Semi Final week 2 Vs Brisbane

[Exsilium]

https://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nr...n/news-story/a45d5656e5b504d1643a85be78bcdd4c

It was play on.

Simple.

We score that try, as subjective as it would be, its play on and we are 6-6

 

[TheEroticGamer]

This game just typified our season, dumb penalties and absolutely appalling attack. Anyone trying to blame the ref for our loss is kidding themselves

If you seriously don't think the refereeing was a significant reason for us losing tonight, then you are completely batshit crazy.

 

[herbert henry1908]

You don't understand, he will be. He is encouraged to run. Same with Ashley Taylor. These two will be champions in there own era, just not yet because they are still in the development stage in their careers.

Moylan will take a load of if he stays.

Yeah I get that you think he will be & if he turns out like that it's awesome.

In the meantime though... we don't have time to waste. That's why we need the right guy next to him.

 

[herbert henry1908]

At Fullback last year he played much the same role in attack.

This year he's certainly been lacking game time but I just can't see why we pin our future on the guy and act like he's the difference between winning and losing.

I honestly dont rate the guy very highly and I accept the criticisms.

I can see that you don't rate him & im not saying he's some superstar or anything,

I'm saying he's our best option right now to compliment Cleary.

Cleary needs someone creative next to him. He also needs someke who has some kicking game. May is neither of those things.

 

[tripster]

Is John Cartwright coming official?

Because all I've seen is a tweet from a nameless Twitter account that is just as reliable as a seedy Kingscross alleyway drug dealer.

You are probably right that it isn't official. I thought I had seen it somewhere official, but when I google I can't now find anything.

 

[Kev07]

You don't understand, he will be. He is encouraged to run. Same with Ashley Taylor. These two will be champions in there own era, just not yet because they are still in the development stage in their careers.

Moylan will take a load of if he stays.

Just listening to those 2 immortals Wally & Joey wrapping May...but hey what would they know?

May is class & will be the 6 next year

 

[chrisD]

If you seriously don't think the refereeing was a significant reason for us losing tonight, then you are completely batshit crazy.

We didn't deserve to win, just as Manly didn't. We are not like them I hope.

 

[tripster]

Did RCG get man of the match in the end (I turned it off after full time, because I couldn't handle hearing Fatty talk absolute crap about "how well Brisbane played" - ffs.

 

[PenrithPanther45]

Yeah that Oates incident is a very touchy subject. Personally, I'm happy with the call. The sound of the collision was very concerning.

 

[OldPanther]

Just listening to those 2 immortals Wally & Joey wrapping May...but hey what would they know?

May is class & will be the 6 next year

May struggles to pass the ball. If he's our 6 we a doomed.

 

[OldPanther]

Yeah that Oates incident is a very touchy subject. Personally, I'm happy with the call. The sound of the collision was very concerning.

We had our chances and didn't make something of them.

 

[Exsilium]

Yeah that Oates incident is a very touchy subject. Personally, I'm happy with the call. The sound of the collision was very concerning.

At that very point we had 31% possession, 0-3 penalty count and hadn't had many chances to do anything. Pretty important point in the game but I hear ya.

 

[Kev07]

May struggles to pass the ball. If he's our 6 we a doomed.

Thanks for your analysis immortal

 

[TheEroticGamer]

Again, I'd have ZERO reason to complain about it if May and Wallace had time stopped for them as well.

But not only was time stopped for Oates, but time was stopped for Thaiday because he had a cramp.So that rules out only stopping play because it was a severe situation.

Hey, it's almost like referees are less intimidated of making decisions against us or something.

Whoops, sorry.Too much logic backed up by facts.I'll start bagging a player who's ex killed herself recently instead.

 

[OldPanther]

Thanks for your analysis immortal

Argument from authority (Latin: argumentum ad verecundiam), also called the appeal to authority, is a common form of argument which leads to a logical fallacy. The appeal to authority relies on an argument of the form:

A is an authority on a particular topic
A says something about that topic
A is probably correct

 

[OldPanther]

Again, I'd have ZERO reason to complain about it if May and Wallace had time stopped for them as well.

But not only was time stopped for Oates, but time was stopped for Thaiday because he had a cramp.So that rules out only stopping play because it was a severe situation.

Hey, it's almost like referees are less intimidated of making decisions against us or something.

Whoops, sorry.Too much logic backed up by facts.I'll start bagging a player who's ex killed herself recently instead.

I don't think it cost us the game and understand the player welfare thing but stopping for Thaiday's menstrual cramps was annoying.

 

[TheEroticGamer]

Penrith player down - let's Brisbane continue upfield with their momentum.

Thaiday down - HE'S CLUTCHING AT HIS VAGINA STOP THE MATCH GOD DAMN IT.

 

[Kev07]

Argument from authority (Latin: argumentum ad verecundiam), also called the appeal to authority, is a common form of argument which leads to a logical fallacy. The appeal to authority relies on an argument of the form:

A is an authority on a particular topic
A says something about that topic
A is probably correct

Appreciate the dictionary web search champion

 

[OldPanther]

Appreciate the dictionary web search champion

Your welcome. I generally stay away from conflict on here but people can see with their own eyes what May is offering at this level and instead of having an opinion you want to hide behind commentators who talk up every new player that comes along. They might have been great players but they hype up young blokes because they get paid to be dramatic. These same blokes called Brooks the next Andrew Johns. Their opinion is crap and I doubt they believe half of what they say.

 

[Kev07]

Your welcome. I generally stay away from conflict on here but people can see with their own eyes what May is offering at this level and instead of having an opinion you want to hide behind commentators who talk up every new player that comes along. They might have been great players but they hype up young blokes because they get paid to be dramatic. These same blokes called Brooks the next Andrew Johns. Their opinion is crap and I doubt they believe half of what they say.

Agree,luckily they haven't compared May to anyone