Rookie of the Year???

[legend]

I think Croker or Dugan. Dugan has been on fire since he came into first grade but Croker really is making a late charge and is the Raiders leading try scorer this year. Not bad for a rookie.

 

[Baldwin]

My pick would be either Jamal Idris, or Joseph Tomane.

 

[legend]

Tomane over Dugan??? You are kidding right?

 

[Baldwin]

Yeah rofl, just thought id say that, its definatly going to be Mortimer... Game over!

 

[Rogue.9]

I'd say Mortimer but I might be a little biased.

 

[Bobby DIGital]

Dugan.....only one who comes close is Croker.

 

[flip]

Dugan

 

[myanonymoususername]

My pick would be either Jamal Idris, or Joseph Tomane.

Won't be Tomane. (a) not as good as some of the others (b) going over to the dark side, the Qld Reds, next year.

 

[lifesgood]

tomane isn't going to the QLD reds he is going to the titans

Its either Idris or Dugan

If Mortimer wins it I wont watch football anymore

Good prospect not desrving of it but.

Croker and gordon desrve it more then him

 

[Perth Tiger]

Won't be Tomane. (a) not as good as some of the others (b) going over to the dark side, the Qld Reds, next year.

That is will chambers who is going to the Reds

Tomane is going to the Titans

 

[Paullyboy]

Dugan comfortably. I think he is the best rookie the NRL has had in years.

 

[SOO]

I think Foran is the best player out of these players mention but i dont think he will get it. Probably Mortimer i would say.

 

[Grail]

Mortimer.
Why?

1. Since he has been in firstgrade, his team has turned around dramatically.
2. He is from a famous family
3. He has been grabbing plenty of headlines and media love
4. He is playing in the halves

 

[Paullyboy]

Mortimer.

Why?

1. Since he has been in firstgrade, his team has turned around dramatically.
2. He is from a famous family
3. He has been grabbing plenty of headlines and media love
4. He is playing in the halves

The last 3 points should have no impact whatsoever on who the rookie of the year is.

 

[Parra Steve]

It'll be between Dugan and Mortimer IMO.

 

[watatank]

Dugan is good but anyone who thinks that he is the best rookie in years gave 2006 and 2007 (arguably) a miss.

 

[Spike]

Daniel Mortimer

 

[legend]

Overall, I think the crop of rookies coming through this year is of the highest quality. It's a testimony to the success of the NYC.

Dugan
Croker
Mead
K Gordon
Idris
Mortimer
Locke
Vidot
Prior
Tomane
Waddell
Thompson
Porter
Ayshford
Wright

 

[Big Pete]

...
McCullough
McGuire
Winterstein
Yow Yeh
Glenn

;-)

 

[Godz Illa]

Prior

Matt Prior played 11 games last year.

Add Trent Merrin to the list though