Round 23 Judiciary Charges

[POPEYE]

If the Bulldogs get through this round unscathed by the judiciary it will be a miracle, the big boy bash'n'barge game plan will be fraught with danger . . . not a fan of theirs but strangely enough I hope they confuse the f**k out of the judiciary

 

[NrlCoach]

How is Luke charged with a shoulder charge. FFS he was protecting himself from the incoming collision. Tonight milford did same shoulder charge as matulino

 

[Nice Beaver]

If the Bulldogs get through this round unscathed by the judiciary it will be a miracle, the big boy bash'n'barge game plan will be fraught with danger . . . not a fan of theirs but strangely enough I hope they confuse the f**k out of the judiciary

The Bulldogs have "luck" on their side!

 

[Rabbits20]

How is Luke charged with a shoulder charge. FFS he was protecting himself from the incoming collision. Tonight milford did same shoulder charge as matulino

Souths have bad luck at the judiciary mate, that's why.

 

[Rabbits20]

They'll really miss Luke, not so sure about the other bloke.

We will be right.

Carter to hooker as McInnes is injured.

Sutto to 5/8, I reckon he will be ok to play next week. His hamstring isn't too bad. They'll strap him up he'll be right.

 

[Rabbits20]

The keary shoulder charge was as bullshit a call as Mason's last week.

At least they are being consistent.

Oh, what a bonus for Greenberg that his mob of imbeciles can cite away at the Bulldogs next opponents...

Cheers for your honesty.

Oh well now my teams copped it:crazy::crazy:

I didn't see Issac do a shoulder charge in the match, must have been nothing in it.

 

[Rabbits20]

Yep, Luke's lifting tackle was stupid, and something he does too often unfortunately which is why he'll miss time from loading.

I honest to goodness cannot recall Luke's supposed shoulder charge on Thurston, and given my hatred for all things Souffs that is saying something.

The Keary shot was a definite shoulder charge in the same mold as a Sandow type hit. Illegal under the rules I suppose but f**k me it shouldn't be a penalty and is just insane that he is going to be missing 1 week plus a a heap of carryover points to go with it (meaning ANY charge for the rest of the year is an automatic week).

TBH if I were souths I would almost prefer to have Keary miss 2 weeks and have no carry over points than to miss 1 game but have 75 points hanging over his head. They should risk fighting it

Yeah Issac has technique issues/brain explosions with these lifting tackles. It was dumb of him.

I wonder if the Warriors can fix Issac's tackling issues?

 

[some11]

Wonder if they'll cite Milford, if they're taking a black and white stance then technically he should be.

 

[Rabbits20]

I hope Souths challenge the charge against Keary.

Just to test this new law.

Keary would probably lose.

 

[Rabbits20]

Wonder if they'll cite Milford, if they're taking a black and white stance then technically he should be.

Get a coin out and flip it!

 

[Snappy]

I'd have to see it again but I thought Milf had his other arm partially wrapped.

I think Wallace may cop a charge for a lifting tackle that wasnt even penalised.

 

[Danish]

Yeah Issac has technique issues/brain explosions with these lifting tackles. It was dumb of him.

I wonder if the Warriors can fix Issac's tackling issues?

Its probably been ingrained in him since he was a kid to drive low and lift. To the guys teaching Luke how to tackle when he was 10 the way Luke tackles was textbook.

He has his other brain snaps where he attacks a bloke's leg or goes a chicken wing and all that crap, but his lifting tackles are honestly just something he will always do.

Greg Bird has a similar lifting style which is continually getting him into trouble.

 

[Nice Beaver]

Get a coin out and flip it!

If these idiots are going to stick with this then there is no coin.

Another one on the pile of the NRL idiocy bonfire.

I did not see the incident by the by, but the line of stupidity has been drawn and anything that meets the definition is done.

Kudos Greenberg.

 

[Rabbits20]

If these idiots are going to stick with this then there is no coin.

Another one on the pile of the NRL idiocy bonfire.

I did not see the incident by the by, but the line of stupidity has been drawn and anything that meets the definition is done.

Kudos Greenberg.

Personally I just don't know what the judiciary decide from week to week, they're so inconsistent/clueless and bias etc..............

Well to me it sounds like Milford has to be charged.

 

[BranVan3000]

This is the Issac Luke shoulder charge

http://gfycat.com/CreativeSpryAssassinbug

Lol is this for real?:lol:

 

[POPEYE]

I'm going to stop chastising my grandsons for changing from League to Union . . . can't keep blaming loss of interest in bush footy if that's the way the game is to be played

 

[Snappy]

Lol is this for real?:lol:

No, thats the wrong tackle

 

[Rabbits20]

Lol is this for real?:lol:

I watched it last night and I can't believe he got charged for that.

It's a joke like Mason's was!

Nothing in it.

 

[Rabbits20]

No, thats the wrong tackle

I know.

It's 30seconds after that.

There was nothing wrong with it either.

Issac was preparing to tackle as he had 2 hands out.

Issac then braced himself for some impact as JT kicked the ball.

It wasn't a shoulder charge.

I know you hate Souths but just admit it and don't be bias for once.

If Milford is charged I will admit it's a joke (even though I don't like Brisbane) too because it bloody well is!!!!



I will say though the lifting tackle from Issac wasn't good.

 

[Rabbits20]

Milford and Taukieaho. We will see if they are charged on Monday.