 competition without James Maloney.

On the other hand, we can certainly win the 2018 comp without Nathan Cleary.

I think we could win with Cleary and Luai/May. Cleary has played with both through the grades.

No way we could win with Maloney and Peachey. Which is the combo Jimmy wanted when Cleary was injured.

Edit
Jimmy + Luai or May could win it also IMO. Just not a combination with Peachey