Wouldn't an open age reserve grade comp achieve the same outcome?
It wouldn't just achieve the same outcome; it would be exactly the same thing. ;-)
I guess it is mitigated somewhat by this year's rise in the minimum salary from $55k to $75k. What this means is that second tier players can now earn up to $74 999 (and 99 cents, ME). But the more second tier players that earn this much, the less of them clubs can use. The second tier cap is $375k, so only five merkins on (approx.) $75k could play, and really, how many of them would be on much less than this?
Then again, only us and the Tigers used more than 30 (top 25 plus five second tier) players this year anyway, so my whinge is probably a bit specific to the club:
25 Chooks
27 Souths
28 Storm
28 Manly
29 Sharks
27 Bulldogs
29 Knights
30 Cowboys
30 Titans
30 Panthers
28 Warriors
28 Broncos
30 Raiders
30 Dragons
34 Tigers
31 Eels
I guess $70-odd thousand bucks a year is enough for merkins to live on, especially blokes in their early 20s. What am I f**king whinging about?