Should Mary be sacked?

[Minh]

Minh - 2
Objectionable - 0

Not hard to keep a clean sheet against this guy JB.

 

[Ruby]

Not hard to keep a clean sheet against this guy JB.

Oh bull...look at the survey, are you dreaming?

Most do NOT agree with YOU!

Keep spruiking the clubs line why don't you, are you on their payroll?

 

[Minh]

Oh bull...look at the survey, are you dreaming?

Most do NOT agree with YOU!

Keep spruiking the clubs line why don't you, are you on their payroll?

Get over it...

 

[Minh]

I am fine with peeps not agreeing to me, do you think I'm worried?

 

[Dragons 09]

Conviction? Hilarious.

Try stubbornness and stupidity.

Straight Shooter

Lol, i share your view mate, Mary the impostor has to go and my personal opinion is that Minh is in pixie land with his support of Mary. But these are our own opinions, like assholes, we both have them and are entitled to them as are you.

The difference is that i have always admired people who stand by their beliefs as long as they are man enough to concede defeat when proven wrong, and i suspect Minh is just that, but only time will tell i guess.

As for calling him stubborn and stupid, that is hardly an "objective view", it borders on narcissistic tendencies, just saying.

 

[Minh]

Lol, i share your view mate, Mary the impostor has to go and my personal opinion is that Minh is in pixie land with his support of Mary. But these are our own opinions, like assholes, we both have them and are entitled to them as are you.

The difference is that i have always admired people who stand by their beliefs as long as they are man enough to concede defeat when proven wrong, and i suspect Minh is just that, but only time will tell i guess.

As for calling him stubborn and stupid, that is hardly an "objective view", it borders on narcissistic tendencies, just saying.

Lol, I am no staunch Mary supporter, but the hate is ridiculous.

 

[CronullaSaint]

He who dares wins
SAS Motto
There is no evidence our team will improve
We only win against teams who also have problems.
We have a reasonable squad in my opinion.
Coaching appears to be the problem
Do we dare to sack Mary?

 

[Minh]

He who dares wins
SAS Motto
There is no evidence our team will improve
We only win against teams who also have problems.
We have a reasonable squad in my opinion.
Coaching appears to be the problem
Do we dare to sack Mary?

Correct, although I don't think sacking Mary solves anything unless there is a Bennett or a Hasler available. I tipped us to come top 6 this year at the beginning of the year, at the moment we don't look like a top 6 team.

 

[TruSaint]

Im all for Mary moving on and voted accordingly, ... changed my position based on our inability threaten in attack. Its no longer coincidence, our game plan, whatever it is, doesnt work.

However, I would think that such as change, as mentioned by Minh, would be moot if the replacement is of the same ilk.. IE, a novice with little experience. It would be farcical to replace Mary with say a Barrett, or Hornby / Young combo.

If we need to go abroad, so be it.

 

[Smurf]

Hassler / Toovey or Madge
At least the post game interviews would be good
We don't even have that now .

 

[TruSaint]

Hassler / Toovey or Madge
At least the post game interviews would be good
We don't even have that now .

Cant argue with that.

 

[BennyV]

Lol, I am no staunch Mary supporter, but the hate is ridiculous.

Is it though?

Lets look at Marys scorecard:
Longest losing streak in the history of the club.
First time the clubs been held to 0 in consecutive games.
The worst attacking start to a season of ANY club in over 30 years.

The 'hate' (more accurately referred to as a wish for the removal) of Mary is well and truly justified.

Hassler / Toovey or Madge
At least the post game interviews would be good
We don't even have that now .

Toovey doesn't belong in the same category as the other 2.

 

[Dakink]

For me, the game against NZ changed my views. I was firmly in the belief that Mary was the right man for the job and was prepared to give him time to develop the team.

However some of the positional changes and play has swayed me to believe that perhaps he isn't...

 

[Minh]

Is it though?

Lets look at Marys scorecard:
Longest losing streak in the history of the club.
First time the clubs been held to 0 in consecutive games.
The worst attacking start to a season of ANY club in over 30 years.

The 'hate' (more accurately referred to as a wish for the removal) of Mary is well and truly justified.



Toovey doesn't belong in the same category as the other 2.

Referring to guys like OV and to a lesser extent Ruby. I can understand that 99% of the other supporters are frustrated, they have every right to be.

 

[Minh]

For me, the game against NZ changed my views. I was firmly in the belief that Mary was the right man for the job and was prepared to give him time to develop the team.

However some of the positional changes and play has swayed me to believe that perhaps he isn't...

Sort of in the same boat as you. The belief was much stronger two weeks ago, then came the DUI and then the Warriors game....I'll judge him after round 26.

 

[BankstownDragon]

Im very disappointed with the Dimitrou situation.

Signed as attack coach but looking after the cutters.

Up there with the f****ng dumbest decisions ive seen in a while.

Pathetic.

 

[Steve timpson]

Lol, I am no staunch Mary supporter, but the hate is ridiculous.

Its not hate Minh, we want Mary to go, we want Doust to go.

Minh, I see you sitting on the fence with many topics, well, fence sitting brings apathy and acceptance.

Your middle ground attitude, whilst calm and well....middle ground, results in situations like we are in now.

Its reasonable we want Mary to go based on his roughly 44% win ratio, if that.

Not only that, the guy talks so unpassionately, so boring, so mono tone, without being personal I would have to ask.... is he depressed or what?


Time for change, the time is now!

 

[Minh]

Its not hate Minh, we want Mary to go, we want Doust to go.

Minh, I see you sitting on the fence with many topics, well, fence sitting brings apathy and acceptance.

Your middle ground attitude, whilst calm and well....middle ground, results in situations like we are in now.

Its reasonable we want Mary to go based on his roughly 44% win ratio, if that.

Not only that, the guy talks so unpassionately, so boring, so mono tone, without being personal I would have to ask.... is he depressed or what?


Time for change, the time is now!

Point taken Steve, respect your thoughts...I don't even want to pretend I know I have the solution because I don't.

 

[TruSaint]

Its not hate Minh, we want Mary to go, we want Doust to go.

Minh, I see you sitting on the fence with many topics, well, fence sitting brings apathy and acceptance.

Your middle ground attitude, whilst calm and well....middle ground, results in situations like we are in now.

Its reasonable we want Mary to go based on his roughly 44% win ratio, if that.

Not only that, the guy talks so unpassionately, so boring, so mono tone, without being personal I would have to ask.... is he depressed or what?


Time for change, the time is now!

Hmmm,
So fence sitting is being calm, yet brings apathy.

Firstly, he is not a fence sitter, which insinuates not making a call. He has. And has done so for years.

He has called it the way he sees it mate. The good the bad and the ugly sometimes.

Whilst I am in the majority ( now ) that Mary needs to go, I respect Minhs opinion, which is the polar opposite of fence sitting. Giving Mary until years end, without knowing whom will replace him, is not unrealistic.

 

[Fingerbang]

I am with you Minh.....job is his until round 26 at least. I don't want Mary sacked unless someone with outstanding credentials is employed to replace him. Someone like Tony Smith, for instance.

And to the blimpheads who have been giving it to Minh for voicing his opinion.....I daresay his opinion, that Mary sees out this year at least, has a much better chance of being how it is than yours does.