What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

R2K comment - Kogarah Jubilee Oval is the right venue

_snafu_

Immortal
Messages
37,148

FundyDragon

Bench
Messages
4,248
Sorry guys I ave to agree with fingerbang. As much as Kogarah has improved over the last 5 years it is sadly lacking in many areas.
Even though I have some great memories of it stretching back to 83 it really needs some rose coloured glasses to ignore the fact that it is deficient in facilities, capacity and access.
And R2K, you questioning whether someone is a true St George fan is absolutely ridiculous. It's that sort of BS that makes your 'cause' harder to support.

Slackboy what is Kogarah lacking in?
 

_snafu_

Immortal
Messages
37,148
yes snafu.....those quotes are from after r2k bagged me. Your point?

He didn't bag you. He understandably questioned whether you supported St George by saying:

Clearly you are not a St.George fan (you said in another post that you have never been to Jubilee) and you must have some unresolved issues if your name is fingerbang!

An appropriate response would be something along the lines of "you think what you like, I follow Saints". You followed it with a tirade that was not proportionate with the response.

I must admit, I found your post to be almost troll like and invited a rebuke.

Kogarah is our current and historic home. If you cannot relate to that then what connection do you have to St George?
 

Fingerbang

Bench
Messages
2,587
He didn't bag you. He understandably questioned whether you supported St George by saying:



An appropriate response would be something along the lines of "you think what you like, I follow Saints". You followed it with a tirade that was not proportionate with the response.

I must admit, I found your post to be almost troll like and invited a rebuke.

Kogarah is our current and historic home. If you cannot relate to that then what connection do you have to St George?
Questioning my allegiance because I don't support his cause, or because I have differing opinions on Jubilee Oval, is bagging someone. Does his campaign make him any better a supporter of St George ILLAWARRA Dragons than anyone else?

I couldn't give a f*&k if you found my post gave you tingles in your jollies.
 

Slackboy72

Coach
Messages
12,112
Slackboy what is Kogarah lacking in?
Exactly as I have written, "facilities, capacity and access"
Facilities - food and beverage service, toilets, corporate boxes, etc. They're relatively poor.
Capacity - More the local constabulay's fault but limiting us to 19,000 (or is it 18,500?) when we could have sold 20-25,000 tickets for a 'marquee' match hurts us.
Access - The eternal disadvantage of suburban grounds is always going to be access especially for people who have to drive (i.e. no ready or easy access to rail transport to Carlton). I'm not saying Moore Park is any better though.
The only things it really has going for it is that it is an excellent surface and on Sunday afternoons it has a nice nostalgic atmosphere to it.
For the most (or 2nd most) popular league team in the country it's a real anathema.
Back in the golden era we used to have an astonishing home record at Kogarah.
That's because we were always playing at the SCG.
 

Willow

Assistant Moderator
Messages
109,833
I never said it was, father....just asking Sticks if he feels it is still Kogarah.

That is if Willow allows me to ask the question, or participate in the conversation because my opinion differs from the majority.
lol. Some people are drama queens. Exactly what conversation are you participating in? It's not the subject matter.

Hey, you've had your say. You're anti-Kogarah, we got it.

You got stuck in from the get-go and demanded to be recognised as a minority. We got that too.

So, mission accomplished.
 

Willow

Assistant Moderator
Messages
109,833
Sorry guys I ave to agree with fingerbang. As much as Kogarah has improved over the last 5 years it is sadly lacking in many areas.
It is one of the more pristine suburban home grounds in the NRL. When it comes to facilities, it's better or no worse than anywhere else... and that includes W'gong.

I know people have expectations now, but you can get your creature comforts by paying extra. That applies to any ground, be it Kogarah or Homebush.

The only difference at Homebush is that you won't have to worry about queues because there'll be bugger all people there.
Slackboy72 said:
Even though I have some great memories of it stretching back to 83 it really needs some rose coloured glasses to ignore the fact that it is deficient in facilities, capacity and access.
Didn't you once say that Kogarah is a shithole?

Or words to that effect.
 

Fingerbang

Bench
Messages
2,587
lol. Some people are drama queens. Exactly what conversation are you participating in? It's not the subject matter.

Hey, you've had your say. You're anti-Kogarah, we got it.

You got stuck in from the get-go and demanded to be recognised as a minority. We got that too.

So, mission accomplished.
Cool. Now that is sorted out, you can get back to your knitting baby booties.
 

Willow

Assistant Moderator
Messages
109,833
Fingerbang's drivel had occupied enough space on the thread. Leave it.
You're quite right, of course.

But before we get back on track, please allow me to take a leaf out of snafu's book...
Troll said:
Cool. Now that is sorted out, you can get back to your knitting baby booties.
:lol:
 

FundyDragon

Bench
Messages
4,248
Exactly as I have written, "facilities, capacity and access"
Facilities - food and beverage service, toilets, corporate boxes, etc. They're relatively poor.
Capacity - More the local constabulay's fault but limiting us to 19,000 (or is it 18,500?) when we could have sold 20-25,000 tickets for a 'marquee' match hurts us.
Access - The eternal disadvantage of suburban grounds is always going to be access especially for people who have to drive (i.e. no ready or easy access to rail transport to Carlton). I'm not saying Moore Park is any better though.
The only things it really has going for it is that it is an excellent surface and on Sunday afternoons it has a nice nostalgic atmosphere to it.
For the most (or 2nd most) popular league team in the country it's a real anathema.
Back in the golden era we used to have an astonishing home record at Kogarah.
That's because we were always playing at the SCG.

Thanks Slackboy.

1. Food and beverages agree are below par compared with ANZ. There are limited numbers and limited choice.

2. Toilets I partially agree. The toilets in the northern grandstand are excellent, the one's behind the old scoreboard are 1970's and should be closed. The Hill area or outer ground have access to the toilets behind the grandstand on the far southern end they are excellent. I can't speak for the western grandstand toilets as I have never been there.

3. Corporate boxes I have no experience to comment but I think that would be a given that the ANZ will win that part of the comparison.


Access and transport. 12k crowds no problems, you can park a car reasonably close by. Full crowd and you arrive when I normally do (30min before kickoff) expect a 25 minute walk. I can get closer but I would then spend additional time in my car trying to head south. So it is easier to walk a little more than sit in heavy traffic.
 

Slackboy72

Coach
Messages
12,112
It is one of the more pristine suburban home grounds in the NRL. When it comes to facilities, it's better or no worse than anywhere else... and that includes W'gong.

I know people have expectations now, but you can get your creature comforts by paying extra. That applies to any ground, be it Kogarah or Homebush.
I'm sorry Willow but it's below average whether you pay extra or not.

Didn't you once say that Kogarah is a shithole?
Or words to that effect.

I don't recall using those exact words but I remember when I expressed my disdain for the state the facilities were in in 2005 (which were worse than they are now) it really got a lot of sand in your vajayjay.
 

_snafu_

Immortal
Messages
37,148
Questioning my allegiance because I don't support his cause, or because I have differing opinions on Jubilee Oval, is bagging someone. Does his campaign make him any better a supporter of St George ILLAWARRA Dragons than anyone else?

I couldn't give a f*&k if you found my post gave you tingles in your jollies.

:lol::lol::lol:
 

FundyDragon

Bench
Messages
4,248
It is one of the more pristine suburban home grounds in the NRL. When it comes to facilities, it's better or no worse than anywhere else... and that includes W'gong.

I know people have expectations now, but you can get your creature comforts by paying extra. That applies to any ground, be it Kogarah or Homebush.

The only difference at Homebush is that you won't have to worry about queues because there'll be bugger all people there.

Didn't you once say that Kogarah is a shithole?

Or words to that effect.

Kogarah is in a higher league then w'gong. Grandstand seating is just way to cramped both in the western and northern. It's like being on a 747.
 

Fingerbang

Bench
Messages
2,587
Don't worry about it Fingerbang, some people are not worth arguing with.
Not worried mate. I just think because I don't like Jubilee Oval and choose to not go there, and never liked r2k or supported them.....that it should not put my allegiance to the Dragons in question. As for Willow, hahaha, well, every family has one. I am used to him.
 
Top