The other forum has a young and enthusiastic moderating crew that really work hard to make sure all topics are covered, but they also make the mistake, IMO, of being too much of forum nazis to kill off all controvery.
This forum has a much more Laissez faire moderating style, which i shouldn't complain about, because i argued long and loud when the forum was being set up for just such a style (along with all the 'founders', who were all in broad agreeance), but i do feel you need moderators with a strong moral compass for this to work, and there are a bloody lot of things that go on here now that are very far from the original concept. Some things are frankly appalling.