Round 10 Panthers V Storm

[WestyLife]

When penrith have a win against the storm giving them their heaviest defeat ever. by penrith, couldn't give a shit, that one side of the attack, scored more than the other.

the carryon doom and gloom by a couple of posters is comedy gold. the continal pretendng, and postulating that you know more than the coaching staffs is delusional.

Me i'm happy for the win, enjoying the success of team and the club without this pretentious bull shit.

ps. i've noticed the wannabe coaches are very quiet about luai and cleary tonight.

Control freak.

 

[BossleyPanther]

Did the Storm come out to play? Or does 50% of their spine make them that bad? Cause I do not buy that they played to their potential. All that hype all week and we wrecked them. I wasn't entertained, felt like we were playing the Bulldogs or Warriors.

At least us so called Luai haters can eat humble pie this week, he played a top game.

We're going to really need to fix up the right edge, 3 bombed tries and To'o looking as lonely as Staines our there. Does Crichton know how to pass left to right?

We should win against the Roosters next week. But we should expect Storm to be much improved next time and I do not read into much of last night performance.

 

[Munky]

Did the Storm come out to play? Or does 50% of their spine make them that bad? Cause I do not buy that they played to their potential. All that hype all week and we wrecked them. I wasn't entertained, felt like we were playing the Bulldogs or Warriors.

At least us so called Luai haters can eat humble pie this week, he played a top game.

We're going to really need to fix up the right edge, 3 bombed tries and To'o looking as lonely as Staines our there. Does Crichton know how to pass left to right?

We should win against the Roosters next week. But we should expect Storm to be much improved next time and I do not read into much of last night performance.

The Storm did us just as easily with no Cleary and Yeo last year.

It was probably the game that got Staines dropped later on.

 

[DinkyDi]

 

[WestyLife]

Did the Storm come out to play? Or does 50% of their spine make them that bad? Cause I do not buy that they played to their potential. All that hype all week and we wrecked them. I wasn't entertained, felt like we were playing the Bulldogs or Warriors.

At least us so called Luai haters can eat humble pie this week, he played a top game.

We're going to really need to fix up the right edge, 3 bombed tries and To'o looking as lonely as Staines our there. Does Crichton know how to pass left to right?

We should win against the Roosters next week. But we should expect Storm to be much improved next time and I do not read into much of last night performance.

There are no "Luai haters" only people who didn't like the off the ball penalties.

 

[BossleyPanther]

There are no "Luai haters" only people who didn't like the off the ball penalties.

Yea that's what I mean, and I saw none of that last night. ... Maybe that's cause SBW said he is one of his best players

 

[mxlegend99]

The Storm did us just as easily with no Cleary and Yeo last year.

It was probably the game that got Staines dropped later on.

Hopefully the last 2 weeks get Salmon dropped.

Talk about a waste of a spot. Charlie Staines would offer more in the second row. He's picked for versatility yet this former half stopped the attack everytime he got the ball and something was on. He's a dud. There's a reason he was on the Eels scrap heap.

Throw in Chris Smith. Or better yet bring back Matt Eisenhuth and use either he or Sorensen on an edge.

 

[Iamback]

There are no "Luai haters" only people who didn't like the off the ball penalties.

Again I ask. Who is going to do the niggle? Every side has one. If him doing that allows the rest to do their thing then so be it

 

[Iamback]

Hopefully the last 2 weeks get Salmon dropped.

Talk about a waste of a spot. Charlie Staines would offer more in the second row. He's picked for versatility yet this former half stopped the attack everytime he got the ball and something was on. He's a dud. There's a reason he was on the Eels scrap heap.

Throw in Chris Smith. Or better yet bring back Matt Eisenhuth and use either he or Sorensen on an edge.

Except he played 6 and none of those can do it.

It is the May argument all over again. Need to cover all positions but of course isn't good enough to start or he would be

 

[Iamback]

The Storm did us just as easily with no Cleary and Yeo last year.

It was probably the game that got Staines dropped later on.

Lets look at their top 17

Papenhuyzen
Smith
Jennings
Hughes
Welsch

All out.

That said their edge defence is weak particularly on the right.

The things we did well last night would work if they were full strength. Grant was almost not there
They have a poor kicking game so if we don't make mistakes you can grind them down

 

[Smug Panther]

Except he played 6 and none of those can do it.

It is the May argument all over again. Need to cover all positions but of course isn't good enough to start or he would be

He played it awfully. He's not good enough

 

[WestyLife]

Again I ask. Who is going to do the niggle? Every side has one. If him doing that allows the rest to do their thing then so be it

Like I originally said last week. He needs to play well like against the Storm to get away with it BUT it will cost in close games if he's not careful. Dropping players who aren't involved in the play isn't the kind of niggle that's necessary though.

 

[Iamback]

He played it awfully. He's not good enough

I doubt he trained there though and in that weather. If he wasn't sure and still threw it. It would be worse then dying with the attack

In the 7 minutes he played

he ran for more metres than Harry Grant
More than Toby Sexton in the game before.

Got more forced drop outs than both hell even than Shaun Johnson got in those same conditions.

 

[Iamback]

Like I originally said last week. He needs to play well like against the Storm to get away with it BUT it will cost in close games if he's not careful. Dropping players who aren't involved in the play isn't the kind of niggle that's necessary though.

It is if they start it. Which you don't always see.

teams are going to come for our left because that is key to beating us

 

[martielang]

I doubt he trained there though and in that weather. If he wasn't sure and still threw it. It would be worse then dying with the attack

In the 7 minutes he played

he ran for more metres than Harry Grant
More than Toby Sexton in the game before.

Got more forced drop outs than both hell even than Shaun Johnson got in those same conditions.

Ridiculous the criticism he’s copping. Thought he looked strong with the ball was just isolated - not sure who’s at fault for that tbh.

He doesn’t have a defined role other than being cover for an injury, he’s in a tough spot especially when the vultures were out for him from day dot.

 

[WestyLife]

It is if they start it. Which you don't always see.

teams are going to come for our left because that is key to beating us

As long as he plays like against the Storm it at least balances out.

 

[ColdWetPanther]

Ridiculous the criticism he’s copping. Thought he looked strong with the ball was just isolated - not sure who’s at fault for that tbh.

He doesn’t have a defined role other than being cover for an injury, he’s in a tough spot especially when the vultures were out for him from day dot.

I’m with you Martie; I need to rewatch the game because I didn’t think he was bad.

My take on a small thing he could do would be to play a little deeper though if he is going to play in the halves; give himself a fraction of a second more. But that is a small tweak and (if the coaching staff agree) I am sure will be picked up in the video sessions.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Control freak.

Me a control freak !. .

I'm not the one eternal complaining about this player, or that. Carrying on about mistakes, rather than enjoying ane celebrating a huge win.

Maintaining that you know so much more than the current coaching staffs.

But I'm the control freak.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

I’m with you Martie; I need to rewatch the game because I didn’t think he was bad.

My take on a small thing he could do would be to play a little deeper though if he is going to play in the halves; give himself a fraction of a second more. But that is a small tweak and (if the coaching staff agree) I am sure will be picked up in the video sessions.

So Salmon is the flavour this week, to pull down..........


I appears that everyone has a turn.


(I can't keep up with the level of rage about various players...... ).

 

[ColdWetPanther]

Which player are you referring to Edwards or Luai?

(I can't keep up with the level of rage about various players......

I was thinking about Salmon when I was responding to Martie.