Taylor denied job with Souths

[strider]

u don't know sh*t about the situation JT is in - no f**king clue

 

[Utey]

ffs I think we are going to get lapped by the Tigers.

 

[eelz47]

i think the tigerpies will leave licking their wounds;-)

 

[Avenger]

I think it is a good idea to have anything connected with Brian (coaching wise) be released from the club in 2007.

 

[Utey]

I think it is a good idea to have anything connected with Brian (coaching wise) be released from the club in 2007.

I think thatd leave us more stuffed then we are now. I agree that having dead weight isnt helping, but it seems like Smithy is going there by himself anyways.

 

[coca-cola]

i understand why souths are going after jason taylor though. he would be one of the best players on their team.

 

[PJ Marshal]

lol zing

 

[Eelementary]

u don't know sh*t about the situation JT is in - no f**king clue

And? So what?

He's making things worse for the club by going on like this.

But oh yes - let's praise the guy.

 

[Suitman]

And? So what?

He's making things worse for the club by going on like this.

But oh yes - let's praise the guy.

There are very few of us (if any) who actually know what is happening re JT.

So we should neither praise nor criticise the situation, just comment.

Suity

 

[Eelementary]

There are very few of us (if any) who actually know what is happening re JT.

So we should neither praise nor criticise the situation, just comment.

Suity

Which is exactly what I did. I made a comment on how much I admire him for even thinking about quitting the team given the situation we're currently in.

 

[coca-cola]

give yourself a pat on the back for that.

 

[strider]

And? So what?

He's making things worse for the club by going on like this.

But oh yes - let's praise the guy.

i'm not saying we should praise him - i just think you are being extremely harsh on him (ie "wanker") without any knowledge of the situation

 

[Hellsy]

There are very few of us (if any) who actually know what is happening re JT.

So we should neither praise nor criticise the situation, just comment.

Suity

Exactly.

There is no need to call JT a wanker without knowing what is behind his motivation to ask for a release. There could be many other factors.. money, location, oppotunity for a future head coach position. No-one knows.
JT has shown this club an awful lot of his time and loyalty over the last few years, something is strange for him to ask for a release.. but he is not a wanker because of it

 

[jason taylor]

dontcall me a wanker

 

[MarkInTheStands]

I also just noticed who wrote this article. . .very interesting.

 

[Eelementary]

i'm not saying we should praise him - i just think you are being extremely harsh on him (ie "wanker") without any knowledge of the situation

OK, that's a fair enough point. Perhaps I was a tad too harsh.

I'm just not very impressed with him wanting to leave in the middle of our situation. Next year - sure. He's off contract. But now, when we need him...It's just disappointing.

 

[strider]

OK, that's a fair enough point. Perhaps I was a tad too harsh.

I'm just not very impressed with him wanting to leave in the middle of our situation. Next year - sure. He's off contract. But now, when we need him...It's just disappointing.

but u have no issue with a certain mr lyon .... at least jt is gonna stick by his contract

 

[Eelementary]

True...

But what I don't understand with JT is that he wants to leave us for Souths for the same position. And from everything I understand from South Sydney's point of view, they are interested in keeping Macrae for as long as he wants to be there - meaning JT wouldn't have a shot at First Grade that quickly. May as well stay lol.

I guess we should be used to people walking out or wanting to walk out by now.

 

[strider]

True...

But what I don't understand with JT is that he wants to leave us for Souths for the same position. And from everything I understand from South Sydney's point of view, they are interested in keeping Macrae for as long as he wants to be there - meaning JT wouldn't have a shot at First Grade that quickly. May as well stay lol.

I guess we should be used to people walking out or wanting to walk out by now.

macrae ain't getting them anywhere and (as far as i am aware) they have not given him any long term seal of approval ... it might be the same position right now, but I wouldn't be surprised if there was more to it down the track ... and maybe JT has no security at parra next season - i've read hages is likely to bring in a new mob - is there room for JT?

i think poor JT is in limbo at the moment .... he's done all he can coaching at a lower level (won a PL GF) - needs a path to something higher ... and I'm not prepared to lay sh*t on him for trying to get that when his current position seems like a deadend

 

[Stagger eel]

JT should do whatever he wants to do once his contract is finished at the club, he's a young ambitious coach with a terrific future and whatever he does..all power to him.