What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumoured Targets 3

Messages
2,091
Brooks needs a strong organising half next to him. He absolutely needs to be second banana to play well

Not sure if that fits our team. Clifford isnt an organiser and Clune isn't going to keep his spot over Clifford if we bring in another starting half

Honestly, I'd rather keep the $500k and look for a backrower and a younger half that can organise.
 

Spot On

Coach
Messages
13,902
Why? He is a former Dally M winning halfback. He should be reaching his peak age for a halfback. Has lost none of his skills. Probably bloom under Joey and in an new environment. I don't know of any off field incidents either.

Only problem so far is his lack of effort and caring. Easily things fixable if he comes here.

Would I want him full price? Of course not, but, with the Tigers chipping in, surely we should take him. Clune has been okay but Brooks is rep level when turned on.

If he comes immediately, I would have him at 7 and Milford at 14 for the rest of the season.

Pearce 2.0.
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,201
Said it before... Prior to this season I thought there was hope for Brooks and a change might've done him good.

This year I think he's just happy collecting his pay and doesn't have much else to offer.

We need to target someone with real ambition.
 

Burwood

Bench
Messages
4,990
I wouldn’t read too much into his 2022 form- having twice asked for a release to join the knights in the offseason, Brooks is playing like someone who is trying to force his club’s hand.

Having said that, I don’t think he’s the answer to our current problems.
 

Woosh

Head Moderator
Messages
1,088
Wayne Bennett has lashed the NRL over the treatment of Anthony Milford as the former Broncos $1 million man prepares to arrive in Sydney for contract talks in a desperate bid to resurrect his career.

News Corp can reveal the true cost of Milford’s NRL exile, with the former Queensland Origin star having lost $175,000 in the wake of his legal saga and the Souths contract bungle that left him without pay for six months.

Milford will fly to Sydney over the next 48 hours to ramp-up negotiations with the Knights, who are keen to have the former Bronco in Newcastle colours as soon as possible to bolster their playmaking stocks.

But whether Milford has any fresh contract formally registered remains to be seen, with the NRL integrity unit to begin their own investigation which could extend the 27-year-old’s time on the sidelines.

Milford had three assault charges dropped in a Brisbane court on Monday. Magistrate Robbie Davies said a glowing character reference from NRL super coach Bennett was critical in convincing him Milford’s alcohol-fuelled incident last September was a one-off indiscretion.

As the NRL plays hardball with Milford, Bennett came out swinging, appealing for the veteran of 193 NRL games to be given the green light immediately by ARL Commission boss Peter V’landys and NRL CEO Andrew Abdo.

“I cannot believe it if Anthony isn’t allowed back,” Bennett said.

“Of all the things I have seen in the game and the moments we’ve seen from other players who have offended, I cannot comprehend it if Anthony is not allowed to play NRL in the very near future.

“The courts have cleared Anthony of assault. The criminal justice system has dealt with him. Anthony is a 200-gamer and first-time offender in the NRL. He pleaded guilty to the minor charges (public nuisance and wilful damage) but the courts agreed he was not guilty of assaulting anyone.

“Based on that, I hope he is back in the NRL very soon. I know Anthony won’t offend again.”

With Milford’s Souths deal having collapsed, Newcastle are ready to pounce. Knights hierarchy will have a face-to-face meeting with Milford and his management in the lead-up to their clash against the Dragons on Sunday.

Bennett, who coached Milford between 2015-18 at the Broncos, explained why he provided a character reference for the troubled playmaker.

“I did it because I have known Anthony for a long time and I have faith in him as a person,” Bennett said.

“I didn’t know Anthony to be someone who was a drinker. He now has two children. He is not a guy to be out on the town on the drink all the time.

“I coached him for four years at the Broncos and I also had Anthony in Queensland Emerging Origin squads. I never had a single issue with Anthony. I never had to worry about his off-field behaviour. He is not a problem child. He is not a thug. He does not have a problem with alcohol.

“He is a quietly-spoken, well-mannered young man and I wanted the court to know I was proud of the way he conducts himself.

“That was the Anthony Milford I knew and coached and I saw him in all situations for years, from having drinks off the field, to playing in grand finals and mixing with the fans and his teammates.

“I’ve had a lot of experiences with Anthony and not once did I have to lecture him or pull him into line with his behaviour.

“In all my time in the game, I have never been embarrassed by Anthony’s behaviour.”

 

Old dog

Bench
Messages
2,658
Potentially as a happy player Brookes is a much better prospect than Clifford, Clune, Crossland etc. He isn’t the Cleary, DCE etc but better than what we have playing 7 especially with Clifford at 6.
He desperately needs a change of club, if he just wants to cruise and collect his contract payment then just stay at Tigers if he wants to fire, win games, win a comp then put in.
The top 4-5 teams don’t need him so he will be looking for team 6-8 who he would improve and I think that is us.
Not sure it will happen but he would improve our team if he puts in.
Clune or Brooks, no where or top 4?
 

TooheysNew

Coach
Messages
1,117
Potentially as a happy player Brookes is a much better prospect than Clifford, Clune, Crossland etc. He isn’t the Cleary, DCE etc but better than what we have playing 7 especially with Clifford at 6.
He desperately needs a change of club, if he just wants to cruise and collect his contract payment then just stay at Tigers if he wants to fire, win games, win a comp then put in.
The top 4-5 teams don’t need him so he will be looking for team 6-8 who he would improve and I think that is us.
Not sure it will happen but he would improve our team if he puts in.
Clune or Brooks, no where or top 4?
Committed Clune or half assed brooks? I know which I'd choose.
 

Old dog

Bench
Messages
2,658
Both playing to ability, fit, well and happy Brooks is well in front.
Can Brooks be fit, well and happy, change of club will likely do it
Clune is full of effort but unlikely to win us a title, he is a very good fill in for 1sts
 

TooheysNew

Coach
Messages
1,117
Both playing to ability, fit, well and happy Brooks is well in front.
Can Brooks be fit, well and happy, change of club will likely do it
Clune is full of effort but unlikely to win us a title, he is a very good fill in for 1sts
A lot of ifs in that...
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,201
I know some have brought up his previous years achievements but I’m basing him solely on this year. It’s been very ugly. Speed bump in defense, not really using his kicking game to get tigers out of trouble. Has shrugged the responsibility and let a rookie half be the dominant playmaker etc.

IF the Tigers are paying majority then I’d take him and give him a chance. But I don’t think he’s going to move our needle at all.
 

Sir Galahad

Juniors
Messages
719
it would be great to have a gun half, it would also be great to have a leader. Brookes is none of those but in a good team no doubt more potential than Clune.

For a pie and a coke I'd take him.

I'm excited by the possibilities with Cliff, now he's left the cowgirls I think he will develop nicely
 
Messages
2,091
it would be great to have a gun half, it would also be great to have a leader. Brookes is none of those but in a good team no doubt more potential than Clune.

For a pie and a coke I'd take him.

I'm excited by the possibilities with Cliff, now he's left the cowgirls I think he will develop nicely

We'd be paying at least $500K for Brooks. Not exactly a pie and a coke
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,201
It's a big punt if the risk is he wont even be better than Clune.

We could be using that money to really upgrade other positions of need too.
 

Latest posts

Top