What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rate Gareth Widdop

TruSaint

Referee
Messages
20,866
Vas comes from nowhere and posts a 1,00 plus posts very quickly predominantly with the Widdop V Benji crap.

Ruby comes from nowhere and already well on the road to a 1,000 posts also with Widdop bagging as the main theme but no stated love for Benji.

Vas has now also decided to follow Ruby and has cast Benji aside (love is fickle indeed).

Vas has stopped quoting Lennin and Ruby is giving tirades with similar vitriol.

To show that there is no link between them Ruby has consigned Vas (and myself) to the "ignore list".

Vas has in turn let me out of his ignore list and wants to have interaction.

Clumsy effort at best so try pants on even days and dresses on odd days and that will stop the confusion.

:lol:

Gold...
 
V

Vasilevsky

Guest
Highlighting stats that has him leading the try assists (4 next best McCrone with 2) and 2nd on our try scoring list does not support your argument. It suggests a systemic problem from the coachimg ranks. Unless of course you blame him for that too?

Hello BrissyRedV. I remember 3 of Widdop's try assists. He was given a try assist for the Dugan try against Penrith which is absurd. You will say "good early ball" or some nonsense like that but in reality he did what he always does with his passing game, catch and pass to the guy outside him with the enemy defensive line at least 5 meters away. Then there was the try assist vs GC when he kicked and the ball bounced off the posts and right. into JDBs arms. The third I remember is the one last week with the kick. So really he has only had at most 2 try assists in 8 games. His line break assists are probably even worse because kicks don't count. For a playmaker that is absolutely terrible. Astounding he is still in first grade based on those stats.

Vas comes from nowhere and posts a 1,00 plus posts very quickly predominantly with the Widdop V Benji crap.

Ruby comes from nowhere and already well on the road to a 1,000 posts also with Widdop bagging as the main theme but no stated love for Benji.

Vas has now also decided to follow Ruby and has cast Benji aside (love is fickle indeed).

Vas has stopped quoting Lennin and Ruby is giving tirades with similar vitriol.

To show that there is no link between them Ruby has consigned Vas (and myself) to the "ignore list".

Vas has in turn let me out of his ignore list and wants to have interaction.

Clumsy effort at best so try pants on even days and dresses on odd days and that will stop the confusion.

let me go through your idiocy point by point.

What does 1.00 posts mean? Am I not allowed to post here?

I don't give a f##k. BrissyRedV is a decent person but we stand at opposite poles vis-a-vis Widdop. Ruby and you are *******.

If it comes to keeping one of either Benji or Widdop, I am still very much in favor or keeping Benji. He was very good last year but he is spending less and less time on the field. As for "my love for Benji", you still don't see the irony? You are very stupid, aren't you? You are the guy who said the Dragons shouldn't chase Robbie Farah because Widdop may not like it. This is really disturbing. I can't remember the name of the movie but it has Robert DeNiro in it where he is a fanatical baseball supporter focusing on one guy. This is the impression I get with you and Widdop. Of course the major difference is that in the movie the baseball player is a superstar while Widdop most certainly is not.

I stopped because you and I think it was that miscreant "coast dragons", kept raving about it. Saying you don't like it, thinking I am as stupid as you and will thus keep doing it because of my dislike for the two of you. As I told him, if you want me to quote Lenin you must ask and then I will decide to grant your request on a case by case basis.

I never had you on my ignore list.

I'm afraid I have absolutely no idea what you are raving about in your last sentence. I guess it's just that you are mentally unwell so it makes perfect sense to you alone.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Messages
17,551
Hello BrissyRedV. I remember 3 of Widdop's try assists. He was given a try assist for the Dugan try against Penrith which is absurd. You will say "good early ball" or some nonsense like that but in reality he did what he always does with his passing game, catch and pass to the guy outside him with the enemy defensive line at least 5 meters away. Then there was the try assist vs GC when he kicked and the ball bounced off the posts and right. into JDBs arms. The third I remember is the one last week with the kick. So really he has only had at most 2 try assists in 8 games. His line break assists are probably even worse because kicks don't count. For a playmaker that is absolutely terrible. Astounding he is still in first grade based on those stats.



let me go through your idiocy point by point.

What does 1.00 posts mean? Am I not allowed to post here?

I don't give a f##k. BrissyRedV is a decent person but we stand at opposite poles vis-a-vis Widdop. Ruby and you are *******.

If it comes to keeping one of either Benji or Widdop, I am still very much in favor or keeping Benji. He was very good last year but he is spending less and less time on the field. As for "my love for Benji", you still don't see the irony? You are very stupid, aren't you? You are the guy who said the Dragons shouldn't chase Robbie Farah because Widdop may not like it. This is really disturbing. I can't remember the name of the movie but it has Robert DeNiro in it where he is a fanatical baseball supporter focusing on one guy. This is the impression I get with you and Widdop. Of course the major difference is that in the movie the baseball player is a superstar while Widdop most certainly is not.

I stopped because you and I think it was that miscreant "coast dragons", kept raving about it. Saying you don't like it, thinking I am as stupid as you and will thus keep doing it because of my dislike for the two of you. As I told him, if you want me to quote Lenin you must ask and then I will decide to grant your request on a case by case basis.

I never had you on my ignore list.

I'm afraid I have absolutely no idea what you are raving about in your last sentence. I guess it's just that you are mentally unwell so it makes perfect sense to you alone.


At least you aren't wearing a dress this time.
 
V

Vasilevsky

Guest
:lol: if had of known you were going to form my own opinion I would given him a 10 on that basis! If you could only be rational with your arguments and form an unbiased opinion then maybe people would take you seriously. So we assume that if you're deducting 3 from my opinion we can then add 3 to yours which would put Widdop around the 5.5 in your opinion.

Just curiously, who do you rate above Widdop? I mean, we are struggling to score points but the bloke who leads our try assists and is 2nd on our try scoring list is a bloke you thoroughly hate, so who do you rate higher?

On anoyher note, how long will you continue to support the team if say Widdop is siigned long term? It must be tough for you already having your most despised player as our captain?

Deal! You give him a 4 and I give him 5.9:cool:.

Widdop is the main playmaker. He is a crap playmaker. The team struggles to score points most as a result of this fact in my opinion. It's nothing personal. I don't have a personal dislike for him. I rate the whole team higher. He being at the bottom of the 17. Not because he is a really bad player but because he is a really bad playmaker but that is what he is in the team to do.

"If" he is signed long term, which I very much doubt, I will continue to support the team even though for as long as Widdop is the main playmaker, the attack will be crap. I hate the fact he was given the captaincy. Especially given that Dugan wanted it. Who do you think leads by example and would inspire the team? The Broncos game was a classic example. It almost made me feel sick when Boyd ran straight at Widdop and Widdop merely stepped out of the way and slapped Boyd across the face as he went past.
 

Old Timer

Coach
Messages
18,198
Hello BrissyRedV. I remember 3 of Widdop's try assists. He was given a try assist for the Dugan try against Penrith which is absurd. You will say "good early ball" or some nonsense like that but in reality he did what he always does with his passing game, catch and pass to the guy outside him with the enemy defensive line at least 5 meters away. Then there was the try assist vs GC when he kicked and the ball bounced off the posts and right. into JDBs arms. The third I remember is the one last week with the kick. So really he has only had at most 2 try assists in 8 games. His line break assists are probably even worse because kicks don't count. For a playmaker that is absolutely terrible. Astounding he is still in first grade based on those stats.



let me go through your idiocy point by point.

What does 1.00 posts mean? Am I not allowed to post here?

I don't give a f##k. BrissyRedV is a decent person but we stand at opposite poles vis-a-vis Widdop. Ruby and you are *******.

If it comes to keeping one of either Benji or Widdop, I am still very much in favor or keeping Benji. He was very good last year but he is spending less and less time on the field. As for "my love for Benji", you still don't see the irony? You are very stupid, aren't you? You are the guy who said the Dragons shouldn't chase Robbie Farah because Widdop may not like it. This is really disturbing. I can't remember the name of the movie but it has Robert DeNiro in it where he is a fanatical baseball supporter focusing on one guy. This is the impression I get with you and Widdop. Of course the major difference is that in the movie the baseball player is a superstar while Widdop most certainly is not.

I stopped because you and I think it was that miscreant "coast dragons", kept raving about it. Saying you don't like it, thinking I am as stupid as you and will thus keep doing it because of my dislike for the two of you. As I told him, if you want me to quote Lenin you must ask and then I will decide to grant your request on a case by case basis.

I never had you on my ignore list.

I'm afraid I have absolutely no idea what you are raving about in your last sentence. I guess it's just that you are mentally unwell so it makes perfect sense to you alone.

Small typo surely you could work it out 1,000.

Never said you couldn't post actually defended you against the very nasty Ruby.

Please find me the exact wording of what i said about Farrah & Widdop.

The Fan

I am not fanatical on Widdop I just don't agree with your position on him.

Lennin obviously didn't have that many good quotes because you became repetitive.

You did indeed say that you put me on your ignore list.

The last sentence means you should only reply on Mon, Wed , Fri never on weekends and pants suits don't count.
 

BrissyRedV

Bench
Messages
4,383
Deal! You give him a 4 and I give him 5.9:cool:.

Widdop is the main playmaker. He is a crap playmaker. The team struggles to score points most as a result of this fact in my opinion. It's nothing personal. I don't have a personal dislike for him. I rate the whole team higher. He being at the bottom of the 17. Not because he is a really bad player but because he is a really bad playmaker but that is what he is in the team to do.

"If" he is signed long term, which I very much doubt, I will continue to support the team even though for as long as Widdop is the main playmaker, the attack will be crap. I hate the fact he was given the captaincy. Especially given that Dugan wanted it. Who do you think leads by example and would inspire the team? The Broncos game was a classic example. It almost made me feel sick when Boyd ran straight at Widdop and Widdop merely stepped out of the way and slapped Boyd across the face as he went past.

No, he still scores a 7 as I reserve my right to change my score to a 10 and you are now on record giving him a 6. As for the attack, now I see it. You are a vehement Mary supporter who thinks that so long as we complete we do not need an attacking plan.
 
Last edited:

TruSaint

Referee
Messages
20,866
No, he still scores a 7 as I reserve my right to change my score to a 10 and you are now on record giving him a 6. As for the attack, no I see it. You are vehement Mary supporter who thinks that so long as we complete we do not need an attacking plan.

I'd like a few points tomorrow Brissy ;-)

I think we might land a few as well.
 

hazzbeen

Bench
Messages
4,617
I'd like a few points tomorrow Brissy ;-)

I think we might land a few as well.

Hi Tru , Mate Im not sure about this game would love a win and I know we have a good record playing them. They have hit rock bottom and have nothing to loose....
 

BrissyRedV

Bench
Messages
4,383
Hi Tru , Mate Im not sure about this game would love a win and I know we have a good record playing them. They have hit rock bottom and have nothing to loose....

Even with their outs it is a danger game and has me a little worried. With all their outs and last weeks performance we should win comfortable. But as the tigers showed, you can be thrashed by 60 and the next week both teams start from scratch.
 
Last edited:

hazzbeen

Bench
Messages
4,617
Even with their outs it is a danger game and has me a little worried.with all their outs and last weeks performance we should win comfortable. But as the tigers showed, you can be thrashed by 60 and the next week both teams start from scratch,

I hear you mate , hope Im wrong...
 

Old Timer

Coach
Messages
18,198
Hi Tru , Mate Im not sure about this game would love a win and I know we have a good record playing them. They have hit rock bottom and have nothing to loose....

Quite correct Haz and they will have a lot of young kids trying to cement a spot for the rest of the season.

These are the game that we have a habit of dropping albeit our record against them is extremely good.
 

Maximus

Coach
Messages
14,101
Then there was the try assist vs GC when he kicked and the ball bounced off the posts and right. into JDBs arms.

You know that is a skill plenty of halves practice and try to carry out during games right? He didn't hit the post by accident.
 
V

Vasilevsky

Guest
You know that is a skill plenty of halves practice and try to carry out during games right? He didn't hit the post by accident.

Of course. I understand perfectly. But it was sheer luck it bounced right into the arms of JDB.
 

Old Timer

Coach
Messages
18,198
Vas

For all your love of Benji and dislike of Widdop and constant quoting of stats please comment on this.

At Balmain Benji averaged a career of 52.74% win ratio in club games and 66% win ratio in finals and the total outcome was 1 premiership in 11 years and that was a club with a very good playing roster for long periods and a great coach.

For him to be the consummate play maker you rate him to be 1 premiership is hardly a "big haul".

So Widdop has been here for a couple of years with terrible coaches and a crap roster so in the interest of procedural fairness judge him when he has been here 11 years and had some good cattle around him and an upgrade in coaches.

In the meantime STFU about it and stick your statistics where the sun don't shine because they are heavily slanted in 1 direction just as you are.
 
Messages
17,551
Vas

For all your love of Benji and dislike of Widdop and constant quoting of stats please comment on this.

At Balmain Benji averaged a career of 52.74% win ratio in club games and 66% win ratio in finals and the total outcome was 1 premiership in 11 years and that was a club with a very good playing roster for long periods and a great coach.

For him to be the consummate play maker you rate him to be 1 premiership is hardly a "big haul".

So Widdop has been here for a couple of years with terrible coaches and a crap roster so in the interest of procedural fairness judge him when he has been here 11 years and had some good cattle around him and an upgrade in coaches.

In the meantime STFU about it and stick your statistics where the sun don't shine because they are heavily slanted in 1 direction just as you are.

You forgot some pathetically disrespectful supporters. One with multiple personality disorder in particular
 

Old Timer

Coach
Messages
18,198
Thought about including Ruby but as I am in the sin bin there I didn't want her to be tempted to break her vow
 

Latest posts

Top